Taking a Bite Out of the Forbidden Fruit: Characterizing Third-Party Iranian iOS App Stores

Amirhossein Khanlari, Amir Rahmati · 2026

Read Taking a Bite Out of the Forbidden Fruit: Characterizing Third-Party Iranian iOS App Stores by Amirhossein Khanlari, Amir Rahmati (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-26343.txt.

Introduction

Khanlari and Rahmati mapped Iran's underground iOS app stores, which serve users barred from Apple's store by sanctions and censorship. From over 1,700 app packages across three major stores, they documented distribution tricks, login methods, and evasion tactics. The ecosystem brims with Iran-only apps, cracked software, unauthorized sales of paid content, and embedded tracking and piracy libraries. The study also prices developer revenue lost to piracy and flags security risks in altered binaries.

Catalog record

CREATORAmirhossein Khanlari, Amir Rahmati
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70946
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.26343

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Taking a Bite Out of the Forbidden Fruit: Characterizing Third-Party Iranian iOS App Stores Amirhossein Khanlari, Amir Rahmati Abstract . Due to U.S. sanctions and strict internet censorship, Iranian iOS users are barred from accessing the Apple App Store and developer services. In response, despite violating Apple’s developer terms, a thriving underground ecosystem of third-party iOS app stores has emerged to serve Iranian users. This paper presents the first comprehensive empirical study of these clandestine app stores. We document how these stores operate, including their distribution mechanisms, user authentication processes, and evasion techniques. By collecting and analyzing more than 1700 iOS application packages and their metadata from three major Iranian third-party app stores, we characterize the ecosystem’s size, structure, and content. Our analysis reveals a significant presence of Iranian-exclusive apps, widespread distribution of cracked apps, unauthorized monetization of paid content, and embedded third-party tracking and piracy libraries. We also uncover a notable overlap among financial, navigational, and social apps that exist solely in this ecosystem, reflecting the unique digital constraints of Iranian users. Finally, we quantify the potential revenue losses for developers due to piracy and document security and privacy risks associated with altered binaries. Our findings highlight how sanctions, censorship, and enforcement gaps have enabled a parallel app distribution ecosystem with complex socio-technical implications. 1. Introduction Iranian iOS users and developers face a unique set of challenges stemming from the intersection of international sanctions and strict domestic internet censorship. Since the imposition of U.S. sanctions ( 77 ) and the subsequent tightening of digital restrictions by Iranian authorities ( 28 ) , access to the official Apple App Store and related developer services has been systematically blocked for individuals residing in Iran. This exclusion not only prevents ordinary users from creating Apple Accounts to download, update, or purchase both free and paid apps but also effectively bars Iranian developers from distributing their products on a global platform. As a result, a parallel ecosystem of clandestine third-party iOS app stores has emerged to fill this market gap. These underground platforms fill a critical void but also introduce a host of new risks, including unauthorized app distribution, widespread piracy, and significant security and privacy vulnerabilities for users. Furthermore, the expansion of unauthorized app stores undermines the safety and reliability of the mobile application landscape for millions of Iranians, exposing them to altered, outdated, or potentially malicious binaries that Apple’s review processes would otherwise filter out. For developers, these stores facilitate the unauthorized monetization of paid content and the widespread distribution of cracked apps, resulting in substantial revenue losses and further discouraging legitimate development efforts in the region. Previous studies have explored mobile application ecosystems, app security, and the effects of sanctions on digital services. Research has focused on app removal dynamics ( 53 ) , the accuracy of privacy labels ( 70 ) , and malware detection ( 59 ; 38 ) in both official ( 4 ) and alternative ( 87 ) Android markets. In the Iranian context, research on third-party Android app stores, such as Cafebazaar ( 52 ) , has examined user behavior and app quality. Broader studies ( 49 ) have investigated the impact of internet censorship on access to information and online services. However, there remains a substantial gap in the literature regarding the operation, content, and risks of clandestine third-party iOS app stores. Specifically, no prior research has systematically documented how these platforms operate, the nature of their app inventories, or the implications for user security and developer revenue on iOS devices. To address these gaps, this paper presents Havva 1 1 1 Havva is the Persian name for Eve , the first system to enable the comprehensive empirical study of clandestine iOS app stores. Using Havva, we systematically characterize the operational practices, distribution mechanisms, and evasion techniques employed by three popular clandestine Iranian iOS app stores, and analyze the scale, structure, and content of their app inventories. We choose to focus our work toward the iOS ecosystem, which is often overlooked in favor of Android ( 54 ) . We provide a data-driven analysis that quantifies both the scope of the problem and its broader implications. Furthermore, we directly compare apps obtained from third-party sources with those from official channels, revealing the unique socio-technical dynamics that have emerged in response to sanctions and censorship within the iOS ecosystem. Havva combines several complementary approaches to ensure a fully automated, robust, and thorough analysis. It incorporates custom web crawlers to systematically collect metadata and application packages from three major Iranian third-party iOS app stores, capturing a wide range of information, including app names, versions, categories, user ratings, and download statistics, as well as tracking update frequencies, pricing strategies, and the prevalence of cracked or pirated content. To supplement this, we utilized the iTunes API and custom scripts to retrieve data on corresponding apps from the official App Store, enabling direct cross-platform comparisons. Havva decrypts IPA binaries using a companion jailbroken device, allowing for in-depth static analysis. This approach enables Havva to examine app characteristics, external libraries, embedded domains, and binary modifications. Our results reveal a robust and resilient parallel app market that is both a response to and a consequence of sanctions and censorship. We document a significant presence of Iranian-exclusive apps. Approximately 510 apps out of 1767 analyzed (nearly 29%)—many of which are essential for the daily life of Iranians but are absent from the official App Store due to policy restrictions. This ecosystem also features the widespread distribution of global apps in cracked or pirated forms, with at least 159 cracked apps and 308 paid apps circulating without authorization, free of charge. Notably, we identify substantial overlaps among apps offered by the stores in critical categories such as finance, navigation, and social networking, leaving Iranian users with no alternative but to rely on these third-party platforms. Our analysis quantifies the potential revenue losses for developers, estimating that piracy and unauthorized distribution in just two stores could exceed $5.26 million in lost revenue. We also highlight security and privacy risks, with static analysis revealing that 489 apps included unauthorized provisioning profiles and over 180 apps contained piracy libraries such as Cydia Substrate and iGameGod. These findings underscore the complex interplay between geopolitical policy, local innovation, and user behavior and advance our understanding of how digital markets adapt and evolve under conditions of constraint. Ultimately, this work provides a foundation for future research and policy discussions on the unintended consequences of sanctions and censorship in the global digital ecosystem. Our contributions are summarized as follows: • We develop Havva, the first system to enable a comprehensive empirical study of clandestine iOS app stores. • We study three clandestine Iranian iOS app stores over 5.5 months, gaining unique insights into their operational practices, app catalog, and user base. • We explore the cracked application catalog in these stores to quantify the potential revenue losses and analyze altered binaries and embedded third-party tracking libraries. To facilitate future research, our dataset will be available to other researchers upon request, subject to fair use provisions and appropriate data use agreements. For more information, please view the appendix. 2. Background 2.1. Sanctions Since the 1979 revolution and the breakdown of diplomatic

Read the complete text