Breaking Bad Financial Habits: How LLM Conversations Correct Financial Misconceptions

Jillian Ross, Eric So, Andrew W. Lo · 2026

Read Breaking Bad Financial Habits: How LLM Conversations Correct Financial Misconceptions by Jillian Ross, Eric So, Andrew W. Lo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-27022.txt.

Introduction

Ross, So and Lo test whether designed language models can durably correct financial misconceptions, across three pre-registered studies. Financial myths carry real economic costs, from panic selling to avoiding equity markets, yet resist correction. Two factors prove necessary. First, corrective intent: models merely discussing a myth correct no better than unassisted self-review, and undirected chats can entrench myths. Second, recipient receptivity: answers pitched below a participant's sophistication seem less credible and correct far less.

Catalog record

CREATORJillian Ross, Eric So, Andrew W. Lo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68682
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.27022

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Breaking Bad Financial Habits: How LLM Conversations Correct Financial Misconceptions Jillian Ross, Eric So, Andrew W. Lo Abstract Financial misconceptions carry direct economic costs, from panic selling to equity market avoidance, yet they are notoriously resistant to correction. Traditional financial literacy interventions are constrained by cost, reach, and a persistent gap between knowledge and behavioral change. Across three pre-registered studies, we find that purposefully designed LLMs can durably correct financial misconceptions. Critically, two factors are necessary for this effect. First, corrective intent: LLMs prompted only to discuss a misconception produce corrections no better than unassisted self-reflection, and undirected LLM conversations can actively entrench misconceptions. Second, recipient receptivity: financial concepts are often foreign to the investors who misapply them, and LLM responses pitched below a participant’s financial sophistication are judged as less credible and produce substantially weaker corrections. LLMs thus offer a scalable alternative to traditional financial literacy intervention, but only when designed with both factors in mind. keywords Large Language Models, Chatbots, Financial Literacy, Financial Advice 1 Introduction Behavioral economics has established that the cognitive errors underlying poor financial decisions are remarkably resistant to correction, not merely because people lack information, but because the heuristics driving those errors feel locally valid and are largely impervious to awareness of their presence. Systematic deviations from rational decision-making are not random noise, but instead predictable patterns, rooted in cognitive shortcuts that served adaptive purposes in other contexts, but misfire reliably in financial ones ( 29 ; 7 ) . Crucially, this awareness offers little protection to the individual; warning people about anchoring bias, for instance, does little to prevent them from anchoring ( 31 ) . These dynamics are particularly consequential for personal financial well-being, where persistent misconceptions translate directly into costly behaviors: buying high and selling low, concentrating risk in single assets, panic-selling during downturns, and avoiding equity markets altogether ( 6 ; 4 ) . Financial misconceptions and their stubborn persistence compound their damage over decades, making their correction both more economically imperative and, in principle, more tractable, given the availability of verifiable expert knowledge. Yet basic financial concepts are often foreign to the very investors who misapply them, and effective correction must account for what they actually understand. Correcting such misconceptions at scale has proven difficult. Traditional financial literacy interventions, such as educational programs, informational campaigns, and one-on-one advising, are constrained by cost, reach, and a persistent gap between knowledge acquisition and behavioral change ( 26 ; 30 ; 21 ) . Human financial advisors can provide personalized guidance, but are inaccessible to many households due to their cost, and are themselves subject to behavioral biases and conflicts of interest that limit advice quality ( 25 ) . Automated robo-advisors are more scalable, but offer generic recommendations without the interactive capacity to address individual misconceptions through dialogue ( 12 ; 18 ) . The result is a persistent literacy gap that falls hardest on the populations with the most to gain from long-term equity participation ( 22 ) . Large language models (LLMs) offer a theoretically promising alternative. Unlike static educational content, conversational LLMs can engage individuals interactively, tailor counterarguments to their reasoning, and adapt in real time to the concerns of a particular user. This combination of personalization and scale has no clear precedent in the history of financial education. A growing body of evidence supports the persuasive potential of LLM-mediated dialogue more broadly: conversational LLMs have been shown to shift beliefs through interactive exchanges that tailor counterarguments to individual reasoning ( 2 ; 3 ; 1 ) , and conversational LLMs have been found to outperform incentivized human persuaders in changing minds when provided with basic personal information ( 28 ) . Most relevantly, Costello et al. 11 demonstrate that brief, tailored LLM conversations can reduce conspiracy beliefs by approximately 20%, with effects persisting two months later. While 11 demonstrate that tailored LLM dialogue can shift conspiracy beliefs, financial misconceptions have a different etiology, and thus need to be studied separately. Conspiracy beliefs are identity-expressive, sustained by motivated distrust of institutions, and resistant to falsification by design. In contrast, financial misconceptions arise from domain-general cognitive heuristics—availability, representativeness, extrapolation from recent experience—that are recognizably wrong once expert reasoning is brought to bear ( 29 ; 7 ) . Because they reflect faulty reasoning rather than motivated belief, financial misconceptions are in principle more tractable targets for evidence-based persuasion, but only if the intervention engages the reasoning process rather than merely supplying information ( 31 ; 26 ) . Additionally, financial misconceptions are less obviously problematic than conspiracy theories, and an unprompted LLM may default to sycophantic validation rather than correction. Which mechanisms are necessary and sufficient in the objectively correctable case remains an open question. We address this question through three pre-registered studies. We propose that two factors are necessary to correct misconceptions with LLMs: corrective intent , whether the intervention delivers an explicit corrective intent rather than merely directing attention toward the misconception, and recipient receptivity , whether the user perceives the source as credible and its arguments as legible given their level of financial sophistication. In the first study, we establish the baseline corrective effect of LLM-mediated dialogue and document its moderation by chatbot perception. In the second, we directly probe the role of corrective intent by comparing an LLM prompted to persuade against three alternatives: an LLM prompted only to engage, a self-articulation condition in which participants elaborate their own reasons for holding the misconception, and an unrelated distractor baseline. In the third, we examine the role of recipient receptivity by testing whether tailoring response complexity to a participant’s financial sophistication improves corrective efficacy. We find that both factors matter: correction requires not only that the LLM be directed to persuade, but that its arguments be legible and credible to the specific user it is addressing. 2 Results First, we find that LLM-mediated conversations produce large, statistically significant reductions in financial misconceptions that persist at least 10 days after the intervention. This effect is moderated by baseline conviction and chatbot perception: the correction is greatest when misconceptions are strongly held and when participants perceive the chatbot as credible and convincing, with lower financial literacy predicting stronger attributions of credibility. Second, explicit persuasive intent is a necessary condition for misconception correction, and the absence of explicit intent is not merely ineffective but actively harmful: an LLM prompted only to discuss a misconception produces corrections statistically indistinguishable from unassisted self-reflection, while undirected LLM engagement raises entrenchment rates. This suggests that conversational elaboration of a held misconception strengthens it in the absence of a deliberate counter-argument. Third, tailoring response complexity to a participant’s financial sophistication improves the efficacy of misconception correction. 2.1 LLMs durably correct financial misconceptions Study 1 establishes the baseline corrective effect of LLM-mediated dialogue. A key design challenge in measuring this effect is separating a genuine misconception correction from more general belief movements that might occur for any strongly held statement following any kind of structured engagement. To address this, participants interacted with the LLM about both their most strongly held financial misconception and their most strongly held neutral statement, a belief with no objectively correct answer. If an LLM is specifically correcting financial misconceptions rather

Read the complete text