Bootstrap Inference in Nonlinear Panel Data Models with Interactive Fixed Effects
Haoyuan Xu, Wei Miao, Geert Dhaene, Jad Beyhum, [6pt] Department of Economics, KU Leuven · 2026
Read Bootstrap Inference in Nonlinear Panel Data Models with Interactive Fixed Effects by Haoyuan Xu, Wei Miao, Geert Dhaene, Jad Beyhum, [6pt] Department of Economics, KU Leuven (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-26826.txt.
Introduction
Xu and three colleagues show that the parametric bootstrap gives valid inference for nonlinear panel models with interactive fixed effects, where maximum likelihood estimates run biased. The bootstrap mirrors the estimator's large-sample spread, giving nearly unbiased estimates and confidence sets with nearly right coverage. They also propose a changed-scale bootstrap interval that works better in small samples. Simulations back the theory, and a study of firm innovation spillovers from tech and product markets rounds out the paper.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Haoyuan Xu, Wei Miao, Geert Dhaene, Jad Beyhum, [6pt] Department of Economics, KU Leuven |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 147247 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.26826
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bootstrap Inference in Nonlinear Panel Data Models with Interactive Fixed Effects Thanks: We are grateful to participants at the KU Leuven Applied Micro PhD Workshop (2024), the Netherlands Econometric Study Group (2025), the International Association for Applied Econometrics Conference (2025), the International Panel Data Conference (2025), and the Asian Summer School in Econometrics and Statistics (2025). We thank Andrei Zeleneev and Weisheng Zhang for sharing the codes from 66 . Haoyuan Xu acknowledges funding from the Research Foundation–Flanders (FWO) fellowship no. 1179925N. Wei Miao acknowledges financial support from the China Scholarship Council (grant no. 202306130036). Jad Beyhum acknowledges financial support from the Research Fund KU Leuven (grant STG/23/014). Haoyuan Xu, Wei Miao, Geert Dhaene, Jad Beyhum, [6pt] Department of Economics, KU Leuven Abstract The maximum likelihood estimator in nonlinear panel data models with interactive fixed effects is biased. Several bias correction methods, such as analytical and jackknife approaches, have been proposed to enable valid inference. This paper shows that the parametric bootstrap also enables valid inference in such models. In particular, we show that the parametric bootstrap replicates the asymptotic distribution of the maximum likelihood estimator. Therefore, it yields asymptotically unbiased estimates and confidence sets with asymptotically correct coverage. We also propose a transformation-based bootstrap confidence interval that delivers improved finite-sample performance. Simulation results support the theoretical findings. Finally, we apply the proposed method to examine technological and product market spillover effects on firms’ innovation behavior. Keywords: Panel data, interactive fixed effects, incidental parameter bias, bootstrap inference, skewness correction. 1 Introduction The importance of unobserved heterogeneity for economic analysis and the design of effective public policies has long been recognized by economists and policymakers. Interactive fixed effects models provide a flexible and powerful framework for capturing such heterogeneity. Unlike classical one-way fixed-effect models ( 19 ) , which rely on agent-specific scalar parameters to absorb unobserved heterogeneity, interactive fixed-effect models allow for multidimensional latent components, thereby accommodating substantially richer forms of unobserved heterogeneity. Moreover, these models naturally incorporate aggregate time-varying shocks through a factor structure, a feature that is particularly important in macroeconomic and financial applications ( 60 ) . Since the seminal contributions of 57 and 8 , a large body of research has developed the theoretical foundations of linear panel data models with interactive fixed effects. These advances have, in turn, facilitated the widespread empirical adoption of such models. Nevertheless, linear specifications are often inadequate in applied work. In many empirical settings, the outcome variable is discrete, rendering linear models potentially misspecified. Recent work, such as 51 , demonstrates that nonlinear factor models can provide a more appropriate framework in a wide range of empirical applications. In contrast to the extensive literature on linear factor models ( 8 ; 52 ; 53 ) , the theoretical foundations of nonlinear panel data models with interactive fixed effects are less developed. A notable recent contribution is 21 , who study the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) in nonlinear panel models with interactive fixed effects. Their approach treats the individual-specific and time-specific effects as fixed parameters and jointly estimates these nuisance parameters together with the common parameters of interest. This fixed-effect framework is attractive because it imposes no restrictions on the joint distribution of the unobserved effects and the covariates, thereby reducing the risk of model misspecification. 