Cosmological Tensions as Consistency Conditions for f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) Gravity

Amare Abebe, National Institute for Theoretical, Computational Sciences (NITheCS), South Africa, [email protected] · 2026

Read Cosmological Tensions as Consistency Conditions for f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) Gravity by Amare Abebe, National Institute for Theoretical, Computational Sciences (NITheCS), South Africa, [email protected] (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27773.txt.

Introduction

Abebe treats cosmic tensions as global fit rules on the base model, rather than lone flukes. The fit trio links cosmic growth (H0), structure-growth size (S8), and the redshift link of growth, shown by the growth index. Using f(Q) gravity as a test case, he draws on recent Bayes and motion-system studies of power-law, exponential, and log kinds. While f(Q) models can ease individual tensions, joint fit across all three corners sharply restricts the viable setting space, leaving only a narrow subset in play.

Catalog record

CREATORAmare Abebe, National Institute for Theoretical, Computational Sciences (NITheCS), South Africa, [email protected]
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26108
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27773

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cosmological Tensions as Consistency Conditions for f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) Gravity Amare Abebe, National Institute for Theoretical, Computational Sciences (NITheCS), South Africa, [email protected] Abstract Cosmology has entered a precision era in which discrepancies between independent datasets, most notably the H 0 H_{0} and S 8 S_{8} tensions, have become robust and statistically significant. These tensions are no longer isolated anomalies but increasingly appear as global consistency constraints on the underlying cosmological model, defining what we will refer to here as a consistency triangle of background expansion ( H 0 H_{0} ), structure-growth amplitude ( S 8 S_{8} ), and the redshift-dependence of growth - summarised by the growth index γ \gamma , or equivalently the shape of f ​ σ 8 ​ ( z ) f\sigma_{8}(z) . The third vertex is non-trivial because in modified-gravity scenarios with a redshift-dependent effective gravitational coupling, growth amplitude and growth shape evolve independently, breaking the rigid coupling characteristic of Λ \Lambda CDM. In this work, we use f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) gravity as a test case for this emerging paradigm. By drawing on a focused set of recent Bayesian and dynamical-system analyses of the three best-studied functional families - power-law, exponential, and logarithmic - we show that while f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) models can alleviate individual tensions, the requirement of simultaneous consistency across H 0 H_{0} , S 8 S_{8} and the growth index severely restricts the viable parameter space. A bulk-viscous extension is then briefly examined as a representative illustration of how additional matter-sector freedom is constrained by the same consistency requirement. Our reading of the current literature supports the view that cosmological tensions should be interpreted as global consistency conditions, and that viable extensions of Λ \Lambda CDM must satisfy this multi-probe constraint [ 3 , 6 ] . Within this framework, only a restricted subset of f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) models remains competitive. 1 Cosmology in the Precision-Tension Era The standard \Lambda CDM model has achieved remarkable success in describing the large-scale universe, particularly in its agreement with CMB observations [ 16 ] . However, a growing body of observational evidence now challenges its completeness. The Hubble constant tension is the sharpest such challenge. The early-Universe inference from Planck 2018, H_{0}=67.27\pm 0.60\penalty\ \mathrm{km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}} [ 16 ] , sits in 5 - 6\sigma disagreement with late-universe distance-ladder values around H_{0}\approx 73\penalty\ \mathrm{km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}} , with strong-lensing time delays providing an additional, partly independent late-universe anchor [ 24 ] . The S_{8} tension reveals a related mismatch in the amplitude of structure growth between CMB and weak-lensing surveys, and it is increasingly framed in terms of a suppressed late-time growth index \gamma inconsistent with the \Lambda CDM expectation \gamma\simeq 0.55 . As emphasised in the Corfu meeting report [ 6 ] , cosmology has now firmly entered a precision-tension era , in which these discrepancies are robust features of the data; the hypothesis that they arise purely from unknown