Cylindrical Matter: A beyond-quantum many-body system for efficient classical simulation of quantum pure-Ising like systems

Sahar Atallah 1 , Peter Carrekmor 1 , Michael Garn 2,1 , Yukuan Tao 3 , and Shashank Virmani 1 · 2026

Read Cylindrical Matter: A beyond-quantum many-body system for efficient classical simulation of quantum pure-Ising like systems by Sahar Atallah 1 , Peter Carrekmor 1 , Michael Garn 2,1 , Yukuan Tao 3 , and Shashank Virmani 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27248.txt.

Introduction

Atallah and four colleagues construct Cylindrical Matter, a hypothetical beyond-quantum many-body system built to allow efficient classical simulation of quantum pure-Ising-like systems. Even simplified quantum many-body models can be hard to analyze. Their model uses lattices of interacting particles called cylindrical bits, in continuous time. Spatial constraints on particle interactions keep probabilities valid, making the toy model non-free in the language of earlier work. They explore those constraints and the resulting entangled behavior.

Catalog record

CREATORSahar Atallah 1 , Peter Carrekmor 1 , Michael Garn 2,1 , Yukuan Tao 3 , and Shashank Virmani 1
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE95837
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27248

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cylindrical Matter: A beyond-quantum many-body system for efficient classical simulation of quantum pure-Ising like systems Sahar Atallah 1 , Peter Carrekmor 1 , Michael Garn 2,1 , Yukuan Tao 3 , and Shashank Virmani 1 Abstract Even simplified models of quantum many-body systems can be difficult to analyse. However, taking inspiration from the foundations of physics, one may wonder whether there are practical advantages to constructing alternative beyond-quantum descriptions of many-body systems. We explore this question in the context of quantum interactions that are diagonal in the computational basis. We construct a hypothetical model of a continuous time dynamical many-body system that is based upon lattices of interacting particles called “cylindrical bits”, a concept first introduced in atallah . In the language of Lee our toy model is non-free , as we need spatial constraints on how the particles interact to ensure valid probabilities. We investigate these constraints and explore the resulting ‘entangled’ states that can exist. Certain pure quantum entangled systems can be faithfully mimicked by our cylindrical worlds. This allows us to simulate efficiently classically, in the sense of sampling measurement outcomes, a variety of previously unknown quantum systems. Examples include some states created by pure Ising interactions algebraically decaying faster than ∼ 1 / r 3 ​ D / 2 \sim 1/r^{3D/2} , with spatial dimension D D , under measurements in the Z Z eigenbasis or eigenbases of a ​ X + b ​ Y aX+bY for a , b ∈ ℝ a,b\in\mathbb{R} . We also explore whether another choice of non-quantum ‘particle’ could expand the applicability of the classical simulation by defining and partially optimising a figure-of-merit that attempts to capture how useful various possibilities may be. This work extends and replaces a previous preprint arXiv:2307.01800. I Introduction When formulating models of a classical or quantum many-body material we are normally forced to make a number of idealisations, leading to simpler effective models which we might hope are more amenable to analysis. However, even relatively simple instances of this approach can lead to difficult mathematical problems. The main example that will motivate the present work is the set of states created by placing single qubits on the vertices of a lattice with interactions that are diagonal in the Z basis. Among the states that can be created in this way are the cluster states. As measurements made on cluster states are sufficient for implementing quantum computation Raussendorf , this strongly suggests that classically simulating general instances of such systems - in the sense of sampling the outcomes of measurements made upon them - will be impossible to do efficiently, in spite of the relative simplicity of the interactions. However, in attempts to understand the non-classicality (computational or otherwise) of quantum theory, it has frequently proven fruitful to consider alternative descriptions of quantum physics, such as (where they exist) hidden variable models, as well as hypothetical theories that endeavour to replicate some of its features in order to elucidate minimal assumptions leading to quantum theories (see e.g. Foils ; gptreview ; gpts ; Lee ). Taking inspiration from such investigations, in previous work atallah we considered an alternative description of cluster state like quantum computations in terms of objects we referred to as ‘cylindrical bits’. While we describe cylindrical bits in more detail later, roughly speaking a single cylindrical bit (parameterised by a ‘radius’ r ) has a state space consisting of a cylinder of vectors in \mathbb{R}^{3} of radius r , somewhat analogous to single qubits having a state space consisting of the Bloch sphere of vectors in \mathbb{R}^{3} . Systems of multiple cylindrical bits are constructed by placing cylindrical bits on an underlying interaction graph, and allowing the cylindrical bits to be interacted and measuremed in certain restricted ways. In atallah cylindrical bits enabled the efficient classical simulation of cluster state quantum computers in which the input qubits are not initialised in |+\rangle:=(|0\rangle+|1\rangle)/\sqrt{2} states, but pure (or indeed mixed) states that are closer to computational basis states. The value of such results is that they provide new examples of non-trivial families of pure entangled systems in which can be efficiently simulated classically, a question that is of interest in the study of both quantum computation and many-body physics. In atallah it was shown that similar results will in principle hold for a wide variety of other systems where the interactions and permitted measurements arise from certain abelian symmetries. The first contribution of the present work will be to analytically compute a continuous time extension of the discrete time analysis of atallah . While the results of atallah already imply that such an extension should exist, the perhaps unexpected fact that it can be obtained analytically will prove to be useful. It will enable us to consider a cylindrical world with continuous time, and significantly expand the range of systems that can be efficiently simulated classically. For instance, at zero temperature/noise, we will be able to efficiently classically simulate certain nearest-neighbour hamiltonians for arbitrarily long real times, and certain power-law decaying interactions for finite times. Our second contribution will be more foundational in spirit. We will consider cylindrical bits and the permitted interactions and measurements as the basis of a hypothetical ‘beyond-quantum’ many body system. One obstacle to such an interpretation is that there exists a threshold cylindrical bit radius, which may depend upon the underlying interactions, above which negative probabilities arise even under the allowed measurements and interactions. Extending observations made for CZ (control- Z ) interactions in atallah , we bound these threshold radii, and explore what sort of ‘cylindrical matter’ can arise. This will allow us to show that a type of ‘cylinder entangled state’ conjectured not to exist in atallah for square two dimensional lattices, does in fact exist for one dimensional chains of cylinders. The motivation for these investigations is that by considering what a many-body theory might look like in a beyond quantum framework, we may uncover new ways to analyse quantum many-body systems. Our final contribution will be to consider whether instead of cylindrical bits it is of value to consider state spaces given by other sets of vectors in \mathbb{R}^{3} , corresponding to other types of hypothetical particle. We will approach this question by defining a particular figure-of-merit for describing how ‘good’ different state spaces are. Roughly speaking this figure-of-merit describes how quickly the state spaces have to ‘grow’ in order to maintain a particular type of separable decomposition as the particles interact. We will show that under this criterion, cylindrical bits are optimal among a wide family of state spaces. However, we will also provide numerical evidence that there are other choices of state space that are slightly better than cylinders for classically simulating some quantum systems. Although the figure-of-merit we use does not perfectly capture how useful a particular state space is, it serves as a good proxy for guiding future systematic searches for useful non-quantum state spaces, while having the advantage that quite strong statements can be made about it using symmetry arguments. Structure of the paper: In section II we discuss background and prior work. In section III we set most of the definitions and notation needed for the first parts of the

Read the complete text