The First Empirical Calibration of the MIR Abundance Diagnostic Ne 23 with JWST Facilities: JWST (MIRI/MRS), LBT (MODS) astropy ( 9 ; 7 ; 8 ) , jupyter ( 58 ) , JWST Calibration Pipeline ( 17 ) , numpy ( 44 ) , scipy ( 119 )
Noah S. J. Rogers, Evan D. Skillman, Danielle A. Berg, Karla Z. Arellano-Córdova, Richard W. Pogge, Alessandra Aloisi, Leslie K. Hunt, Anne E. Jaskot, Matilde Mingozzi, Ryan J. Rickards Vaught, Karin M. Sandstrom, O. Grace Telford, Macarena G. del Valle-Espinosa · 2026
Read The First Empirical Calibration of the MIR Abundance Diagnostic Ne 23 with JWST Facilities: JWST (MIRI/MRS), LBT (MODS) astropy ( 9 ; 7 ; 8 ) , jupyter ( 58 ) , JWST Calibration Pipeline ( 17 ) , numpy ( 44 ) , scipy ( 119 ) by Noah S. J. Rogers, Evan D. Skillman, Danielle A. Berg, Karla Z. Arellano-Córdova, Richard W. Pogge, Alessandra Aloisi, Leslie K. Hunt, Anne E. Jaskot, Matilde Mingozzi, Ryan J. Rickards Vaught, Karin M. Sandstrom, O. Grace Telford, Macarena G. del Valle-Espinosa (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27056.txt.
Introduction
Rogers and twelve colleagues give the first calibration of Ne23, an abundance diagnostic using mid-infrared neon lines insensitive to electron temperature. Optical strong-line methods suffer temperature-driven errors, limiting their use as metallicity tracers, especially in dusty metal-rich gas. From JWST/MIRI views of ten H II regions plus eight metal-poor galaxies with oxygen measures, Ne23 tracks oxygen abundance over a range. The relation scatters just six hundredths of a dex in oxygen at fixed Ne23, enabling oxygen estimates out to redshift 0.8 from JWST/MIRI spectra.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Noah S. J. Rogers, Evan D. Skillman, Danielle A. Berg, Karla Z. Arellano-Córdova, Richard W. Pogge, Alessandra Aloisi, Leslie K. Hunt, Anne E. Jaskot, Matilde Mingozzi, Ryan J. Rickards Vaught, Karin M. Sandstrom, O. Grace Telford, Macarena G. del Valle-Espinosa |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54343 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27056
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The First Empirical Calibration of the MIR Abundance Diagnostic Ne 23 with JWST Facilities: JWST (MIRI/MRS), LBT (MODS) astropy ( 9 ; 7 ; 8 ) , jupyter ( 58 ) , JWST Calibration Pipeline ( 17 ) , numpy ( 44 ) , scipy ( 119 ) Noah S. J. Rogers, Evan D. Skillman, Danielle A. Berg, Karla Z. Arellano-Córdova, Richard W. Pogge, Alessandra Aloisi, Leslie K. Hunt, Anne E. Jaskot, Matilde Mingozzi, Ryan J. Rickards Vaught, Karin M. Sandstrom, O. Grace Telford, Macarena G. del Valle-Espinosa Abstract Large surveys of galaxies in the local and high-redshift Universe have, traditionally, relied on the intensity of rest-optical emission lines from metal ions in the Interstellar Medium (ISM) to indirectly estimate the O/H abundance in the gas. However, these optical strong line diagnostics are also sensitive to the electron gas temperature ( T e T_{e} ), resulting in large systematic uncertainties that inherently limit their utility as metallicity tracers, especially in dust-obscured and metal-rich environments. To this end, we provide the first empirical calibration of Ne 23 , a novel abundance diagnostic using the mid-infrared (MIR) T e T_{e} -insensitive [Ne II] λ \lambda 12.81 μ \mu m and [Ne III] λ \lambda 15.56 μ \mu m fine-structure lines. We present new JWST/MIRI MRS observations of ten H II regions with optical measurements of T e T_{e} and O/H from the CHAOS project, and we analyze MIRI observations of eight low-metallicity galaxies with similarly high-fidelity direct O/H. We measure Ne 23 from 1D MIR spectra extracted from apertures matched to the ground-based spectroscopy used to obtain O/H, a method that is unfeasible from MIR spectra acquired on prior space-based observatories. From these nebulae, Ne 23 is strongly correlated with O/H over 1.5 dex in 12+log(O/H). We calibrate the O/H-Ne 23 relation from the empirical data, finding a scatter of just 0.06 dex in O/H at fixed Ne 23 . The O/H-Ne 23 relation presented here provides a means to reliably estimate 12+log(O/H) from JWST/MIRI MRS observations of ionized nebulae out to z ≈ \approx 0.8, enabling new chemical abundance surveys of highly-attenuated regions and in the metal-rich ISM. I Introduction I.1 Background The abundance of heavy elements, or metallicity, is a central physical quantity of stars and galaxies. The metallicity of the Interstellar Medium (ISM), as traced by the O abundance, is linked