Users’ Activity Logs: the Good, the Bad, the Misconception, and the Disastrous
Eman Alashwali · 2026
Read Users’ Activity Logs: the Good, the Bad, the Misconception, and the Disastrous by Eman Alashwali (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27676.txt.
Introduction
Alashwali offers a balanced view of users' activity logs: the good, the bad, misconceptions, and the disastrous. Most prior work stressed the negative side, such as low awareness of privacy controls and privacy concerns about own data. Through a case study of Google's controls, based on interviews with 30 account holders in Saudi Arabia, she sorts views into four themes. The study finds new themes and use cases and closes with practical tips for providers, researchers, experts, and users.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Eman Alashwali |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66011 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27676
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Users’ Activity Logs: the Good, the Bad, the Misconception, and the Disastrous Eman Alashwali Abstract Most service providers, such as Google, save logs from data generated by users while using the service. Many service providers provide users with privacy controls to manage whether, how, and for how long the data is saved and used by the service provider. While most prior studies focused on the negative side of users’ activity logs, such as users’ lack of awareness about the logs’ privacy controls and users’ privacy concerns toward their data, this work aims to provide a balanced view of users’ perceptions regarding activity logs by considering the positive, negative, and extremely negative (hence disastrous) sides, as well as the misconceptions of activity logs. In this work, we present a case study of Google’s Activity controls by conducting a secondary analysis of interview data from 30 Google personal account holders in Saudi Arabia. Using template analysis, we analyzed the data from the lens of four main themes: the good, the bad, the misconception, and the disastrous aspects of users’ activity logs from the users’ perspective. Our findings uncover new themes and use cases, offering a balanced view of users’ perceptions of activity logs, and provide a better understanding and a useful source for subsequent studies on related topics. We conclude with practical recommendations for service providers, privacy researchers and experts, and users alike. keywords security, privacy, policy, settings, data, Google, web, applications 1 Introduction Most web and mobile service providers collect and analyze data generated by users while they use their services, such as users’ search queries, visited locations, and watched videos within a given service. In this paper, we refer to such data as “ activity logs ”. Activity logs contain data that varies in sensitivity by application and data type. For example, intuitively, activity logs of orders in a food delivery application are unlikely to contain surprising or sensitive information to the user. However, with the rapid advancements in the Internet of Things (IoT), smart home devices, behavioral analytics, and personalization, many service providers are now saving unconventional types of activity logs, e.g., saving every search query the user typed in a search engine, or every voice command given to a smart speaker, over a long period of time. Many service providers offer users privacy controls (also known as privacy settings) that allow them to determine whether, how, and for how long their activity logs are saved and used by the service provider. However, these controls are often hidden 32 ; 13 , confusing even for security and privacy experts 24 ; 30 , and have relatively permissive defaults 13 ; 36 . Users who are unaware of default settings and how to adjust them may inadvertently share data 45 ; 46 ; 55 ; 30 , leading to consequences such as embarrassment, bullying, stalking, identity theft, and fraud 31 . Some service providers have been accused of misleading users through privacy setting interfaces. For example, in the US in 2022, Google agreed to a $392 million settlement for misleading users about privacy controls that failed to clearly inform them of the status of the location-tracking setting 39 . Previous work has investigated users’ perceptions and behaviors with respect to privacy controls in various contexts, such as social media 31 ; 18 ; 45 ; 46 ; 33 , smart home devices 48 ; 63 ; 44 , mobile apps 54 ; 21 , and web service providers such as Google 2 ; 20 ; 34 . While most prior studies focused on the negative side of activity logs, such as users’ lack of awareness about privacy controls and users’ privacy concerns about their data, this work aims to provide a broader perspective of users’ perceptions regarding activity logs. Our research aims to answer the following question: what are the positive and negative aspects, and misconceptions about activity logs from the users’ perspective? To answer this question, we conducted a case study on Google’s Activity controls . We qualitatively analyzed interview data from 30 Google personal account holders in Saudi Arabia regarding their views on Google’s Activity controls , which provide users with control over the activity logs that Google saves about them while using Google services. Our work provides a secondary analysis of data obtained from a previous study by Alashwali and Cranor 2 . Nevertheless, the analysis we provide in this work was not covered in 2 , and is an original contribution for this paper. Namely, in 2 , the focus of the analysis was on identifying themes related to users’ awareness, use, preferences, behaviors, and concerns about Google’s Activity controls and the data it collects about them, as well as the steps they take to control Google’s collection or use of this data. This paper complements Alashwali and Cranor’s work 2 by analyzing data from a new perspective, focusing on the positive and negative aspects and misconceptions regarding Google’s Activity controls as a case study of activity logs, from the users’ perspective. See the related work in Section 2.2 for further details about how this work is different from 2 . Our results show that participants identified some positive aspects of Google’s Activity controls , such as saving browsing history and bookmarks, synchronization, security and safety, and parental control. On the other hand, they also identified negative aspects, such as a lack of knowledge of Google’s data practices and the presence of Google’s Activity controls , privacy concerns, and biased web content. Some Google activity logs’ features, such as tailored ads, were controversial, where some participants appreciated them while others did not. We also identified misconceptions among participants, such as confusion between local browsing history and cloud-based activity logs, and between security and privacy measures. Participants also raised serious concerns about Google’s Activity controls , which can lead to serious consequences, such as unauthorized logins and data breaches. The main contribution of this paper is offering a balanced view of users’ perceptions of activity logs and providing a better understanding and a useful source for subsequent studies on related topics. We offer a set of practical recommendations for service providers, security and privacy researchers and experts, and users alike. 2 Background and Related Work In this section, we first describe Google’s Activity controls . We then summarize related work on privacy perceptions and behaviors associated with privacy controls. Finally, we provide a background on the Saudi society and privacy. Before we move to the related work, we need to shed light on the difference between two main types of privacy controls that have been described in the literature 4 : between a user and other users (“ user-to-user ”) and between a user and institution(s) (“ user-to-institution ”). Our study falls into the second category. 2.1 Google’s Activity Controls Google’s Activity controls 1 1 1 Now called Personalisation and activity . 26 , an area inside Google accounts that spans from the Data & personalization 2 2 2 Now called Data and privacy. menu, was introduced in 2016 and then called My Activity 52 ; 20 . It provides Google account holders with control over multiple activity logs while using Google services, namely: the Web &