Scaling in Supersonic Turbulence: Energy Spectra and Fluxes using High-Fidelity Direct Numerical Simulations
Harshit Tiwari, Dhananjay Singh, Mahendra K. Verma, Rajesh Ranjan · 2026
Read Scaling in Supersonic Turbulence: Energy Spectra and Fluxes using High-Fidelity Direct Numerical Simulations by Harshit Tiwari, Dhananjay Singh, Mahendra K. Verma, Rajesh Ranjan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-26290.txt.
Introduction
Tiwari and three colleagues ran high-resolution simulations of forced compressible turbulence across Mach numbers up to 3. On a 1024-cubed grid with a GPU solver, they tracked how energy moves between swirling and squeezing motions as speed rises. The swirling spectrum steepened toward Burgers scaling while the squeezing spectrum flattened, driven by transfer from swirling to squeezing modes. Injection rates hinged on forcing type, not Mach number, while dissipation shifted toward squeezing modes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Harshit Tiwari, Dhananjay Singh, Mahendra K. Verma, Rajesh Ranjan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70263 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.26290
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Scaling in Supersonic Turbulence: Energy Spectra and Fluxes using High-Fidelity Direct Numerical Simulations Harshit Tiwari, Dhananjay Singh, Mahendra K. Verma, Rajesh Ranjan Abstract Supersonic turbulence plays a central role in astrophysical and high-speed engineering flows, yet the mechanisms governing its energy transfers remain poorly understood. In this work, we present high-resolution ( 1024 3 1024^{3} ) direct numerical simulations (DNS) of forced compressible turbulence across a wide range of turbulent Mach numbers, from low subsonic to high supersonic ( M t = 0.2 M_{t}=0.2 – 3.0 3.0 ). Using the GPU-accelerated solver DHARA with a seventh-order, low-dissipation Targeted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (TENO) scheme, we accurately resolve both fine-scale turbulent eddies and sharp shock fronts. Our results reveal a fundamental change in the energy cascade in the supersonic regime. As M t M_{t} increases, the rotational kinetic energy spectrum steepens from a Kolmogorov-like k − 5 / 3 k^{-5/3} scaling toward a Burgers-like k − 2 k^{-2} scaling. Conversely, the compressive energy spectrum becomes noticeably shallower, deviating from Burgers-like scaling. We show that these spectral modifications are driven by a dominant cross-scale transfer of energy from solenoidal to compressive modes within the inertial range, accompanied by non-negligible contributions from pressure dilatation. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the scaling laws for the root-mean-square compressive velocity ( U C U_{C} ) and the compressive energy flux ( Π C \Pi_{C} ) closely mirror those of classical Burgers turbulence. We also examine how key energy transfer statistics vary with forcing and M t M_{t} . While the normalized solenoidal and compressive energy injection rates exhibit only weak dependence on M t M_{t} , they depend strongly on the ratio of rotational to compressive forcing amplitudes. Furthermore, as M t M_{t} increases, the normalized rotational dissipation decreases, whereas both the normalized compressive dissipation and pressure dilatation increase. These findings elucidate the intermodal energy cascade mechanisms, advancing the understanding of energy transfers in supersonic turbulence. I Introduction Supersonic turbulence is of fundamental interest in astrophysics Carroll 2006 ; Elmegreen and Scalo 2004 ; Mac Low and Klessen 2004 , space physics, and high-speed aerodynamics von Kármán 1941 . Prime examples include supernovae explosions, star formation in molecular clouds Krumholz and McKee 2005 ; Padoan and Nordlund 2011 , inertial confinement fusion Fujisawa 2021 , and hypersonic propulsion Ingenito and Bruno 2010 . However, despite this significance, the mechanisms of energy transfer in supersonic flows remain poorly understood. Unlike incompressible turbulence, supersonic flows involve intricate interactions among shocks, acoustic modes, and nonlinear advection, leading to fundamentally distinct physical behaviors. Previous studies have also shown that supersonic turbulence ( M_{t}>1 ) differs markedly from the subsonic regime ( M_{t}<1 ) Kritsuk et al. 2007 ; Schmidt et al. 2009 ; Federrath 2013 . For incompressible turbulence, a well-established theoretical framework describes the velocity spectrum Kolmogorov 1941a ; Kolmogorov 1941b ; Kraichnan 1959 ; Dar et al. 2001 ; Verma 2004 ; Lesieur 2008 . A cornerstone of this theory is Kolmogorov’s spectrum, E(k)=K_{\mathrm{Ko}}\,\epsilon_{\mathrm{Ko}}^{2/3}\,k^{-5/3} , which characterizes the distribution of kinetic energy among wavenumbers k in the inertial