Quantifying the safe operating space for the Amazon rainforest under climate change and deforestation
Jonathan Krönke, Arie Staal, Jonathan F. Donges, Johan Rockström, Nico Wunderling · 2026
Read Quantifying the safe operating space for the Amazon rainforest under climate change and deforestation by Jonathan Krönke, Arie Staal, Jonathan F. Donges, Johan Rockström, Nico Wunderling (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27681.txt.
Introduction
Krönke and four colleagues quantify the Amazon rainforest's safe operating space under warming and deforestation. The forest may tip to savannah between 2 and 6 degrees of warming, while deforestation adds a simultaneous threat that can lower the tipping threshold. Under current conditions of about 1.4 degrees of warming and about 17 percent deforestation, more than a third of the forest is at high risk of crossing thresholds. The authors conclude the forest may already have left its safe operating space, urging climate action and an end to net deforestation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jonathan Krönke, Arie Staal, Jonathan F. Donges, Johan Rockström, Nico Wunderling |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26669 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27681
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantifying the safe operating space for the Amazon rainforest under climate change and deforestation Jonathan Krönke, Arie Staal, Jonathan F. Donges, Johan Rockström, Nico Wunderling Abstract The Amazon rainforest is considered one of the core tipping elements in the climate system with a potential tipping point from rainforest to savannah between 2 and 6 ∘ C of global warming. However, ongoing deforestation constitutes an additional major threat to the Amazon rainforest that acts simultaneously to undermine the stability of the rainforest. Both effects could synergistically compound and lower the overall threshold in global warming and deforestation when tipping points may be crossed. Here, we quantify the safe operating space of the Amazon rainforest, which we define as the joint global warming and deforestation conditions where resilience of the system as a whole is preserved. Based on the underlying environmental data from a global climate model, we use a reduced complexity model and explicitly take into account the adaptive capacities of the forest as well as the atmospheric moisture recycling. We quantify that under current conditions of around 1.4 ∘ 1.4~^{\circ} C of global warming and around 17 % of deforestation, more than a third of the Amazon rainforest is at high risk of crossing critical thresholds. We therefore conclude that the Amazon rainforest may have already left its safe operating space. Furthermore, we find that the historic and projected deforestation pattern could be particularly detrimental. Our results support the need for ambitious climate action to hold the Paris climate target and also nature protection to end net deforestation. The Amazon rainforest is not only the most biodiverse region of the planet holding over 10 % of Earth’s terrestrial biodiversity [ 12 ] , but has also been an important sink for human \mathrm{CO}_{2} emissions, storing over 100 GtC [ 3 , 15 , 23 ] . Global-warming induced water stress in the Amazon due to the decrease of overall water availability as well as an increase in intensity and frequency of droughts [ 8 , 10 ] threatens this regulating capacity of the Earth and it has been found to decline regionally [ 15 ] . Further forest loss would significantly reduce the \mathrm{CO}_{2} uptake capacity of the climate system in addition to a distressing loss of biodiversity. Furthermore, the Amazon rainforest is considered one of the core tipping elements of the climate system [ 3 , 20 ] with a potential tipping point at 2-6~^{\circ} C and 3.5~^{\circ} C as a best estimate [ 3 ] . Earth System Models with and without dynamic vegetation usually do not show one singular tipping point. Instead they show regional-scale forest dieback with varying spatial extent and in different regions [ 43 , 28 , 9 , 24 ] . While the Amazon rainforest constitutes a complex ecosystem with numerous feedbacks [ 13 ] , forest-rainfall interactions are of particular importance and are often discussed in the context of Amazon tipping [ 51 , 6 ] . Around a third of the rainfall in the Amazon basin is recycled partly by moisture transpired from vegetation, typically travelling 100s to 1000s ~\mathrm{km} before raining down again [ 40 ] . This moisture recycling acts primarily along the dominant wind direction from east to west and is particularly strong during the dry season [ 4 , 40 ] . Loss of tree coverage in one region can thus not only significantly reduce the rainfall in remote regions downwind on average, but also intensify the dry season [ 12 ] . Additionally, fire feedbacks can explain observed bimodality of forest and savanna locally ( \sim 1~\mathrm{km} [ 38 ] ) leading to the hypothesis of local (irreversible) tipping initiated by water stress [ 45 , 41 , 17 ] . Insufficient consideration of fire and moisture recycling feedbacks could explain why such irreversible tipping is often not observed in dynamic global vegetation models [ 27 ] . This justifies the need for complementing approaches based on a combination of known key mechanisms and (semi-)empirical data from observations and Earth System Model output. Furthermore, plants are often adapted to their local environmental conditions and it has been suggested that drought impacts will be experienced by plants in relation to the relative departure from their long-term environmental conditions [ 29 , 42 ] . Due to that, the eastern regions of the Amazon with high rainfall seasonality inhabit trees that established deep roots to overcome periods of water stress [ 11 , 33 ] . In addition to global-warming induced water stress, deforestation represents a further human-induced pressure. Large-scale deforestation taking place across the Amazon rainforest [ 37 , 14 , 16 ] reduces atmospheric moisture recycling and undermines its overall resilience. The tipping point for the effects of deforestation has been estimated at 20-25~\% of deforestation together with 1.5-2.0 ~{}^{\circ} C of global warming [ 21 ] . A possible scenario for the Amazon rainforest would thus be: local precipitation reductions from climate change may exceed adaptation thresholds and initiate local forest dieback. This local forest tipping in combination with deforestation reduces precipitation in downstream areas through diminished atmospheric moisture recycling thereby decreasing their resilience or even initiating cascades and a larger scale tipping of the Amazon rainforest [ 51 , 49 ] . The interaction of multiple pressures on the Amazon rainforest demands a combined assessment of its resilience. Among many drivers [ 13 ] , deforestation and precipitation changes due to climate change were identified as major drivers of potential critical transitions in the Amazon rainforest [ 12 ] . A combined assessment under consideration of these two drivers can be viewed as a quantification of the safe operating space of the Amazon rainforest [ 34 ] in analogy to the safe operating space for the whole planet, delineated by the planetary boundaries [ 31 ] . The safe operating space of the Amazon rainforest would be the combined climate change and deforestation conditions where the risk of crossing a larger scale or even system-wide tipping point is low or where dangerous levels of forest loss are not yet reached [ 32 ] , thereby preserving most of the resilience of the Amazon rainforest as a whole. Outside of the safe operating space, resilience losses become detrimental. Determining the boundaries between the safe and dangerous regions is thus key for the limitation of, potentially irreversible, damage to the Amazon rainforest. Following the precautionary principle, individual boundaries of the safe operating space could be set to 2~^{\circ} C and to 20 % deforestation as these correspond to the minima of current tipping point estimation ranges established by [ 12 ] . However, the stress from both drivers occurs simultaneously and interferes via moisture recycling, creating the need for a combined quantification of the safe operating space. Here, we provide such an improved assessment by conducting a safe operating space quantification with explicit consideration of moisture recycling and relate current levels of around 1.4~^{\circ} C of global warming [ 1 ] and around 17 % of forest loss [ 15 ] (mainly by deforestation [ 12 ] ) to that safe operating space. We assess the safe operating space of the Amazon rainforest using a reduced-complexity