Institutional Floors and Partisan Lenses: Cross-National Online Discourse on Political Violence in France and the United States

Andrew Yen Chang · 2026

Read Institutional Floors and Partisan Lenses: Cross-National Online Discourse on Political Violence in France and the United States by Andrew Yen Chang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-26245.txt.

Introduction

Chang compared online talk about political violence in France and the United States across three killings, from 2020 through 2026. French discussion centered on victims' civic roles, while American discussion split along partisan lines. Comparing two French cases with different victim profiles, he found support for a civic floor: French institutions sustain a shared civic baseline whatever a victim's politics.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrew Yen Chang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36958
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.26245

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Institutional Floors and Partisan Lenses: Cross-National Online Discourse on Political Violence in France and the United States Andrew Yen Chang Abstract This paper studies how online discussion shapes and assesses political violence across different settings, particularly how moral evaluation, as a social perception, varies across institutional contexts 8 . We take France and the United States as case studies, both democracies, and three incidents of political violence: the 2020 killing of Samuel Paty in France, the 2025 shooting of Charlie Kirk in the United States, and the 2026 murder of Quentin Deranque in France 19 ; 13 ; 24 . Using publicly available posts on Instagram and Facebook, we use GPT-4o-mini for zero-shot classification and social network analysis 20 ; 23 . Our research demonstrates clear cross-national differences in how moral values are perceived, the emotional intensity expressed, the framing of institutions, and the structure of semantic networks. In France, the discourse tends to focus on the victim’s civic role rather than their political affiliation, whilst in the U.S., the conversation is more ideologically divided, with moral judgments frequently reflecting partisan lines. By comparing the two French cases—a civic victim (Paty) versus the politically-affiliated victim (Deranque)—we find evidence consistent with the civic floor hypothesis , which demonstrates France’s institutional framework upholds a cross-partisan civic baseline regardless of the victim’s political ties. We conclude by analyzing the implications of computational social perception for multilingual NLP and by exploring moral judgment in cross-national digital political discourse. 1 Introduction Political violence stirs up many sentiments that reflect institutional values and norms, culture, and social identity 8 ; 12 . The frames for which the public sphere evaluates such events reveal the normative structural makeup and mindsets of their societies 14 ; 8 . Online discourse provides a window into this phenomenon. Social media platforms serve as new public spheres for moral judgment, emotional responses, and blame attribution. By analyzing how public actors respond to instances of political violence, we can investigate how differing democratic value structures mold cultural interpretation at scale. An important distinction aids such investigation: the violent event and its interpreted meaning. The event is an objective occurrence, while its perceived meaning—as a civic atrocity, a partisanship issue, religious extremism, or a tragic accident—is not simply determined by the event’s occurrence, but rather by the perception and interpretation that observers construct through their respective cultural and institutional structures 8 . These frameworks themselves can be viewed as lenses colored by culture and institutions 8 . This paper studies this specific perception layer, treating evaluation and framing as forms of social perception that depend on societal norms, and that in turn inform us about the societies from which they emerge 8 . Using three cases of political violence across two national contexts—France and the United States—we examine the 2020 beheading of French schoolteacher Samuel Paty, the 2025 shooting of American conservative activist Charlie Kirk, and the 2026 murder of French far-right activist Quentin Deranque 11 ; 19 ; 13 ; 24 . The former two are used in cross-national comparison, whilst the latter serves as an empirical test of whether observed differences reflect national value structures rather than merely the victim’s type. We pose three research questions. RQ1: How do public discussions of political violence differ between France and the United States in terms of dominant frames? RQ2: How do these frames reflect their respective political and cultural models? RQ3: What do differences in discourse composition reveal about how political violence is perceived and debated in each public sphere? Our main argument is that the meaning of political violence is constructed through pre-existing institutional and cultural values and norms. French discourse exhibits a civic-republican structure that fosters strong moral consensus regardless of the type of victim. American discourse displays a divided partisanship structure that leads to evaluative fragmentation. These differences are observable in online public posts. 2 Theoretical Background French and American Democratic Value Structures France and the U.S. have similar yet distinct models of democratic institutions and values 11 . This creates a stable environment to evaluate their respective differences in response to acts of political violence. The French Fifth Republic, under the motto liberté, égalité, fraternité , is organized as a unitary state representing its people through Universal Republicanism, wherein citizens are regarded as equal individuals while group identities receive less institutional recognition 10 . Laïcité —the French concept of secularism that removes religion from public institutions—is unique to France compared to the United States, where religion is tolerated in public life 25 . France also enforces Race-Blind governance, with the collection of racial data strictly restricted 18 . Together, these principles center political legitimacy on the Republic, its civic duties, and state authority 17 . The United States operates under a contrasting structure with extensive Freedom of Speech and Expression, Freedom of Religion in public life, and a pluralist identity model that allows racial, religious, and cultural identities as legitimate bases for political mobilization 7 . The decentralized federal system allows for great contrasts in governmental views, and political legitimacy may center on party partisanship, expressive freedoms, and divided group-based identities rather than a unified civic universalism 22 . The Republican State as Institutional Embodiment of Civic Value A theoretical premise of our institutional floor hypothesis is French republican theory, which holds that the state and civic values are not separate domains 6 . The Republic is not merely a form of government, but an institution embodying the general will and civic universalism of the French people 6 . French rights discourse is classically articulated through republican constitutionalism and the Declaration, rather than primarily through the U.S.-style bill-of-rights framing. Rights are defined by the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen and the Constitution of the Fifth Republic, and upheld by the state 6 . Laïcité is not a private preference but a constitutional obligation enforced by the state 25 . Civic education is similarly administered by the state as a republican duty 6 . Such a tradition carries direct empirical implications. When a violent event occurs in France, the republican response is expressed in French civic language— laïcité , republican values, civic duty—or in state authority language through discourse on governmental response, institutional legitimacy, and state protection. Both are expressions of the French Republic. We therefore conceptualize institutional activation as discourse that invokes either civic universalist norms or state authority as the guardian of those norms. This framing is rooted in French Republican Theory and is not constructed post hoc from the data. The Deranque case serves as a stress test of whether this dual notion of civic and institutional response is elevated for a partisan victim relative to a civic victim such as Paty. Social Media as a Public Sphere of Moral Judgment Social media platforms can signal and amplify moral judgment, emotional responses, and blame attribution following acts of political violence, making these values now quantifiable at scale 14 . We integrate computational frame detection and comparative political theory into a unified methodology for studying social perception across national contexts. Moral Foundations and Evaluative Framing Moral Foundation Theory notes that care/harm, fairness, loyalty, authority, and sanctity are universal moral dimensions but vary in

Read the complete text