Machine Learning and Molecular Simulations Reveal Mechanisms of ZIFs Polymorph Selection

Emilio Méndez, Rocio Semino · 2026

Read Machine Learning and Molecular Simulations Reveal Mechanisms of ZIFs Polymorph Selection by Emilio Méndez, Rocio Semino (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-28106.txt.

Introduction

Méndez and Semino ask why zinc-imidazolate frameworks end up as one crystal form rather than another. Their self-assembly simulations, sorted by neural nets, show early clusters and later glassy middles already vary with the final form. Choice of form thus seems set at the early cluster stage, well before final crystals form.

Catalog record

CREATOREmilio Méndez, Rocio Semino
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE76558
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.28106

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Machine Learning and Molecular Simulations Reveal Mechanisms of ZIFs Polymorph Selection Emilio Méndez, Rocio Semino Abstract Zn(imidazolate) 2 metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) exhibit a remarkable degree of polymorphism. Because of their promising industrial applications, many research groups have investigated phase transitions, phase diagram and relative stability of these polymorphs. There is now wide consensus in the research community that these MOFs are solvothermally formed via non-classical nucleation mechanisms, in which pre-nucleation clusters are first formed, followed by an intermediate amorphous structure that subsequently reorganizes to yield the final crystalline MOF. However, no study up to date has uncovered which part of the synthesis process determines the final polymorph obtained. In this work, path collective variable metadynamics simulations performed with a partially reactive force field give insights into mechanistic and thermodynamic aspects of the self-assembly of these MOFs. Databases of transient and intermediate synthesis structures are built from the simulations. By developing and applying neural network classifiers over these databases, it is found that both pre-nucleation clusters and the amorphous intermediate structures are polymorph-dependent. These results suggest that polymorph selection happens as early as the pre-nucleation cluster stage. † † affiliation: Sorbonne Université, CNRS, Physico-chimie des Electrolytes et Nanosystèmes Interfaciaux, PHENIX, F-75005, Paris, France † † affiliation: Sorbonne Université, CNRS, Physico-chimie des Electrolytes et Nanosystèmes Interfaciaux, PHENIX, F-75005, Paris, France † † email: [email protected] 1 Introduction The 2025 Nobel Prize in Chemistry was awarded for the development of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), fascinating hybrid materials that possess large cavities that confer them sieving, adsorption and nano-reactor properties. MOF cavities can be tuned by varying the metal and ligand building blocks or by post-synthesis modifications, Meek et al. 2010 ; He et al. 2023 making them suitable for solving a wide range of societal challenges, including water harvesting in deserts, Kim et al. 2018 effective drug delivery Osterrieth and Fairen‐Jimenez 2021 and carbon dioxide capture. Mahajan and Lahtinen 2022 Synthesis experts have accumulated decades of experience designing new MOFs for target applications through reticular chemistry principles and interaction-based approaches to choose MOF building blocks. Yaghi et al. 2003 ; Chen et al. 2022 ; Guillerm and Eddaoudi 2021 ; Freund et al. 2021 ; Kalmutzki et al. 2018 ; Jiang et al. 2021 ; Stock and Biswas 2011 ; Guillerm and Maspoch 2019 ; Kitagawa et al. 2022 Machine learning methods applied to databases of successful and failed experiments have allowed us to optimize synthesis parameters to form known MOFs. Moosavi et al. 2019 Large language models and self-driven laboratories have provided immense value by using knowledge accumulated by hundreds of groups over more than three decades to propose synthesis protocols for new MOFs. Zheng et al. 2025 ; Zhao et al. 2025 ; Zheng et al. 2023 But despite all this progress, little is known about how these materials form: on the nature of the intermediate species formed during the synthesis and on the steps that connect their formation and disappearance to yield the synthesis product. The