Convex Hull Volumes in Hyperbolic 3-Space
Cameron MacMahon · 2026
Read Convex Hull Volumes in Hyperbolic 3-Space by Cameron MacMahon (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27291.txt.
Introduction
MacMahon gives a shape-based test on certain closed subsets of the Riemann sphere. It implies that their hyperbolic convex hulls in 3-space have infinite volume. As a result, he describes sets in the Riemann sphere whose hulls have infinite volume. That answers a question of Danny Calegari. He further gives a geometric account of planar self-similar sets whose hyperbolic convex hulls have infinite volume. Sphere geometry thus links directly to hull size in three dimensions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cameron MacMahon |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28491 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27291
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Convex Hull Volumes in Hyperbolic 3-Space Cameron MacMahon Abstract In this paper we provide a geometric condition satisfied by certain closed subsets of the Riemann sphere which implies that their hyperbolic convex hulls in ℍ 3 \mathbb{H}^{3} have infinite volume. As a corollary, we characterize continua in the Riemann sphere whose hyperbolic convex hulls have infinite volume, answering a question of Danny Calegari. Furthermore, we give a geometric characterization of planar self-similar sets whose hyperbolic convex hulls have infinite volume. 1 Introduction It was claimed in [ 1 ] that the hyperbolic convex hull in \mathbb{H}^{3} of a Jordan curve \Gamma in the Riemann sphere \hat{{\mathbb{C}}} has infinite volume except when \Gamma is a circle. More generally, Danny Calegari asked whether or not it is possible to characterize those continua (compact, connected sets) in \hat{{\mathbb{C}}} whose hyperbolic convex hulls have infinite volume. In this work we provide such a characterization: Theorem 1.1 . The volume of the hyperbolic convex hull of a continuum K in the Riemann sphere is either zero or infinity, and is zero if and only if K lies on a circle. This follows from Theorem 3.4 below, which gives a condition on a closed subset E\subset\hat{{\mathbb{C}}} that, when satisfied, implies that the hyperbolic convex hull of E has infinite volume. This condition will be satisfied if the one dimensional Hausdorff measure of E is positive and E does not lie on a circle. Investigating whether or not this condition is necessary, we discuss hyperbolic convex hull volumes of planar self-similar sets. We also characterize planar self-similar sets whose hyperbolic convex hulls have infinite volume: Theorem 1.2 . The volume of the hyperbolic convex hull of a self-similar set K\subset\hat{{\mathbb{C}}} is either zero or infinity, and is zero if and only if K lies on a circle. It is the author’s belief that the methods in this paper can be tweaked to decide the question of finite or infinite hyperbolic convex hull volume for other classes of sets in the plane and/or particular sets. In the case of continua motivation for Theorem 1.1 comes from hyperbolic geometry, in particular the discussion following Theorem 6.24 in [ 3 ] . The proof of Theorem 6.24 (whose statement is beyond the scope of this work) would be greatly simplified if one could prove the following `` No Wandering Continua” conjecture (Conjecture 6.29 in [ 3 ] ): Conjecture 1.3 . Let G be a co-compact Kleinian group. Suppose K\subset\hat{{\mathbb{C}}} is a continuum which is disjoint from all of its G -translates. Then K consists of a single point. As stated in [ 3 ] , it is possible to prove Conjecture 1.3 in the case when K contains an arc of a round circle by a theorem of Zeghib [ 8 ] . Calegari [ 4 ] suggested proving Theorem 1.1 so that it suffices to go about proving Conjecture 1.3 with the additional assumption that the hyperbolic convex hull of K has infinite volume. A brief remark on notation. When A and B are quantities that both depend on some parameter, we use the symbol A\gtrsim B to denote that there exists a constant C independent of the parameter so that CA\geq B . The notation A\lesssim B has a similar meaning. We take A\asymp B to mean that there is a constant c independent of the parameter so that c^{-1}A\leq B\leq cA . 