Doubly Robust Local Projections Difference-in-Differences Journal: Economics Letters
Daniel de Abreu Pereira Uhr, Guilherme Valle Moura · 2026
Read Doubly Robust Local Projections Difference-in-Differences Journal: Economics Letters by Daniel de Abreu Pereira Uhr, Guilherme Valle Moura (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27035.txt.
Introduction
Uhr and Moura develop a doubly robust version of local-projection difference-in-differences for staggered treatments. Their estimator, DRLPDID, keeps the local-stack target and stays consistent when either the outcome regression or the treatment model is right. It also gives influence inference for post-treatment summaries and bootstrap bands for dynamic paths. In simulations with covariate selection it matches adjusted LP-DiD when outcome models align, and beats the IPT-only variant when propensity scores are wrong.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel de Abreu Pereira Uhr, Guilherme Valle Moura |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 15882 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27035
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Doubly Robust Local Projections Difference-in-Differences Journal: Economics Letters Daniel de Abreu Pereira Uhr, Guilherme Valle Moura Abstract This paper develops a doubly robust extension of local-projections difference-in-differences (LP-DiD) for staggered absorbing treatments. The resulting estimator, DRLPDID, preserves the LP-DiD local-stack ATT target and is consistent when either the local untreated-outcome regression or the local treatment-probability model is correctly specified. It also delivers influence-function-based inference for post-treatment summaries and multiplier-bootstrap bands for dynamic paths. In Monte Carlo designs with covariate-driven selection, DRLPDID matches regression-adjusted LP-DiD under outcome-model alignment and clearly outperforms the IPT-only variant under propensity-score misspecification. In the no-fault-divorce application, DRLPDID tracks robust staggered-adoption estimators and is less negative than unadjusted LP-DiD. JEL codes: C14, C21, C23, C12 1 Introduction Event-study designs are standard tools for tracing policy dynamics. In staggered-adoption settings with heterogeneous treatment effects, however, the usual two-way fixed-effects event-study regression need not recover a causal path because it can mix already-treated comparisons and non-transparent weights [ 3 , 8 , 2 , 15 , 1 , 7 , 4 , 12 ] . LP-DiD estimates horizon-specific effects [ 11 ] on clean-control stacks that exclude unclean comparisons, thereby avoiding contamination from already-treated controls [ 6 ] . But each horizon-specific stack remains an observational comparison. When untreated outcome dynamics or treatment timing depend on covariates, the horizon-specific LP-DiD problem can be cast as a semiparametric Average Treatment Effect on the Treated (ATT) problem under conditional parallel trends [ 6 ] . Although doubly robust estimators for staggered adoption already exist [ 2 , 13 ] , they operate on the full panel rather than on horizon-specific clean-control stacks; a researcher committed to the LP-DiD framework, therefore, needs nuisance adjustment derived within that framework, with local propensity scores and outcome regressions that are stack- and horizon-specific by construction. This article extends the LP-DiD framework by incorporating robustness to misspecification through a doubly robust approach in staggered adoption settings. It shows that the existing LP-DiD horizon problem can be enriched with Regression-Adjusted (RA), Inverse-Probability-Tilting (IPT), and Doubly Robust (DR) structures that admit influence-function-based inference and multiplier-bootstrap bands [ 10 , 9 , 13 , 2 ] . The Monte Carlo compares DRLPDID with LP-DiD benchmarks and its RA and IPT counterparts across nuisance-specification scenarios designed to diagnose the value of double robustness. The application then shows how the resulting dynamic path compares with leading staggered-adoption estimators in practice. The appendix provides the general base-period formulation, proofs, and supplementary results. 