Fairness for distribution network operations and planning
Pedro F. C. de Carvalho, Zijie Liu, Md Umar Hashmi, and Dirk Van Hertem · 2026
Read Fairness for distribution network operations and planning by Pedro F. C. de Carvalho, Zijie Liu, Md Umar Hashmi, and Dirk Van Hertem (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27669.txt.
Introduction
Pedro de Carvalho and three colleagues review fairness notions and metrics for distribution network planning and operation. Fairness costs efficiency, a loss called the price of fairness, paid for social cohesion through fair outcomes. Locational disparity drives schemes to level the playing field, from egalitarian to merit-based criteria, with math ranging from linear to non-linear programming. The study compiles these notions and metrics, reviews their effects on stakeholders and resource allocation, and aims to support consistent, transparent planning and decisions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pedro F. C. de Carvalho, Zijie Liu, Md Umar Hashmi, and Dirk Van Hertem |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26412 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27669
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fairness for distribution network operations and planning Pedro F. C. de Carvalho, Zijie Liu, Md Umar Hashmi, and Dirk Van Hertem Abstract The incorporation of fairness into the distribution network (DN) planning and operation has become a key goal of recent studies. The cost of implementing fairness, denominated the price of fairness (PoF), covers the efficiency that is renounced for attaining social cohesion through fair outcomes. Locational disparity makes fairness schemes emerge to level the consumers playing field. However, fairness encompasses a range of notions. From egalitarian to merit-based criteria, various metrics are implemented as a tool for measuring equitable utility distribution. These have different mathematical complexities, from linear to non-linear programming cases, which affect their overall applicability. Hence, this study compiles the overarching fairness notions and metrics, reviewing how these affect stakeholders and the inherent mathematical optimisation in resource allocation problems. The aim is to support consistent and transparent planning and decision-making within DN operations. Disclaimer : This paper is a preprint of a paper submitted to and presented at the CIRED 2026 Brussels workshop on Implementing Successful Innovation in Distribution Networks, Belgium. The final version of the paper will be available at CIRED’s website. I Introduction Fairness in distribution network (DN) planning and operations is gaining prominence, yet remains inconsistently defined. Current studies often introduce bespoke indicators and rules, limiting comparability and transparency. Moreover, the trade-off between fairness and efficiency is seldom made explicit. In fact, incorporating notions of fairness in low-voltage (LV) DNs followed the considerable growth in Distributed Energy Resources (DERs) during the last couple of decades. With Photovoltaic (PV) generation swarming both domestic and industrial infrastructure, the grid, originally designed to carry electricity from the producer to the consumer, now faces recurrent bidirectional flows. In order to avoid technical violations, congestion is managed, voltage is controlled, and the Hosting Capacity (HC), the maximum capacity of Distributed Generation (DG) that can be installed [ 14 ] , is assessed. Fairness, more specifically unfairness, becomes an issue as the layout of the grid dictates the outcome of these prevention mechanisms. Nodes farther away from the substation suffer from locational disparity effects, receiving less HC allocation and being overall more prone to curtailments. Thus, due to power network physics, the traditional efficiency-centered resource allocation is insufficient in providing a just solution. Hence, fairness must be integrated into the optimisation problem-solving, ensuring existing disparities are not aggravated by feeder topologies. I-A Literature Review and Gaps Among the reviewed fairness applications in DN optimisation, most studies fall under a small group of umbrella terms: Congestion Management (CM), Hosting Capacity (HC), Local Energy Systems (LESs) and Voltage Regulation (VR). Regarding CM, the framework presented by Liu et al. provides three different schemes, each with its own metric as a fairness proxy. The first focuses on the harvesting quantity, the second on the exports and the third on the net benefit of a given household in order to fairly implement PV curtailment [ 17 ] . Abdolahinia et al. focuses on using Transactive Control Signals (TCSs) in a peer-to-peer (P2P) bi-level framework as a way to influence market participant behavior, tackling recurring DN limitations [ 1 ] . Hernández et al., on the other hand, propose Virtual Power Lines (VPLs) as a tool for managing congestion fairly [ 15 ] . Tackling the complications caused by rapid fluctuations in renewable energy sources, Zhan et al. propose a fairness-incorporated online feedback optimization approach [ 29 ] . Liang et al. recently proposed an innovative aggregation mechanism which, as in [ 1 ] , implements a bi-level model as a way to ensure fairness is guaranteed throughout the process [ 16 ] . While modern HC analysis also deals with load, it is traditionally focused on the maximum grid integration of DG. Rubbers et al. shed light not only on the impact topology has, comparing four different feeders, but also on different fairness notions [ 22 ] . Another example that also contrasts bounded efficiency against a fair HC allocation is Mahmoodi and Blackhall’s HC Envelope study [ 20 ] . In fact, this study adopts one of the proportional performance metrics proposed in [ 17 ] , namely the PV Harvesting index (PHI). Eldridge and He propose an auction mechanism designed to coordinate DN planning by balancing consumer demand with the utility’s need for infrastructure upgrades [ 7 ] . Recent studies enhance existing fairness-aware HC calculations through the use of matrices, either through convex inner approximation approaches [ 2 ] , or through sequential linear optimization methods [ 18 ] . LESs include Energy Communities (ECs), Collective Self-Consumption (CSC) and P2P schemes often involving game-theory concepts. Thus, Abdolahinia et al. also contribute to these efforts by alleviating Transactive Energy Markets (TEMs) [ 1 ] . Soares et al. lay the groundwork on this topic by providing a comprehensive fairness review in LES studies [ 24 ] . For instance, two of the covered papers are [ 4 ] , which uses an ad-hoc fairness metric, and [ 19 ] , which uses the Shapley Value (SV) as the ideal fair distribution to achieve a representative fairness index. Subsequently, Gasca et al. assess both centralized and decentralized frameworks, highlighting the higher systematic economic yield for centralized ones [ 8 ] . Furthermore, Couraud et al. provide not only a thorough description of the CSC process in France, but also a review of the main fairness types relevant to LES [ 6 ] . Transversally, these studies are particularly centered around meritocratic fairness notions [ 24 ] . Finally, [ 17 ] and [ 15 ] also adopt PV curtailment in their frameworks as a VR tool. As some authors propose a distributed framework for fair DER coordination [ 9 , 21 ] , Geerdroodbari et al. focus on a decentralised control strategy approach [ 10 ] . Sun et al. propose a three-stage incentive-based VR strategy, which implements a threshold-based mode selection [ 25 ] . Hashmi et al. evaluate locational disparity effects due to inverter injection rules by proposing a Loss of Consumer Gain (LCG) metric, serving as the fairness proxy in their study [ 13 ] . At last, Gupta and Molzahn not only aim to improve fairness in PV curtailment schemes by proposing feedback-based daily topology reconfigurations [ 12 ] , but also by decomposing existing VR schemes into two groups: one that maximizes an extra fairness objective and another that employs feedback-based weights to promote fairness within the traditional curtailment minimization objective for each PV plant [ 11 ] . Focusing on general optimization (GO), Wei and Bandi examine how to integrate fairness into network flow problems by addressing the price disparities that often emerge from purely cost-focused models [ 28 ] . Chen and Hooker provide one of the most comprehensive guides to formulating fairness in optimization models, covering a plethora of fairness notions, metrics and their respective Social Welfare Functions (SWFs) [ 5 ] . Building on that study’s foundations, in [ 26 ] , Sundar et al. provide a fairness representation for decision-making problems, proposing a novel metric as a solution to some critiques of the metrics presented in [ 5 ] . Hence, the gaps