Empire Amplifier: Uncovering and Contesting the Prioritization of Colonial Content on Platforms Through Community-Informed Algorithmic Auditing * DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Journal: PACMHCI ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Social and professional topics Geographic characteristics
Nel Escher, Bakyt Yrysov, Ashley McDermott, Daniel Chechelnitsky, Hermela Berehan Benyam, Nikola Banovic · 2026
Read Empire Amplifier: Uncovering and Contesting the Prioritization of Colonial Content on Platforms Through Community-Informed Algorithmic Auditing * DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Journal: PACMHCI ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Social and professional topics Geographic characteristics by Nel Escher, Bakyt Yrysov, Ashley McDermott, Daniel Chechelnitsky, Hermela Berehan Benyam, Nikola Banovic (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27498.txt.
Introduction
Escher and five colleagues audit how YouTube recommendations affect Kyrgyz children, whose caregivers fear the platform pushes Russian over Kyrgyz, their heritage language. Working with the community, they measure how recommendations rank languages for child users, Indigenous versus others. Their results back caregiver worries: Kyrgyz children mostly get non-Kyrgyz recommendations from YouTube, even when they flag a Kyrgyz preference. They test practices that reduce Russian recommendations, such as device sharing across generations, and argue platforms can amplify colonial influence rather than revitalize Indigenous heritage.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nel Escher, Bakyt Yrysov, Ashley McDermott, Daniel Chechelnitsky, Hermela Berehan Benyam, Nikola Banovic |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 101579 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27498
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Empire Amplifier: Uncovering and Contesting the Prioritization of Colonial Content on Platforms Through Community-Informed Algorithmic Auditing * DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Journal: PACMHCI ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Social and professional topics Geographic characteristics Nel Escher, Bakyt Yrysov, Ashley McDermott, Daniel Chechelnitsky, Hermela Berehan Benyam, Nikola Banovic Abstract . Though online platforms claim to amplify Indigenous voices, Indigenous communities are worried that these systems are instead eroding their language and culture. We conduct a community-informed algorithmic audit to explore whether online platforms sustain or endanger Indigenous cultural practice. First, we review ethnographic research pertaining to the cultural anxieties of a specific Indigenous community, as Indigenous peoples are not a monolith. We consider concerns from Kyrgyz communities who believe that platforms are expanding Russia’s linguistic influence and threatening their language. Next, we construct and conduct an algorithmic audit in conversation with the community. Our audit investigates deep-seated fears among Kyrgyz caregivers that YouTube encourages their children to speak Russian instead of Kyrgyz, their heritage language. We measure how the YouTube recommendation algorithm prioritizes content across Indigenous and non-Indigenous languages for child users. Our results validate caregiver concerns, as we find that YouTube primarily recommends non-Kyrgyz content to Kyrgyz children, even when children signal clear preferences for Kyrgyz content. Thus, platform recommendations reinforce Kyrgyz children’s offline uptake of colonial language ideologies. Finally, we evaluate strategies to align platform behavior with Indigenous values. We identify effective end-user practices for reducing the proportion of Russian-language YouTube recommendations, like cross-generational device sharing. Overall, our work uncovers how platforms can amplify colonial influence, rather than revitalizing Indigenous cultural heritage. We encourage researchers to consider how algorithmic systems can reimpose oppressive power structures that decolonial efforts have sought to dismantle. * * footnotetext: Accepted to the 2026 ACM Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing (CSCW ’26). 1. Introduction Social media platforms claim that they amplify Indigenous voices and incorporate marginalized values ( 136 ; 93 ; 61 ) . Scholars have supported this view, optimistically hailing platforms as a resource for preserving Indigenous cultural heritage ( 23 ; 99 ; 148 ) . They point to online language reclamation projects such as the Chickasaw Word of the Day account on Twitter ( 26 ) , videos on TikTok promoting the heritage language and dress of minority language speakers in China ( 148 ) , and Facebook archives dedicated to sharing historical records in endangered South Asian languages ( 23 ) among many others. Proponents assume that online platforms connect members of endangered language communities and expand their domains of use ( 26 ) . However, Indigenous communities are concerned