2 Local DRLPDID LP-DiD compares post-entry outcomes with a pre-treatment benchmark constructed using a specific base-period rule, indexed by b . For a given entry date t , let \mathcal{B}(t;b)\subset\{1,\dots,t-1\} denote the set of active pre-treatment periods and let \omega_{tl}^{(b)} be weights summing to one. The generic benchmark operator is defined as: B_{it}^{(b)}=\sum_{l\in\mathcal{B}(t;b)}\omega_{tl}^{(b)}Y_{il}, (2.1) This paper focuses on the standard last-pre-treatment benchmark (denoted by b=-1 ), which assigns a weight of one to period t-1 and zero otherwise, yielding B_{it}^{(-1)}=Y_{i,t-1} . The horizon- h long difference is therefore: \Delta_{it}(h)=Y_{i,t+h}-Y_{i,t-1}. (2.2) Write the local treatment-entry indicator as D_{it}=\mathds{1}\{G_{i}=t\}. (2.3) Here D_{it} denotes local treatment entry, not calendar-time treatment status. For h\geq 0 , the clean-control stack compares treated entries at t with observations untreated at t+h . For h<0 , it reuses the clean-control stack at h=0 and changes only the outcome transformation. The horizon-specific local target is \theta_{h}=\mathbb{E}\!\left[\Delta_{it}(h;1)-\Delta_{it}(h;0)\mid D_{it}=1,\ (i,t)\in\mathcal{S}_{h}\right]. (2.4) Let X_{it} be predetermined covariates. For each h , assume no anticipation or overlap: 0<\mathbb{P}\!\left(D_{it}=1\mid X_{it},t,(i,t)\in\mathcal{S}_{h}\right)<1, (2.5) and local conditional parallel trends, \mathbb{E}\!\left[\Delta_{it}(h;0)\mid D_{it}=1,X_{it},t,(i,t)\in\mathcal{S}_{h}\right]=\mathbb{E}\!\left[\Delta_{it}(h;0)\mid D_{it}=0,X_{it},t,(i,t)\in\mathcal{S}_{h}\right]. (2.6) Then each horizon is an ATT problem on its own LP-DiD stack. Define the local nuisance functions \displaystyle\pi_{h}(X_{it},t) \displaystyle=\mathbb{P}\left(D_{it}=1\mid X_{it},t,(i,t)\in\mathcal{S}_{h}\right), (2.7) \displaystyle m_{0h}(X_{it},t) \displaystyle=\mathbb{E}\left[\Delta_{it}(h)\mid D_{it}=0,X_{it},t,(i,t)\in\mathcal{S}_{h}\right]. (2.8) In the implemented estimators, both nuisance steps use the same horizon-specific linear basis Q_{it,h} , built from the same predetermined covariates and calendar-time controls; the difference is the fitting criterion, with inverse-probability tilting for the treatment-probability working model and least squares or weighted least squares for the untreated-outcome regression. The local regression-adjusted and inverse-probability-weighting representations are \displaystyle\theta_{h}^{RA} \displaystyle=\frac{\mathbb{E}\left[D_{it}\{\Delta_{it}(h)-m_{0h}(X_{it},t)\}\right]}{\mathbb{E}[D_{it}]}, (2.9) \displaystyle\theta_{h}^{IPW} \displaystyle=\frac{\mathbb{E}\left[D_{it}\Delta_{it}(h)\right]}{\mathbb{E}[D_{it}]}-\frac{\mathbb{E}\left[(1-D_{it})\omega_{h}(X_{it},t)\Delta_{it}(h)\right]}{\mathbb{E}\left[(1-D_{it})\omega_{h}(X_{it},t)\right]}, (2.10) where \omega_{h}(X_{it},t)=\pi_{h}(X_{it},t)/(1-\pi_{h}(X_{it},t)) . Combining them yields \theta_{h}^{DR}=\frac{\mathbb{E}\left[D_{it}\{\Delta_{it}(h)-m_{0h}(X_{it},t)\}\right]}{\mathbb{E}[D_{it}]}-\frac{\mathbb{E}\left[(1-D_{it})\omega_{h}(X_{it},t)\{\Delta_{it}(h)-m_{0h}(X_{it},t)\}\right]}{\mathbb{E}\left[(1-D_{it})\omega_{h}(X_{it},t)\right]}. (2.11) Under ( 2.6 ), ( 2.11 ) identifies \theta_{h} if either m_{0h} or \pi_{h} is correctly specified. Here, IPW refers to the population weighting identity in ( 2.11 ), whereas the implemented weighted estimator obtains \pi_{h} by inverse-probability tilting (IPT). DRLPDID estimates ( 2.11 ) horizon by horizon using inverse-probability tilting for the local propensity score [ 9 ] and weighted least squares for the untreated-outcome regression, following the improved doubly robust logic of Sant’Anna and Zhao 2020 in an LP-DiD environment. 