21 derive the asymptotic distribution of the MLE of the common parameters and show that it is asymptotically biased due to the incidental parameter problem. Importantly, this source of bias differs fundamentally from that encountered in linear factor models estimated by least squares, where bias in the slope parameters arises from cross-sectional and time-series dependence in the error terms ( 8 ) . To address the incidental parameter bias, they propose analytical and jackknife corrections that eliminate the leading bias term and enable asymptotically valid inference. Relatedly, 33 study the MLE in binary choice models with interactive fixed effects and heterogeneous slope parameters. Although analytical and jackknife bias corrections are asymptotically valid, their finite-sample performance may be limited in empirically relevant settings with moderate sample sizes and short time dimensions, as commonly encountered in microeconomic panel datasets. Analytical bias corrections rely on estimating the asymptotic bias and subtracting the estimated bias from the original estimator. However, as shown in 21 , the asymptotic bias is a highly intricate expression involving up to third-order derivatives of the likelihood function, which may be numerically unstable. The split-panel jackknife method is comparatively straightforward to implement but can suffer from efficiency losses in finite samples ( 38 ) . Moreover, analytical and jackknife corrections rely on normal approximations to construct confidence intervals, which may be inaccurate. Recently, 42 show that the parametric bootstrap delivers asymptotically valid confidence intervals without explicit bias correction in one-way fixed-effect nonlinear panel data models, and that bootstrap-based inference can exhibit superior finite-sample performance when the time dimension is short. In this paper, we extend the parametric bootstrap approach to nonlinear panel data models with interactive fixed effects. Unlike analytical bias-correction methods, the parametric bootstrap avoids the explicit calculation of the asymptotic bias by approximating it through parametric bootstrap simulations. An important feature of the parametric bootstrap, emphasized by 42 , is that it yields asymptotically valid inference even without preliminary bias correction. Confidence intervals are constructed directly from the quantiles of the bootstrap distribution rather than relying on normal approximations, which can improve accuracy in finite samples. We show that these properties of the parametric bootstrap also hold in nonlinear panel data models with interactive fixed effects. Simulations corroborate our theoretical results. Furthermore, simulations indicate that bootstrap-based confidence intervals tend to be conservative in finite samples, with coverage probabilities often exceeding the nominal level and thus reflecting a systematic overestimation of uncertainty. This finding is in line with 42 , who document similar behavior in one-way fixed-effect models. They also note that iterating the bootstrap procedure can improve coverage accuracy, but at a substantial computational cost. To mitigate this issue, we follow the bootstrap literature on skewness correction ( 41 ) and apply a monotone transformation to the estimator prior to constructing confidence intervals. The transformation reduces skewness in the bootstrap distribution, and intervals are then obtained from the transformed scale and mapped back. By the bootstrap delta method ( 61 ) , this procedure preserves asymptotic validity while improving finite-sample performance. Simulations show that the resulting intervals are substantially shorter and achieve more accurate coverage. All bias correction methods considered in this literature rely on the MLE, i.e., the global maximizer of the loglikelihood function, being obtainable. However, in practice, the loglikelihood function in nonlinear factor models is generally non-concave, implying that standard optimization algorithms may converge to a local instead of the global maximizer. 21 propose an EM-type algorithm, which guarantees convergence only to a local maximizer. They suggest using multiple starting values to increase the probability of reaching the global maximizer; nevertheless, this strategy does not ensure global maximization and can substantially increase the computational burden. More recently, 66 propose a computationally efficient two-step estimator based on nuclear-norm penalization, which is shown to attain the global maximizer with probability one and is asymptotically equivalent to the MLE. In this paper, we adopt their two-step estimator in conjunction with the bootstrap procedure,