2 Geometry of Cuspidal Hulls We begin with some notation (see Figure 1 ). Denote by {\mathbb{B}} hyperbolic 3-space in the Poincaré ball model, and let {\mathbb{S}} denote its 2-sphere at infinity. Let D_{\delta}=B(0,\delta) be the ball of hyperbolic radius \delta at 0 , and let x\in{\mathbb{S}} . Let \Sigma_{\sigma} stand for the Euclidean sphere of radius (1-\sigma) centered at zero, and let K_{\sigma} denote the closed Euclidean ball centered at 0 of radius (1-\sigma) . Finally, let C_{x} be the hyperbolic convex hull of D and x , and let \gamma_{x} stand for the unique geodesic ray issuing from 0 and landing at x . Note that C_{x} is a hyperbolic `` cusp” neighborhood of \gamma_{x} . Figure 1: A Cross Section of C_{x} Let V(\sigma) be the hyperbolic volume of C_{x}-K_{\sigma} , and note that this definition is independent of x because all such regions are isometric. Furthermore, C_{x}\bigcap\Sigma_{\sigma} is a spherical ball on \Sigma_{\sigma} centered at \gamma_{x}\bigcap\Sigma_{\sigma} . Set the radius of this ball in the Euclidean spherical metric on \Sigma_{\sigma} to be R(\sigma) ; this is also independent of x . Let x,y\in{\mathbb{S}} . Let D(x,y,\sigma) denote the spherical Euclidean distance between \gamma_{x}\bigcap\Sigma_{\sigma} and \gamma_{y}\bigcap\Sigma_{\sigma} on \Sigma_{\sigma} . We will prove the following: Theorem 2.1 . As \sigma\rightarrow 0 , the following hold for all x,y\in{\mathbb{S}} with constants depending only upon \delta : \framebox{$V(\sigma)\gtrsim\sigma^{2}$} (1) \framebox{$R(\sigma)\asymp\sigma^{2}$} (2) \framebox{$D(x,y,\sigma)\asymp|x-y|$} (3) where |x-y| denotes the spherical distance between x and y . Proof. We begin by proving (1) . We may assume that x lies on the unit circle in \hat{{\mathbb{C}}} and is equal to 1 there. Map the hyperbolic ball model {\mathbb{B}} to the upper half space model \mathbb{H}^{3} by an isometry \phi taking 0 to i and 1 to \infty . Let the image of C_{x} be called \Gamma_{x} . Since x\mapsto\infty under this map \Gamma_{x} is a Euclidean vertical cylindrical tube issuing from the sides of a small ball (exactly how small depending only on \delta ) around i tending upward toward \infty . Thus, up to a constant depending only on \delta , the tube has Euclidean radius 1 . Figure 2: A cross section of the image of C_{x} under \phi Denote the coordinate along the vertical axis in {H}^{3} by y . Let t>1 , and consider the horosphere y=t . We estimate the volume of \Gamma_{x}\bigcap\{(x_{1},x_{2},y)\in{H}^{3}:y\geq t\} . Since up to a constant the tube \Gamma_{x} has width 1 , we have that a horospherical cross section \Gamma_{x}\bigcap\{(x_{0},x_{1},y_{0})\in{H}^{3}:y=y_{0}\} , y_{0}>t has hyperbolic area \frac{1}{y_{0}^{2}} up to a constant dependent only on \delta . The volume v(t) of \Gamma_{x}\bigcap\{(x_{1},x_{2},y)\in{H}^{3}:y\geq t\} is thus, with C_{\delta} a constant depending only on \delta , equal to v(t)=C_{\delta}\int_{y=t}^{\infty}\frac{1}{y^{2}}(\frac{dy}{y})=\frac{C_{\delta}}{t^{2}} Under the map back to {\mathbb{B}} , \Gamma_{x}\bigcap\{(x_{1},x_{2},y)\in{H}^{3}:y\geq t\} maps to C_{x}\bigcap H_{\sigma} where H_{\sigma} is the horosphere at x=1 tangent to \Sigma_{\sigma} , where 1-\sigma=\frac{it-i}{it+i} and so \sigma=\frac{2}{t+1}\quad\quad\quad t=\frac{2-\sigma}{\sigma} Since the horosphere H_{\sigma} lies tangent to \Sigma_{\sigma} , we have that V(\sigma)\gtrsim v(t)=v(\frac{2-\sigma}{\sigma})\asymp(\frac{\sigma}{2-\sigma})^{2}\rightarrow\sigma^{2} as \sigma\rightarrow 0 . This completes the proof of (1) . To prove (2) , we recall that hyperbolic geodesics in the Poincaré model are arcs of circles orthogonal to the boundary at x . Assume once again that x=1 . Note that a hyperbolic planar cross section of C_{x} is the region between two such circles (whose radii depend only on \delta ) lying tangent precisely at x=1 . Because \Sigma_{\sigma}\bigcap C_{x} is rotationally symmetric about \gamma_{x} , it suffices to prove (2) for a hyperbolic planar cross section. Within such a cross section note that the circular arc giving the intersection of \Sigma_{\sigma} and C_{x} is better and better approximated by segment of the line orthogonal to \gamma_{x} between the geodesic arcs as \sigma\rightarrow 0 . The Euclidean length of the segment orthogonal to \gamma_{x} lying