Some Properties and Uses of the Species Scale
* · 2026
Read Some Properties and Uses of the Species Scale by * (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27835.txt.
Introduction
Ibáñez summarizes his Corfu contribution in September 2025, on two Species Scale moduli topics. In the first, with Aoufia and Castellano, Wilson coefficients for BPS operators obey Laplace-like eigenvalue equations. This lies at the root of Swampland conjectures on tower damping rates and Distance behaviour. In the second, with Casas, the no-scale moduli potential sums light and heavy tower modes. The Species Scale serves as cut-off. It has desert-point minima, falls exponentially at large moduli, with a de Sitter hill in between.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | * |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44747 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27835
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Some Properties and Uses of the Species Scale * Abstract The ’Species Scale’ has proved to be an important concept when studying consistent effective actions in Quantum Gravity. This is a short summary of my contribution to the Corfu Summer Institute in September 2025, in which I covered two topics, both related in different ways to the fact that the Species Scale is moduli dependent. In the first, based on work done in collaboration with C. Aoufia and A. Castellano, we show how the one-loop Wilson coefficients ℱ n ( d ) {\cal{F}}_{n}^{(d)} multiplyiing BPS protected ℛ 2 n {\cal R}^{2n} operators obey Laplace-like eigenvalue differential equations of the form 𝒟 ℳ 2 ℱ n ( d ) = η d ℱ n ( d ) \mathcal{D}^{2}_{\bf{\cal M}}{\cal{F}}^{(d)}_{n}=\eta_{d}\,{\cal{F}}^{(d)}_{n} . This is true both for n = 2 n=2 with 32 and 16 SUSY generators in 10,9,8 dimensions and theories with 8 SUSY generators in 6,5,4 dimensions ( n = 1 ) (n=1) . We argue that this fact is at the root of some Swampland conjectures put forward in the past, like bounds on the dumping rates for the tower scales and the exponential behaviour in the Swampland Distance Conjecture. For the second topic, based on work done in collaboration with G.F. Casas, we discuss the one loop potential of the no-scale moduli in GKP-like Type IIB 4d orientifolds. To compute this potential we sum both over light and heavy (tower) modes using the Species Scale as a UV cut-off. We find a generic form V 1 − l o o p ∼ g 2 m 3 / 2 2 M p 2 ( g i i ¯ ( ∂ i Λ ) ( ∂ i ¯ Λ ) ) / Λ 2 V_{1-loop}\sim g^{2}m_{3/2}^{2}M_{p}^{2}(g^{i{\bar{i}}}(\partial_{i}\Lambda)(\partial_{\bar{i}}\Lambda))/\Lambda^{2} , with Λ \Lambda the Species Scale. This has minima at the desert points in moduli space and exponentially decreases at large moduli, with a dS hill in between. We argue that this potential may lead to the stabilisation of some or all Kahler moduli at the desert points in 4d Type IIB orientifolds of phenomenological interest. [a,b]Luis E. Ibáñez 1 The Species Scale It seems natural to consider the Planck scale M_{pd} as the scale at which Quantum Gravity (QG) becomes important in a theory of d -dimensions. However since first pointed out by Gia Dvali [ 34 , 33 , 32 ] and collaborators, it has become clear that the notion of QG fundamental scale is slightly more subtle, particularly in the presence of a large number of degrees of freedom N , like those of a KK or string tower, which appear when the moduli go to points at infinite distance. In those limits the Swampland Distance Conjecture (SDC) [ 55 ] states that towers of such particles must exist, with lightest state mass in the tower exponentially dumping, m_{t}\sim m_{0t}exp(-\lambda_{t}\Delta\phi) ,with \Delta\phi some geodesic distance in moduli space. The spectra of towers in string theory takes typically the following general form for the mass of the n -th level state (see e.g. [ 22 , 24 ] ) m_{n}^{2}\ =\ n^{2/p}m_{0}^{2}\ ,\ n=0,...,N\ . (1) Thus, e.g., for a single KK tower