Viscous Settling of Bravais Unit-Cells Preprint: APS/insert.number

Sebastian Bürger, Harshit Joshi, S Ganga Prasath, Rahul Chajwa, Rama Govindarajan · 2026

Read Viscous Settling of Bravais Unit-Cells Preprint: APS/insert.number by Sebastian Bürger, Harshit Joshi, S Ganga Prasath, Rahul Chajwa, Rama Govindarajan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-26189.txt.

Introduction

Bürger and four colleagues study how porous Bravais lattice unit-cells settle in viscous fluid, varying pore share at will through lattice spacing. Tests in a tank find sinking speed fits a power law in solid fraction with the same power for all cell shapes. Analysis and models show tank walls shaping that power; fixing for wall effects with a Faxen boundary term gives a lower power for open settling. That helps estimate sedimentation fluxes of complex objects in clouds and oceans, though irregular natural aggregates remain open.

Catalog record

CREATORSebastian Bürger, Harshit Joshi, S Ganga Prasath, Rahul Chajwa, Rama Govindarajan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52928
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.26189

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Viscous Settling of Bravais Unit-Cells Preprint: APS/insert.number Sebastian Bürger, Harshit Joshi, S Ganga Prasath, Rahul Chajwa, Rama Govindarajan Abstract We study experimentally and theoretically the Stokesian settling of a well-known class of porous shapes: Bravais lattice unit-cells, whose porosity we vary controllably by changing their lattice spacing. In our experiments, conducted in a square cuboidal container with its long-axis aligned along gravity, we find that the settling speed U U and the solid fraction ϕ s \phi_{s} of these lattice units obey a power-law relationship U ∝ ϕ s γ U\propto\phi_{s}^{\gamma} , with an exponent γ = 0.43 \gamma=0.43 independent of their shape. To understand the observed scaling exponent, we analytically and numerically investigate the settling of the simple cubic structure under different approximations. We find that the walls of the container, though far from the sinking object, have a defining effect. Our Stokesian boundary integral simulations show that the Faxén boundary correction captures the wall-effects accurately and enables us to discount the wall-effect from the experimental data, yielding a power-law exponent γ = 0.30 \gamma=0.30 for settling in an unbounded domain. The power-law relating sinking speed and porosity is a step towards predictively understanding the sedimentation fluxes of complex objects in the clouds and the oceans. However, the applicability of this universal scaling to irregular and biologically richer aggregates found in nature remains an open direction. I Introduction Sedimentation of particles through viscous fluids is ubiquitous in geophysical and industrial processes Guazzelli and Morris 2011 ; Clift et al. 2005 ; Zhao et al. 2025 , such as the settling of marine snow Alldredge and Gotschalk 1988 , microplastics DiBenedetto 2026 and other biogenic particles Boyd et al. 2019 in the oceans, precipitation in reacting flows Nabika et al. 2019 , and the sedimentation of ice crystals in cirrus clouds Mitchell et al. 2008 . The limited predictability of settling speeds of particles in the ocean Laurenceau‐Cornec et al. 2019 and the atmosphere Mitchell et al. 2008 leads to significant uncertainties in climate models. In the limit of small Reynolds number, the motion of isolated rigid particles is governed by the Stokes equation Kim and Karrila 2005 ; Happel and Brenner 1983 , where geometric effects enter through boundary conditions imposed on the particle surface, and the settling velocity is determined by a balance between gravitational forcing and viscous drag. Figure 1 : (a,b) Schematic of the experimental setup and the settling porous object: an Simple Cubic lattice made of spheres of diameter 2a=6\ \mathrm{mm} which are connected by cylindrical rods of diameter 2b=1\ \mathrm{mm} . The centre-to-centre distance between spheres is d . (c) Seven Bravais lattice structures we investigate in our sedimentation experiments: (i) Simple cubic (SC), (ii) body-centred cubic (BCC), (iii) tetrahedron, (iv) hexagonal close-packed (HCP), (v) face centred cubic (FCC), (vi) octahedron and (vii) square-based pyramid structures. Each of them contains one black-painted sphere to track the settling path, speed and orientation. For BCC and FCC, the lattice constant d refers to the unit