Multirate characterization of relaxation mechanisms for two nonequivalent nuclear spins 1/2 in a liquid using maximally entangled pseudo-pure quantum states

Georgiy Baroncha, Alexander Perepukhov, Boris V. Fine · 2026

Read Multirate characterization of relaxation mechanisms for two nonequivalent nuclear spins 1/2 in a liquid using maximally entangled pseudo-pure quantum states by Georgiy Baroncha, Alexander Perepukhov, Boris V. Fine (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27220.txt.

Introduction

Baroncha, Perepukhov, and Fine map spin decay in NMR for two adjacent non-equivalent spin-1/2 nuclei, hydrogen-1 and carbon-13, in a liquid molecule. Their study reads eight decay rates for the pair at once. Such a set acts as a fingerprint of complex molecules under several decay routes. Some rates come from standard inversion recovery and Overhauser tests. Others come from decay started by maximally entangled pseudo-pure Bell states of the pair.

Catalog record

CREATORGeorgiy Baroncha, Alexander Perepukhov, Boris V. Fine
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE110798
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27220

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Multirate characterization of relaxation mechanisms for two nonequivalent nuclear spins 1/2 in a liquid using maximally entangled pseudo-pure quantum states Georgiy Baroncha, Alexander Perepukhov, Boris V. Fine Abstract Multirate characterization of spin responses in nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is a promising approach to fingerprinting complex molecules in the presence of multiple relaxation mechanisms. Here we present experimental and theoretical investigations simultaneously accessing 8 relaxation rates describing the density matrix of two adjacent non-equivalent nuclear spins 1/2 ( 1 H and 13 C) belonging to a molecule in a liquid. The selected nuclear pair is stable with respect to chemical exchange. Some of the rates are obtained from conventional measurements of inversion recovery and nuclear Overhauser effect, while other, less conventional ones, are extracted from the relaxation initialized by the maximally entangled pseudo-pure Bell states (Bell PPSs) of the spin pair. The Bell PPSs are created using a hereby introduced method based on a detuned Hartmann-Hahn double resonance condition. Microscopic theory behind the measured relaxation rates is presented, and its consistency is demonstrated by several parameter-free tests. In particular, it is shown both theoretically and experimentally, that the eigenmodes of the off-diagonal relaxation of the two-spin density matrix can be selectively initialized using Bell PPSs. Our multirate analysis suggests that the measured off-diagonal relaxation is partly due to an unconventional mechanism arising from very weak J J -couplings of the spin pair with fluctuating distant nuclear spins. Furthermore, we identify a dimensionless ratio of diagonal relaxation rates, which is determined exclusively by intra-pair magnetic dipolar interaction and hence possesses a universal value for a broad class of nuclear spin pairs. This value is consistent with both our experiments and other experiments reported in the literature. I Introduction Relaxation of nuclear spins in a liquid measured by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is sensitive to the structure and dynamics of molecules carrying those spins. Detailed characterization of this relaxation can reveal difficult-to-access microscopic parameters. NMR experiments pursuing such an agenda often focus on longitudinal T_{1} -relaxation, transverse T_{2} -relaxation and the nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) 1 ; 38 ; 26 ; 23 . However, the above kinds of experiments deliver only a fraction of microscopic information for a strongly coupled pair of nuclear spins 1/2. The density matrix of two spins 1/2 is determined by 15 parameters, whose relaxation is characterized in its entirety by a 15 \times 15 matrix of coefficients, which we call “rates”. A promising and not yet fully exploited resource for NMR relaxation studies is the use of the maximally entangled pseudo-pure Bell states (Bell PPSs) of nuclear spin pairs. Bell PPSs have been of interest for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) for decades: they are often used in the context of the quantum computing agenda 12 ; 10 , but their utility in NMR is much broader 7 ; 33 ; 45 ; 16 ; 11 ; 8 ; 2 ; 14 ; 43 ; 35 ; 9 ; 37 ; 29 ; 15 ; 36 . In this