to past star formation and is sensitive to a variety of feedback mechanisms and the evolving gas fraction within a galaxy ( 115 ; 32 ; 26 ; 65 ; 20 , e.g.,) . Therefore, to appreciate the prevalence of these physical processes and the chemical evolution of local and distant galaxies necessitates precision estimates of O/H in the ISM. The ISM metallicity can be measured from optical spectroscopy of star-forming regions ionized by massive stars. The optical band contains numerous H I recombination lines and collisionally-excited lines (CELs) from metal ions, with intensities dependent on the ionic abundance, electron gas temperature ( T_{e} ), and density ( n_{e} ). Ratios of specific CELs enable the direct calculation of T_{e} , n_{e} , and the ionic abundance in the ISM. Notably, the two relevant ionization states of O in typical H II regions, O + and O 2+ , emit CELs in the optical, permitting a measure of the total O/H abundance. The CEL or direct method ( 29 ; 83 ; 66 ) has been viewed as the gold standard for measuring ISM metallicities and widely used to measure chemical abundances in H II regions and star-forming galaxies ( 41 ; 54 ; 35 ; 36 ; 33 ; 34 ; 49 ; 100 ; 14 ; 22 ; 2 ; 5 ; 96 ; 74 ) . The direct abundance method is not without limitations. For example, direct T_{e} are calculated using metal auroral lines, faint CELs that originate from relatively high-excitation energy levels. Direct T_{e} are often inaccessible in metal-rich nebulae, where CEL cooling is efficient and suppresses auroral line excitation ( 79 ) . Further, auroral line emission is associated with hotter regions of the ISM, such that temperature fluctuations in the gas bias direct T_{e} high and O/H lower than the true ISM metallicity ( 84 ; 75 ) . Dust attenuation is also significant at optical wavelengths and prevents the detection of the auroral lines in obscured nebulae. Finally, the direct method cannot account for O depletion onto dust grains, which can be significant at solar metallicities ( 82 ; 85 , up to 0.1 dex,) . Owing to these challenges, methods relating the ratios of strong optical emission lines to O/H have been developed. These strong line diagnostics are calibrated on existing empirical direct abundance data ( 1 ; 28 ; 89 ; 69 ; 90 ; 23 ; 24 , e.g.,) , line ratio predictions from grids of photoionization models ( 72 ; 55 ; 116 ; 37 ; 68 , e.g.,) , or a mixture of the two ( 80 , e.g.,) . The use of intense, easily-observed CELs enables the application of strong line diagnostics on large spectroscopic samples of typical star-forming galaxies ( 115 , e.g.,) , at high redshift ( 31 ; 102 ; 103 ; 18 ; 104 ) , and in metal-rich objects. The T_{e} sensitivity of the optical CELs results in many well-documented issues with common strong line diagnostics. First, line ratios utilizing high excitation energy CELs (e.g., R3 = log([O III] \lambda 5007/H \beta )) are most sensitive to T_{e} , often resulting in the same line ratio at low and high O/H ( 81 ; 108 ; 57 ; 66 , a double-value problem, see) . Second, the flux density of ionizing photons, or the ionization parameter, influences the energy distribution of free electrons, making optical line ratios sensitive to both metallicity and the ionization parameter ( 72 ; 55 ) . Finally, diagnostics utilizing emission lines from other metals, like [N II] \lambda 6584, are sensitive to the relative abundance of O and that element ( 87 ; 38 , e.g.,) . For all these reasons, there is large dispersion in O/H at fixed optical strong line ratio, both in empirical data ( 88 ; 16 ) and photoionization model predictions ( 55 , e.g.,) . Further, different calibrations of the same strong line diagnostic can result in inferred O/H values that disagree by more than 0.6 dex ( 56 ; 78 ) , an issue related to different empirical calibration samples or treatments of the gas physics in photoionization models. I.2 A Novel Abundance Diagnostic The need for accurate abundance diagnostics is imperative and necessitates the exploration of new techniques. An alternative to the optical CELs are the IR fine-structure lines, the intensities of which are T_{e} -insensitive due to their low excitation energies. While the mid-IR (MIR) lacks any prominent emission lines from O + or O 2+ , this band contains fine-structure lines of Ne + and Ne 2+ , the most abundant ionization states of Ne in H II regions photoionized by massive stars. O and Ne are produced in massive stars and released to the ISM via core-collapse supernovae ( 59 ) , resulting in