GREEN PHYSICS-INFORMED MACHINE LEARNING MODELS FOR STRUCTURAL HEALTH MONITORING
Daisy R. Bradley 1, Elizabeth J. Cross 2 · 2026
Read GREEN PHYSICS-INFORMED MACHINE LEARNING MODELS FOR STRUCTURAL HEALTH MONITORING by Daisy R. Bradley 1, Elizabeth J. Cross 2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27638.txt.
Introduction
Bradley and Cross compare black-box and grey-box machine learning models for structural health monitoring through a green lens. Purely data-driven models falter where data from relevant environmental and operating conditions are missing, while grey-box models add an engineer's physical insight about the structure. The authors test whether the strong extrapolation of grey-box models cuts runtimes and thus carbon emissions. They aim for physics-informed models with lower computational cost that keep high performance, shown in a structural health monitoring case study.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daisy R. Bradley 1, Elizabeth J. Cross 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19801 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27638
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
GREEN PHYSICS-INFORMED MACHINE LEARNING MODELS FOR STRUCTURAL HEALTH MONITORING Daisy R. Bradley 1, Elizabeth J. Cross 2 Abstract Machine learning continues to emerge as an important tool to be utilised within structural engineering and structural health monitoring, due to its ability to accurately and quickly perform both regression and classification tasks. However, a purely data driven approach has its limitations, particularly where we lack data from relevant environmental and operational conditions, a situation that has led to the development of physics-informed machine learners for structural health monitoring. These “grey-box” models take into account the physical insight that an engineer would have about the structure they are modelling and have shown promising results in the structural engineering field among many others. This work compares black and grey-box models through a “green” lens, comparing them in terms of their environmental impact, and investigating how the high extrapolative performance of grey-box models can reduce their runtimes and therefore carbon emissions. The authors aim to develop physics-informed models with reduced computational costs, while maintaining high performance, illustrated through a structural health monitoring case study. keywords Physics-informed machine learning, green computing, structural health monitoring, sustainable machine learning \heading Daisy R. Bradley, Elizabeth J. Cross 1 INTRODUCTION It is inevitable that within the engineering community, our use of machine learning (ML) will significantly increase in the coming years. As new models are created, likely to be larger and more powerful than the current state of the art [ 2 ] , the energy demand of engineering ML will increase accordingly, alongside its environmental impact. The computer science research community have published several works on reducing the emissions associated with ML, as discussed below in the literature review. However, within the engineering sector, the majority of research on sustainable ML focuses on implementing ML as a tool to achieve sustainability related goals, rather than the sustainability of models themselves. This work aims to start to address this gap in the literature by exploring the sustainability of ML models within an engineering (structural health monitoring (SHM)) context. In particular, we begin to explore the question of how the environmental impact of a model changes with the addition of physical knowledge, by comparing a purely data driven “black-box” against two physics-informed machine learning (PIML) or “grey-box” models with different levels of integrated physical knowledge. The authors explore the working hypothesis that reduced emissions are possible when the physical knowledge embedded in the model allows a reduction in training data without significantly increasing model complexity. 2 LITERATURE REVIEW Research on the emissions produced by ML models has identified several contributing factors, such as the choice of hardware, the use and power usage effectiveness (PUE) of a data centre, the carbon intensity of the electricity generated to run the model/data centre, and the time taken for the model to run/train [ 19 , 1 , 9 , 16 , 13 , 15 ] . Within the field of sustainable ML, it is well understood that having an awareness of our emissions is the first step to reducing them [ 12 ] and as a result, several packages and programmes have been created to quantify carbon emissions from computing, including CodeCarbon [ 4 ] , which will be used throughout this work to compare models using an estimation of their environmental footprints. There is extensive work in the literature on increasing the efficiency of ML models, though this is rarely solely motivated by environmental factors. In Menghani’s 2023 review, the author categorises efficient techniques into five focus areas: compression techniques, learning techniques, automation, efficient architectures, and infrastructure and hardware [ 18 ] . In large language models (LLMs), some of the most successful techniques include pruning, quantisation, and mixture of expert (MoE) architectures. Many traditional engineering models rely on numerical approaches, where there are a number of means of increasing efficiency (e.g. reduced order and surrogate models). Our focus here is on reducing the burden of ML models employed for engineering tasks where less attention has been given. We look particularly to the field of PIML as a promising field to provide methods with reduced emissions. Physics-informed machine learners are a subcategory of ML models, where physical knowledge is embedded into the black box to create a hybrid grey box. Examples include residual models, hybrid architectures, constrained machine learners, and the popular physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) [ 5 , 10 ] . Some of the benefits of grey-box models compared to their black-box counterparts include increased generalisation, efficiency and interpretability [ 17 ] . Although PIML models have received much attention in the literature, this is the first work to introduce physics knowledge into a model with the intention of reducing its environmental footprint. As an initial study on the topic, we develop and demonstrate a very simple set of test cases, using a Gaussian Process (GP) model structure that can be easily interpreted and interrogated. We choose GPs for this initial study not because of their heavy computational burden (the examples here are in fact particularly light), but because they provide a framework where physics can be embedded in multiple different ways without changing the model architecture [ 6 ] , providing a direct means of comparing emissions with varying levels of embedded physics. 3 TEST CASES It is well known that grey-box models often require less training data than black-box models, especially in extrapolative scenarios. This is demonstrated in Figure 1 for a generated surface, where a black-box model (a standard GP regression) is unable to perform adequately outside of its training set, whereas the grey-box model (with insight embedded in a kernel) achieves a far better performance with the same training data. (a) Black-1 - NMSE 72.1 (b) (c) Grey-2 - NMSE 2.92 Figure 1: The performance of black-box and grey-box models with 20% training data coverage, where NMSE is a normalised mean squared error Although the requirement for training data often decreases when embedding physics into a model, model complexity often increases in return, creating a complex relationship between the amount of physics and the training time (hence energy consumption and emissions) of a model. The surface seen in Figure 1, and defined by Equation 1, is a very simple “toy-box” test case, which was used as a starting point to explore this trade-off. \displaystyle y=\sqrt{|x_{2}|}\,\sin\!\left(4\,x_{1}\right) (1) To explore emissions, three GP models were designed with various “greyness”, where the embedded information/knowledge concerns the periodicity of the surface. The first model, Black-1, is a commonly used black-box GP regression, with a constant mean function and a squared exponential (SE) covariance function (kernel), which is defined in Equation 2. This kernel consists of two hyperparameters, length-scale ( l ) and output variance ( \sigma^{2} ), hence Black-1 has a total of four hyperparameters to learn - two from the kernel, the mean, and the observation noise. For all models, learning is achieved by maximising the marginal likelihood [ 20 ] . \displaystyle k_{SE}(x,x^{\prime})=\sigma^{2}exp(-\frac{(x-x^{\prime})^{2}}{2l^{2}}) (2) The two grey-box models also use a constant mean function, but differ to Black-1 by multiplying the SE kernel by a periodic kernel, outlined in Equation 3, which we use as our physics knowledge proxy. \displaystyle k_{Per}(x,x^{\prime})=\sigma^{2}exp(-\frac{2sin^{2}(\pi|x-x^{\prime}|/p)}{l^{2}}) (3) The periodic kernel consists of 3 hyperparameters