Beyond Cloud-9: The case for discovering more HI-rich failed halos
Jorge Moreno, Coral Wheeler, Francisco J. Mercado, M. Katy Rodriguez Wimberly, Pratik J. Gandhi, Jenna Samuel, Robert Feldmann, James S. Bullock, Andrew Wetzel, Michael Boylan-Kolchin · 2026
Read Beyond Cloud-9: The case for discovering more HI-rich failed halos by Jorge Moreno, Coral Wheeler, Francisco J. Mercado, M. Katy Rodriguez Wimberly, Pratik J. Gandhi, Jenna Samuel, Robert Feldmann, James S. Bullock, Andrew Wetzel, Michael Boylan-Kolchin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27047.txt.
Introduction
Moreno and ten colleagues examine hydrogen starless halos nearby across three simulations: FIREbox, Recal-EAGLE, and NIVARIA-LG. All three produce such objects, with hydrogen masses up to 2 dex above Cloud-9, but densities varying by a factor near 30. The populations span mass spaces: NIVARIA-LG makes objects with high hydrogen and gas masses, while FIREbox confines them to narrow gas and mass ranges. Recal-EAGLE and NIVARIA-LG show a gas-mass correlation with different normalizations. The gaps argue for a sample of halos to tell predictions apart.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jorge Moreno, Coral Wheeler, Francisco J. Mercado, M. Katy Rodriguez Wimberly, Pratik J. Gandhi, Jenna Samuel, Robert Feldmann, James S. Bullock, Andrew Wetzel, Michael Boylan-Kolchin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22480 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27047
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond Cloud-9: The case for discovering more HI-rich failed halos yt ( 51 ) , Amiga Halo Finder ( 29 ) , PlotDigitizer ( https://plotdigitizer.com/app) ). Jorge Moreno, Coral Wheeler, Francisco J. Mercado, M. Katy Rodriguez Wimberly, Pratik J. Gandhi, Jenna Samuel, Robert Feldmann, James S. Bullock, Andrew Wetzel, Michael Boylan-Kolchin Abstract HI-rich starless halos, should they exist, hold great promise for elucidating properties of dark matter halos. This Letter examines the properties of HI-rich failed halos at redshift zero across state-of-the-art cosmological simulations (FIREbox, NIVARIA-LG and Recal-EAGLE). First we compare two numerical analogs with Cloud-9, purported to be the first discovery of a starless HI-rich halo. We argue that differences may be driven by environmental factors, and/or the treatment of gas self-shielding – which might further limit existing analytic schemes aimed at inferring dark matter halo information from 21 cm HI observations. We also find that the failed halo samples in the three simulations span different regions of the HI-gas-halo mass ( M HI − M gas − M 200 M_{\rm HI}-M_{\rm gas}-M_{\rm 200} ) plane. FIREbox objects occupy a very narrow regime, while NIVARIA-LG extends to a wider range of M 200 M_{\rm 200} values - and achieves higher M HI M_{\rm HI} and M gas M_{\rm gas} values. Recal-EAGLE M HI M_{\rm HI} values are similar to FIREbox, albeit with lower gas and halo masses. Lastly, we predict that more HI-rich starless halos can be discovered by exploring the HI-poor regime in the local universe, rather than HI-rich populations at high redshift. Overall, we advocate for the allocation of resources to detect and characterize other HI-rich (and HI-poor) failed halos in the local universe, plus dedicated follow-up spectroscopic observations that scrutinize claims to the absence of a faint stellar component, and that assess their isolation status in detail. show][email protected] I Introduction A few months ago, 1 proclaimed confirmation of Cloud-9 as a bonafide HI-rich starless halo. Originally detected by 55 with the Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope (FAST), and characterized using follow-up observations with the Very Large Array (VLA) and the Green Bank Telescope (GBT), these authors report an HI-mass of \sim 1.4\times 10^{6}M_{\odot} ( 28 , see also) . Furthermore, their Hubble Space Telescope (HST) observations rule out a stellar component with M_{\star}\gtrsim 10^{4}M_{\odot} at \simeq 99.5\% confidence. Although other such candidates have been propounded, either faint stellar components have been eventually detected ( 27 ; 34 ; 32 ; 47 , e.g.,) or they have have been identified as tidal debris associated with neighboring gas-rich massive galaxies ( 42 ; 31 , e.g.,) . Cloud-9 and future kindred discoveries open a powerful baryonic window into the nature of dark matter ( 49 ) . Unlike their