that online platforms are instead eroding their language and culture ( 19 ; 125 ; 101 ) . In contrast with academic enthusiasm for language revitalization content on social media ( 23 ; 26 ; 99 ; 148 ) , Indigenous people worry that these systems cause their children to prefer majority languages like English ( 107 ; 49 ) . Some users believe that platforms afford less visibility to content from Indigenous creators than that produced by white creators ( 86 ; 123 ) , reaffirming colonial hierarchies that cast local cultures, relations, and people as inferior ( 138 ; 36 ) . Even if these impacts are not intended by developers, communities question whether their values are protected by Big Tech. These concerns have not been pursued in scholarly evaluations of algorithmic systems, which typically follow Western anxieties ( 144 ; 95 ) (e.g., audits frequently use American categories, such as framing political bias as Republicans vs. Democrats ( 81 ) ). Though journalists, scholars, and activists have collected anecdotal reports of Indigenous concerns, no empirical, rigorous investigation has yet explored whether popular systems are operating as feared. In this study, we use community-informed algorithmic auditing to explore whether an online platform sustains or imperils Indigenous culture. We employ an empirical and decolonial approach, so that the evidence we gather about platforms serves Indigenous people ( 138 ; 141 ) . First, we draw upon qualitative research to understand Indigenous community concerns, surfacing particular cultural aspects that are perceived to be under threat from online platforms. Then, we create our algorithmic audit research questions in conversation with the community. Algorithmic audits provide evidence about the operation and impacts of algorithmic curation ( 95 ) , so we tune our inquiry to examine content related to the threatened cultural aspects. Finally, we evaluate different strategies to contest platform algorithms and better align recommendations with community values. This approach yields knowledge that is immediately useful to the impacted community. As it is inappropriate to assume all Indigenous peoples share the same views ( 104 ) , we build our inquiry from an in-depth analysis of a specific community. We consider the context of Kyrgyzstan, where the Indigenous Kyrgyz population has long contended with Russia’s imperial power, because the community has expressed serious anxieties about the impact of platforms on their Indigenous language. Our audit investigates widespread, deep-seated fears among Kyrgyz caregivers that YouTube encourages their children to speak Russian instead of Kyrgyz, their heritage language. Our team surfaced this cultural distress in a prior ethnographic study conducted in Bishkek, the capital of Kyrgyzstan ( 87 ) . In the Soviet Union, Russian was a required subject in schools ( 69 ; 48 ; 38 ) and fluency was vital for career advancement ( 57 ; 85 ; 127 ; 128 ) . After Kyrgyzstan declared independence, government entities and language activists tried to promote the Kyrgyz language ( 28 ; 58 ; 70 ; 8 ) . Kyrgyz parents believe YouTube undermines such language revitalization efforts, since their children consume predominantly Russian-language content on the platform and mimic language heard online. To determine whether the platform steers Kyrgyz children away from Indigenous language videos and toward Russian-language content, we conduct a sock-puppet algorithmic audit ( 121 ) that measures how the YouTube recommendation algorithm prioritizes content across Indigenous and non-Indigenous languages. Since sock-puppets can signal different interests to an audited platform, this approach allows us to investigate videos recommended to children. We design a series of experiments to test the search and recommendation algorithms, because children used these to locate YouTube content during prior participant observation. These experiments record the algorithmic recommendations presented in response to popular search queries in Kyrgyzstan or encountered while browsing the platform. Research assistants from a university in Bishkek labeled the languages that appeared in each of the 10,741 unique videos gathered during the experiments. Our auditing results validate caregiver concerns, as we find that YouTube primarily recommends non-Indigenous content to Indigenous Kyrgyz children---even when children signal clear preferences for Indigenous content. Evaluating equal numbers of search terms in Russian and Kyrgyz, we find that YouTube prioritizes Russian-language content over Kyrgyz-language content, and that this skew is even greater for terms related to children’s interests. Surprisingly, a child who signals a strong interest in Kyrgyz-language content (i.e., by watching a sequence of Kyrgyz cartoons) is likely to see fewer Kyrgyz-language recommendations while browsing than new users who have yet to signal their interests. This behavior exists despite significant revitalization efforts to post Kyrgyz-language children’s content on the platform