range, where \epsilon_{\mathrm{Ko}} is the constant energy flux and viscous dissipation rate, and K_{\mathrm{Ko}} is Kolmogorov’s constant Kolmogorov 1941a ; Kolmogorov 1941b ; Lesieur 2008 . Moreover, the energy cascade in incompressible turbulence is fundamentally driven by local interactions, meaning that energy transfer occurs primarily between neighboring wavenumber shells Kraichnan 1971 ; Domaradzki and Rogallo 1990 ; Zhou 1993a ; Zhou 1993b ; Verma et al. 2005 . The primary flow structures in incompressible turbulence consist of eddies and vortical tubes. In contrast, compressibility fundamentally modifies both the flow organization and the underlying dynamics Kida and Orszag 1990 ; Lele 1994 ; Erlebacher et al. 1990 ; John et al. 2021 , leading to the emergence of shocks and localized compression regions as dominant features. A key distinction from the incompressible regime is the presence of a dilatational (compressive) velocity component and associated pressure dilatation effects Kida and Orszag 1990 ; Sarkar 1992 ; Miura and Kida 1995 ; Praturi and Girimaji 2019 . Consequently, the velocity field can be decomposed into solenoidal (divergence-free) and dilatational (curl-free) components, which exhibit distinct dynamics. Their relative contributions are primarily governed by the turbulent Mach number, defined as M_{t}=U/C_{s} , where U is the root-mean-square velocity and C_{s} is the average speed of sound Kida and Orszag 1990 ; Jagannathan and Donzis 2016 ; Sarkar 1992 . In the nearly incompressible limit [ (\delta\rho)/\rho\rightarrow 0 ], Zank and Matthaeus 1991 demonstrated that both velocity and density fields follow the k^{-5/3} spectrum. At subsonic Mach numbers, numerical simulations have shown that the rotational velocity component exhibit nearly Kolmogorov-like k^{-5/3} spectrum, while the compressive component exhibits a steeper k^{-2} scaling due to the presence of shocklets Kida and Orszag 1990 ; Wang et al. 2013 ; Schmidt and Grete 2019 ; Sakurai and Ishihara 2024 . Supersonic turbulence is considerably more complex than its subsonic counterpart, and its scaling laws remain a subject of active debate despite extensive numerical investigations. Kritsuk et al. 2007 reported that, for isothermal turbulence at M_{t}\approx 6 , both solenoidal and compressive components exhibit a k^{-2} velocity spectrum, while the kinetic energy spectrum follows a shallower k^{-3/2} scaling. They further proposed a modified Kolmogorov framework based on the density-weighted velocity \rho^{1/3}\mathbf{u} , whose spectrum was found to be largely insensitive to variations in Mach number. It should be noted, however, that these results were obtained under isothermal and inviscid assumptions, neglecting viscous dissipation and compressive heating. Subsequent work by Schmidt et al. 2009 reported similar trends, indicating that the influence of forcing is reduced when expressed in terms of \rho^{1/3}\mathbf{u} . In contrast, Federrath et al. 2010 demonstrated a strong sensitivity of the scaling behavior to the nature of turbulent forcing, showing that the spectra of \mathbf{u} , \rho^{1/2}\mathbf{u} , and \rho^{1/3}\mathbf{u} all steepen under compressive driving, with the kinetic energy spectrum approaching a k^{-2} scaling. Furthermore, Federrath 2013 established consistency between these numerical observations and the exact relations derived by Galtier and Banerjee 2011 , which predict a scaling of \rho^{1/3}\mathbf{u}\propto k^{-19/9} in the presence of strong compressive modes. These observations highlight that the scaling laws of supersonic turbulence remain unresolved and are strongly influenced by both the forcing mechanism and the degree of compressibility. Energy fluxes in supersonic turbulence are another aspect that is poorly understood. Note that incompressible flows have a single energy flux, which is constant in the inertial range. Compressible turbulence, unlike its incompressible counterpart, has multiple energy fluxes for its different velocity components and internal energy Wang et al. 2013 ; Schmidt and Grete 2019 . Using a coarse-graining framework, Aluie 2011 ; Aluie 2013 showed that kinetic energy transfer in compressible turbulence can remain constant within an inertial range, where nonlinear interactions are dominant. This is possible as long as the pressure-dilatation co-spectrum diminishes faster than k^{-1} . Aluie et al. 2012 provided the first direct evidence for this condition, demonstrating that kinetic and internal energy budgets statistically decouple beyond a transitional coversion scale. Furthermore, Zhao and Aluie 2018 numerically demonstrated that the Favre decomposition is unique in satisfying the inviscid criterion, which ensures that viscous effects remain negligible at these large scales. These findings were