star-endowed counterparts ( 10 ; 7 ; 41 ; 23 ) , HI-rich starless halos are immune to star-formation driven feedback, and its effects on the underlying dark matter distribution ( 43 ) . Beyond dark matter constraints, HI-rich failed 1 1 1 Hereafter, we use ‘failed’ and ‘starless’ interchangeably, and in the simulations this means that no star particle exists in the dark matter halo at z=0 , following 37 . halos – which are likely just under the threshold of galaxy formation – can also provide unique insights on the physics of galaxy ignition ( 37 ) . The goal of this Letter is to make the following inquiries. First, are modern state-of-the-art cosmological simulations able to produce Cloud-9 analogs? Beyond this specific object, do these simulations predict similar HI-rich failed halo populations? If the answer is ‘no’ to either question, what challenges need to be addressed in both observations and theory? Figure 1: The mass content of failed halos. Left: HI-gas mass ( M_{\rm HI}) versus halo mass ( M_{\rm 200} ). FIREbox objects are color-coded by total gas mass ( M_{\rm gas} ) and are split into two samples, HI-poor objects (small gray-edged circles) and HI-rich objects (large black-edged circles). The horizontal dashed-gray line at M_{\rm HI}=10^{6}M_{\odot} demarcates these two populations. The orange diamond denotes estimates for Cloud-9’s halo mass ( 9 ) and HI-gas mass ( 1 ) . The gray arrows with question marks underscore the uncertain assumptions behind Cloud-9’s M_{\rm 200} estimate. The red squares denote HI-rich failed halos in the NIVARIA-LG simulation ( 20 ) , and the brown pentagons denote HI-rich failed halos in a simulation employing Recal-EAGLE physics ( 50 ) . The large turquoise and red diamonds represent two fiducial examples from FIREbox and NIVARIA-LG, selected for further examination. Right: HI-gas mass versus total gas mass. FIREbox objects are color-coded by halo mass. II Methods and Results We employ FIREbox ( 18 ) , a large-volume cosmological simulation based on the FIRE-2 physics model ( 24 ) , which captures the turbulent multiphase structure of the interstellar medium (down to 10~K ) and treats star formation in a self-regulated fashion. FIREbox has a periodic box of 22.1\,{\rm cMpc}\, on the side, and achieves mass resolution of m_{\rm b}=6.3\times 10^{4}\,M_{\odot} for baryonic particles, and m_{\rm dm}=3.3\times 10^{5}\,M_{\odot} for the dark matter particles. Force resolution is set at a fixed h_{\rm dm}=80 pc (physical) for dark matter particles and 12 pc for star particles, while our adaptive softening length for gas reaches h_{\rm g}=1.5 pc. To identify halos, we use the Amiga Halo Finder algorithm ( 29 , AHF,) , whose virial mass ( M_{\rm vir} ) definition follows 11 . To compare with other simulations, we convert M_{\rm vir} into M_{\rm 200} , the mass enclosed within a region with average density 200 times the mean matter density, following 12 . In this Letter, we only analyze central halos with resolved dark matter and gas components ( N_{\rm dm}\geq 128 , N_{\rm gas}\geq 128 ). We also compare our results with the NIVARIA-LG ( 20 ) and the Recal-EAGLE ( 50 ) simulations 2 2 2 Although other works investigate the nature of starless halos, they do not report or examine HI-rich objects in detail ( 45 ; 8 ; 19 ; 30 ; 26 ; 15 ; 54 , e.g.,) . , whose mass resolutions do not differ substantially from FIREbox. This is not the case for the gas gravitational softening length, which is h_{\rm g}=488 pc ( 195 pc) for NIVARIA-LG (Recal-EAGLE); Furthermore, those simulations rely on the analytical prescription by 40 , while our FIRE-2 model explicitly applies a local Sobolev/Jeans-length approximation to capture the physics of gas self-shielding ( 24 , see Appendix B of) . The left panel of Figure 1 shows M_{\rm HI} (the total mass in HI) versus M_{\rm 200} for a set of failed 3 3 3 Whether or not a halo is ‘failed’ might be resolution-dependent, with low-mass ( M_{\rm 200}\lesssim 10^{9}\rm M_{\odot} ) FIRE-2 halos forming star particles in higher-resolution zoom-in simulations (e.g., 53 ). However, the stellar components of these low-mass halos are below the current stellar threshold for Cloud 9, so we believe the comparison is still valid. halos with a resolved gas component ( N_{\rm gas}\geq 128 ), color coded by M_{\rm gas} (the total gas mass) – while the right panel shows M_{\rm HI} versus M_{\rm gas} , color-coded by M_{\rm 200} . We split