systematics is no longer dominant, as also stressed in the CosmoVerse White Paper [ 3 ] . Recent large-scale structure observations further sharpen this picture. DESI DR2 provides high-precision BAO measurements broadly consistent with \Lambda CDM while leaving room for late-time extensions [ 5 ] , whereas joint analyses of ACT, SPT, and Planck CMB-lensing data show strong consistency in structure-growth measurements [ 18 ] . Together, these results impose stringent constraints on any proposed resolution of cosmological tensions. A key conceptual shift has therefore emerged: viable cosmological models must satisfy global consistency across multiple probes, including the expansion history, the present-day amplitude of structure growth, and its redshift-dependence [ 3 , 6 ] . We formalise this requirement below as the consistency triangle - expansion ( H_{0} ), growth amplitude ( S_{8} or \sigma_{8} ), growth shape (encoded in the growth index \gamma or in the redshift-evolution of f\sigma_{8}(z) ) - and use it as the organising principle for the rest of this paper. The three vertices are not redundant: in modified-gravity scenarios with a redshift-dependent effective gravitational coupling, the present-day amplitude of growth and its evolution with redshift respond differently to changes in the underlying theory, so requiring simultaneous consistency at all three vertices is a strictly stronger constraint than requiring consistency at any pair of them. H_{0} Background expansion S_{8} Growth amplitude ( z=0 ) \gamma,\ f\sigma_{8}(z) Growth shape (redshift) A single function f_{Q}(Q(z)) governs all three vertices Figure 1: The cosmological consistency triangle. Any viable cosmological model must simultaneously match three constraints: the background expansion ( H_{0} ), the present-day amplitude of structure growth ( S_{8} or \sigma_{8} ), and the redshift-evolution of growth - encoded in the growth index \gamma or equivalently in the shape of f\sigma_{8}(z) . The three vertices are not independent observational statements , since they are different functionals of the same underlying matter-density field; but in modified-gravity scenarios with a redshift-dependent effective gravitational coupling they become independent constraints on theory . In f(Q) gravity, all three are governed by the single function f_{Q}(Q(z)) : f_{Q}(Q_{0}) controls the present-day growth amplitude through G_{\rm eff}(z=0)=G_{\rm N}/f_{Q}(Q_{0}) , while the full redshift profile f_{Q}(Q(z)) controls the growth shape. 2 f(Q) Gravity as a Test Case of Consistency 2.1 Why f(Q) gravity Modified gravity provides a natural framework for exploring deviations from \Lambda CDM. Among the recently active geometric alternatives, f(Q) gravity - the non-linear extension of the symmetric teleparallel equivalent of General Relativity (STEGR) - has emerged as one of the most versatile frameworks for cosmology. In this class of theories, gravitation is encoded in the non-metricity scalar Q rather than curvature R or torsion T , while the field equations remain second order, which makes the framework technically attractive for model building and data confrontation. Recent reviews emphasise that f(Q) gravity has rapidly developed into a broad research programme spanning late-time acceleration, early-universe dynamics, perturbations, compact objects, and cosmological tensions [ 9 ] . From the point of view of cosmological tensions, the appeal of f(Q) gravity is twofold: it modifies both the background expansion history, which is relevant to the H_{0} discrepancy, and the effective gravitational coupling governing structure formation, which is relevant to the S_{8} and more general growth tensions. Recent dedicated analyses show that some f(Q) models can shift the inferred H_{0} upwards relative to Planck \Lambda CDM, while selected sectors with effectively weakened gravity, G_{\rm eff}<G_{\rm N} , can suppress structure growth enough to move predictions towards weak-lensing-preferred values [ 2 ] . At the same time, DESI-era BAO measurements and CMB-lensing-derived growth measurements make it clear that no proposed modification can be assessed in isolation: viability requires simultaneous consistency of background expansion, growth amplitude, and growth shape [ 3 , 6 , 5 , 18 ] . 2.2 Field equations and the H_{0} - S_{8} link Throughout this paper we adopt the spatially flat FLRW geometry and the coincident gauge , in which the affine-connection coefficients vanish in Cartesian coordinates and the non-metricity scalar reduces to Q=6H^{2} , with H\equiv\dot{a}/a . This choice corresponds to “Connection I” in recent classifications of admissible homogeneous and isotropic connections in f(Q) cosmology; alternative non-coincident branches yield modified dynamics for the same functional form f(Q) [ 1 , 17

Read the complete text