work, we investigate a pair of two non-equivalent nuclear spins 1/2, generate their Bell PPSs using hereby introduced method based on detuned Hartmann-Hahn double resonance condition and then combine conventional relaxation measurements with those initialized by the Bell PPSs to obtain 8 relaxation rates for the same system. The measured rates characterize both diagonal and off-diagonal relaxation of the density matrix in the quantum basis imposed by external magnetic field. We show, in particular, both experimentally and theoretically that Bell PPSs can be used to selectively initialize individual eigenmodes of the off-diagonal relaxation. On the theoretical side, we analyze the measured rates using Redfield’s equations 34 , thereby connecting those rates to various relaxation mechanisms. The mechanisms are separated into the one due to the intra-pair magnetic dipolar interaction (IPMDI) and those described as originating from fluctuating local fields that are not affected by the spin state of the selected nuclear pair. This analysis then leads us to identifying significant contributions from the currently underappreciated off-diagonal relaxation mechanism associated with very small J -couplings of the selected spin pair to distant nuclear spins. Such a mechanism, besides being a necessary part of multirate analysis 23 , is also potentially useful for assessing small J -couplings not resolvable directly in NMR spectra, which, in turn, can help to characterize the connectivity and the local geometry of complex molecules. Our theoretical description is to be subjected to a number of experimental tests. Particularly notable among them is the parameter-free test validating the NMR relaxation theory of Bloembergen, Purcell and Pound 4 (BPP) and of Solomon 40 : it involves a combination of four diagonal relaxation rates, where all contributions from non-IPMDI mechanisms are canceled. IPMDI played the central role in the BPP-Solomon theory, and, despite the theory being well established, the parameter-free tests of it have been somewhat elusive — consequence of multiple mechanisms involved in the relaxation. In particular, the theory of Solomon 40 initially assumed that the IPMDI completely determines NOE in hydrofluoric acid HF — in disagreement with experiment, which was later explained 39 ; 1 by the J -coupling modulated by chemical exchange. Chemical exchange was also part of the reason 31 ; 1 why the simple equality T_{1}=T_{2} for the longitudinal and the transverse relaxation times was not observed for water — contrary to the prediction of the BPP theory based on the IPMDI mechanism only. Given the above examples, it is natural to explore the parameter-free tests of the BPP-Solomon theory for nuclear spin pairs stable towards chemical exchange, such as the one investigated in this article. In what follows, Section II introduces the system to be investigated, Section III describes the theoretical basis of our analysis, Section IV presents the experimental investigations. The experimental results are compared with the theoretical predictions and interpreted in terms of microscopic relaxation mechanisms in Section V . Section VI discusses literature-based parameter-free tests of IPMDI relaxation mechanism. Section VII contains summary and conclusions. II System of interest (a) (b) g(\omega) [a.u.] \omega/2\pi [Hz] (c) g(\omega) [a.u.] \omega/2\pi [Hz] Figure 1: (a) Diethylphthalimidomalonate( -2-^{13} C, 15 N molecule with the measured pair of nuclear spins 1 H – 13 C highlighted by colored circles. (b) Spectrum g(\omega) of the highlighted 1 H, where \omega is the frequency offset. The peak doublet originates from the J_{\text{HC}} -coupling. The inset shows the spectrum of all 1 H nuclei belonging to the molecule, with the frequency range of the main panel indicated by the gray background. (c) Spectrum g(\omega) of the highlighted 13 C consisting of the J_{\text{HC}} -split doublet with further small splitting due to the coupling to the nearby 15 N spin, whose influence on the measured pair is discussed in Appendix A . We investigate experimentally and theoretically a pair of adjacent nuclear spins 1/2, 1 H and 13 C, belonging to the molecule diethylphthalimidomalonate( -2-^{13} C, 15 N) in the solution C 6 D 6 . The molecular structure is shown in Fig. 1 (a) with the selected 1 H – 13 C pair highlighted. The molecule is 99.5 percent enriched by 13 C at the highlighted position and by 15 N. The J -coupling constant for the 1

Read the complete text