one has p=1 and the familiar relation m_{n}^{2}=n^{2}m_{0}^{2} follows. The case p=2 would correspond e.g., to an effective tower for two KK towers. Concerning string towers, although one would also naively say that one has p=2 , it turns out that a more appropriate description is p=\infty since the degeneracy at each level grows like e^{\sqrt{n}} [ 22 , 24 ] . In these singular limits the appropriate QG scale is in general not the Planck scale but rather the Species Scale , [ 34 , 33 , 32 ] , which may be much lower than the Planck scale depending on the number of states N with mass below \Lambda_{QG} . In a perturbative definition for the Species Scale in d-dimensions, it is related to the number of species in a tower N by \Lambda^{d-2}\ \simeq\ \frac{M_{\rm P}^{d-2}}{N}\ . (2) Combining this expression with eq.( 1 ) one can check that the species scale associated to a a given tower mass m_{t} is given by \Lambda_{t}\ \simeq\ m_{t0}^{p/(d-2+p)} (3) in Planck units. This corresponds to a particular direction in moduli space, and along a specific tower of states m_{tn} . This is thus a local definition of Species Scale. Note that the number of species depends on the moduli, N(\phi) , since the masses in the tower are field dependent themselves and so is the number of states below the cut-off \Lambda_{t} . More generally, it is important to realise that the species scale is a function of all the moduli of the theory [ 61 , 63 , 62 , 23 , 6 ] , giving different results depending on the moduli direction. In particular the species scale should be also defined in the bulk of moduli space, not associated to any tower. Clearly, it would be very informative to have a closed expression for \Lambda as a function of the all moduli for any given string vacua. It has been recently realised [ 61 , 63 , 62 , 23 ] that in string vacua with enough SUSY generators one can obtain in some cases explicit expressions for the species scale. Thus if the species scale \Lambda is a UV cut-off, higher dimensional operators in the theory should appear suppressed by powers of \Lambda . Thus an alternative definition to eq.( 2 ) could be obtained by identifying the Wilson coefficients multiplying such higher dimensional operators. Concretely, one can consider BPS protected higher derivative gravitational operators of the general form S_{\rm BPS}\ =\ \frac{1}{2\kappa_{d}^{2}}\int d^{d}x\sqrt{-g}N{\cal F}_{n}^{(d)}\frac{{\cal R}^{2n}}{M_{p;d}^{4n-2}}\ , (4) with n=2 in the case of 32 and 16 supercharges, and n=1 for the case of 8 supercharges, like 4d {\cal N}=2 CY compactifications of Type II string theory. One expects the mass scale controlling these operators to be given by the cut-off of the theory so that one has \Lambda\ \simeq\ M_{{\rm p}}^{(d)}\,{\cal F}_{n}^{-\frac{1}{4n-2}}\ . (5) Thus one can get a field dependent expression over all moduli space if one is able to compute the Wilson coefficients {\cal F}_{n}^{(d)} . This is the case e.g of maximal sugra from Type IIA and Type IIB and their toroidal compactifications [ 42 , 43 , 44 , 58 , 41 , 45 ] . As an example the Wilson coefficient {\cal F}_{2} has been computed from the scattering amplitude involving four gravitons in Type IIB with the general result. S_{R^{4}}^{\text{10d}}=\frac{1}{\ell_{10}^{2}}\int d^{10}x\sqrt{-g}\,E_{3/2}^{sl_{2}}(\tau,\bar{\tau})\,t_{8}t_{8}R^{4}\,. (6) Here t_{8} are standard helicity tensors and E_{3/2}^{sl_{2}} is the non-holomorphic Eisenstein-Maas form of weight 3/2 corresponding to the SL(2,{\bf Z}) duality symmetry of the Type IIB complex dilaton \tau . One can then write for the species scale \Lambda_{IIB}^{6}=1/E_{3/2}^{sl_{2}}(\tau,{\overline{\tau}}) and check that , for large Im\tau , one gets \Lambda_{IIB}\simeq M_{s} . One has analogous expressions (though slightly more cumbersome) for the maximal SUSY theories obtained upon toroidal compactification of M -theory [ 42 , 43 , 44 , 58 , 41 , 45 ] . In the case of 4d {\cal N}=2