2.1 Influence-function inference Let \hat{\Theta}=(\hat{\theta}_{h})_{h\in\mathcal{H}} collect the horizon-specific estimates. For each h , the improved estimator solves stacked local moments for the outcome-regression coefficients, the tilting parameters, and the treated and weighted-control means. Standard M-estimation then gives \sqrt{N_{C}}(\hat{\theta}_{h}-\theta_{h})=\frac{1}{\sqrt{N_{C}}}\sum_{c=1}^{N_{C}}\mathrm{IF}_{c,h}+o_{p}(1), (2.12) where N_{C} is the number of clusters. Equation ( 2.12 ) yields cluster-robust standard errors for each horizon and for any linear contrast built from the horizon-specific effects. For dynamic paths, the paper uses a multiplier bootstrap based on the stacked influence array. If \hat{\Phi}_{c}=(\hat{\mathrm{IF}}_{c,h})_{h\in\mathcal{H}} and \xi_{c} are i.i.d. multipliers with mean zero and variance one, bootstrap draws are \hat{\Theta}^{\ast}=\hat{\Theta}+N_{C}^{-1/2}\sum_{c=1}^{N_{C}}\xi_{c}\hat{\Phi}_{c}. (2.13) The main text reports pointwise cluster-robust intervals in the Monte Carlo and multiplier-bootstrap bands in the empirical event-study figures. The appendix provides the full moment system and proofs. 3 Monte Carlo The Monte Carlo uses a staggered-adoption panel with covariate-driven treatment timing, heterogeneous dynamic treatment effects, and a never-treated group. The complete data-generating process is reported in the appendix. We compare five ATT-oriented estimators that share the same treated-entry-weighted target: LPDID-RW, LPDID-RW + X, LPDID-RA, DRLPDID-IPT, and DRLPDID. The designs vary regarding which nuisance component is aligned with the DGP: both nuisance components aligned, outcome-regression misspecified, propensity-score misspecified, and both nuisance components misspecified. Table 1 reports bias, RMSE, and pointwise 95% coverage for the average post-treatment effect over 500 replications at N=500 ; the corresponding N=250 results are reported in Appendix Table . Table 1: Monte Carlo: average post-treatment effect ( N=500 ) Scenario Estimator Bias RMSE Coverage Both nuisances aligned LPDID-RW -2.505 2.735 0.430 LPDID-RW + X 0.064 0.104 0.866 LPDID-RA 0.004 0.079 0.944 DRLPDID-IPT -0.208 0.229 0.502 DRLPDID 0.004 0.083 0.942 OR misspecified LPDID-RW -3.561 3.747 0.100 LPDID-RW + X -0.073 0.587 0.948 LPDID-RA -0.108 0.577 0.958 DRLPDID-IPT -0.308 0.634 0.904 DRLPDID 0.011 0.634 0.924 PS misspecified LPDID-RW -1.786 2.104 0.634 LPDID-RW + X 0.061 0.102 0.872 LPDID-RA -0.004 0.078 0.960 DRLPDID-IPT -0.157 0.188 0.690 DRLPDID -0.003 0.082 0.964 Both nuisances misspecified LPDID-RW -3.543 3.712 0.098 LPDID-RW + X -0.159 0.606 0.944 LPDID-RA -0.214 0.614 0.938 DRLPDID-IPT -0.382 0.682 0.896 DRLPDID -0.068 0.663 0.916 Notes: All entries refer to the average post-treatment effect. Results are based on 500 Monte Carlo replications, with pointwise cluster-robust confidence intervals. The corresponding N=250 panel is reported in Appendix Table . Three patterns stand out. First, LPDID-RW is consistently unstable across scenarios once local selection and untreated trends depend on covariates. Second, when the outcome-regression component is aligned with the DGP, LPDID-RA remains highly competitive, and DRLPDID stays very close to it, rather than uniformly dominating it. Third, propensity-score misspecification is the setting in which the doubly robust