ZIF-8 Park et al. 2006 (Zn(2-methylimidazolate) 2 ) MOF synthesis mechanism has been widely studied in the past two decades by many research groups through a collection of in situ and ex situ experimental techniques. Venna et al. 2010 ; Bustamante et al. 2014 ; Balog et al. 2022 ; Moh et al. 2013 ; Cravillon et al. 2012 ; Jin et al. 2023 ; Talosig et al. 2024 ; Dok et al. 2025 From this body of works, a global picture of ZIF-8 synthesis has emerged: after a transient period, an amorphous intermediate phase is formed, Venna et al. 2010 ; Balog et al. 2022 ; Talosig et al. 2024 ; Dok et al. 2025 which then reorganizes to give the final crystalline MOF. The work by Talosig and coworkers suggests that this amorphous phase is a critical structure-directing precursor, whose composition and local coordination determine the final crystalline polymorph. Talosig et al. 2024 Prior to the formation of the amorphous intermediate, pre-nucleation clusters (PNCs) are formed. Talosig et al. 2024 ; Dok et al. 2025 PNCs are short-lived and small-sized species, which are difficult to characterize by direct experimental measurements. In the past few years, computer simulation works have shed further light into ZIF synthesis mechanisms. Filez et al. 2021 ; Balestra and Semino 2022 ; Balestra et al. 2023 ; Méndez and Semino 2025 ; Gargari and Semino 2025 PNCs and the amorphous intermediate were also observed in silico , Balestra and Semino 2022 and the structure of the amorphous intermediate was found to be synthesis conditions-dependent (temperature and concentration). Gargari and Semino 2025 The synthesis mechanism of ZIFs formed by the combination of Zn 2+ and imidazolate (Im - ) ions was comparatively much less investigated, Méndez and Semino 2025 despite of their rich polymorph landscape. Park et al. 2006 ; Widmer et al. 2019 More than ten Zn(Im) 2 polymorphs exist, which can be obtained by varying synthesis conditions (the main variables are metal-to-ligand ratio and temperature) Park et al. 2006 or by exposing a ZIF-4 MOF to higher temperatures or pressures. Widmer et al. 2019 Computational works performed in our group suggest that the synthesis of this kind of ZIFs proceeds via a similar global mechanism as that of ZIF-8, Méndez and Semino 2025 ; Gargari and Semino 2025 with PNCs that grow and merge to form an amorphous intermediate. In analogy with ZIF-8, it could be postulated that polymorph selection will occur at the level of the amorphous intermediate phase. Talosig et al. 2024 Alternatively, polymorph selection could happen prior to the formation of the amorphous phase, at the elusive PNCs stage, or later on, for example via an Ostwald ripening mechanism. Dok et al. 2025 In this work, we combine computer simulation and machine learning methods to tackle a central question in elucidating the synthesis mechanism of ZIFs: at which stage of the synthesis process does polymorph selection occur? We model the ZIFs through the nb-ZIF-FF partially reactive force field, Balestra and Semino 2022 that has been validated for a wide range of ZIF polymorphs, and we use adaptive path collective variable metadynamics Laio and Parrinello 2002 ; Díaz Leines and Ensing 2012 simulations to obtain a statistically representative set of configurations of both the amorphous intermediates and PNCs for a series of Zn(imidazolate) 2 polymorphs (ZIF-3, ZIF-4, ZIF-6 and ZIF-10, see Figure 1 ). Then, we compare structures associated to different polymorphs employing neural network classifiers, Méndez and Semino 2024 to determine whether they are distinguishable or not. Our results suggest that the structure of PNCs is already polymorph-dependent, thus leading us to hypothesize that polymorph selection occurs at synthesis stages as early as the formation of PNCs, even before the amorphous intermediate is formed. Figure 1 : Equilibrated crystal structures of the four Zn(Im) 2 polymorphs studied in this work, viewed from the XY plane. Ochre vertices and blue edges correspond to Zn and N atoms of the same ligand respectively. For clarity purposes, all other ligand atomic species are not displayed. The yellow circles denote the pores that are used as target structures in Section 2.2. 2 Results We aim to discover in which stage of the self-assembly process occurs polymorph selection for Zn(Im) 2

Read the complete text