cell size and not to the nearest centre-to-centre distance of spheres. (d) Sequence of SC-lattices with increasing lattice constant d , from left to right in \mathrm{mm} : 8, 10, 12, 16. The scale bar is 5 \mathrm{mm} . In many cases, settling objects possess an internal structure that allows fluid to pass through them. This internal geometry-dependent resistance is often described through lumped quantities such as porosity Bear 2013 . A common approach is to describe such objects as effective porous media, in which the flow is governed by Darcy’s law or its viscous extension, the Brinkman equation Brinkman 1947 . In this framework, the fluid motion within the porous aggregate is governed by a linear relationship between the pressure gradient and the filtration velocity, effectively treating the microstructure as a uniform resistive medium. Darcy’s law Brinkman 1947 and its later variants have been used to estimate drag and settling velocities of permeable particles, beginning with the classical work on sedimentation of polymers Debye and Bueche 1948 , and developed further for the analyses of slow bulk flow through stationary low porosity beds Happel and Brenner 1983 . However, these studies do not account for boundary effects from the no-slip conditions and viscous shear at the outer boundary of a non-spherical settling object. Subsequent models based on the Brinkman equation allow for the matching of interior and exterior flow fields but introduce effective parameters like permeability which must be supplied, in the form of an empirical relationship with porosity Starov and Zhdanov 2001 . An alternative approach treats porous object as a collection of particles interacting hydrodynamically. Through pairwise addition of forces and torques, building on the two-body solution Stimson and Jeffery 1926 , this approach has been used to study many-particle systems, enabling the calculation of close-packed conglomerates Cichocki and Hinsen 1995 ; Lasso and Weidman 1986 , periodic array of spheres Sangani and Acrivos 1982 , and random or fractal aggregates Alabrudziński et al. 2009 ; Binder 2012 . In these systems, relationships between settling velocity and porosity or fractal dimension have been proposed for specific models and geometries, but it remains unclear how universal these relationships are across geometry of finite–porosity objects. In the present work, we study the coupling between flow and geometry of a sinking porous object, using a minimal system which allows for precise control of porosity through a single tunable parameter. We experimentally study low Reynolds number sedimentation and flow of 3D printed unit cells of Bravais lattices Kittel and Masi 1954 with equal sized spheres at the lattice nodes. The spheres are connected by slender rods to create rigid ball-and-stick structures. By varying the lattice spacing, the porosity of the structure is tuned systematically while preserving its symmetry. We experimentally find that the settling speed U as a function of the solid volume fraction \phi_{s} follows a power-law scaling U\propto\phi_{s}^{\gamma} , when U is appropriately rescaled. Remarkably, this power law exponent \gamma=0.43 is measured across the different unit-cell structures, suggesting an underlying universality in the settling behavior. To understand these observations, we conduct a detailed theoretical analysis of one of these shapes, the simple cubic, using a hierarchy of models of increasing fidelity, including analytical approximations based on Stokeslet interactions and slenderbody theory Kim and Karrila 2005 , as well as numerical simulations using Stokesian Dynamics (SD) Brady and Bossis 1988 and Boundary Integral Methods (BIM) Pozrikidis 1992 . These calculations reveal that the presence of confining boundaries has a significant effect on the measured settling velocity, even when the container dimensions are large compared to the particle size. We show that Faxén boundary corrections Happel and Brenner 1983 are sufficient for eliminating this effect from the experimental data, allowing us to infer the corresponding unbounded behaviour, which is geophysically relevant. After accounting for wall effects, the power-law exponent reduced to 0.30 , a scaling that is independent of the internal geometry of the object in an unbounded fluid. II Experiments II.1 Experimental setup The settling experiments were conducted in a 75 cm high glass tank with a square cross-section of width 15 cm. The settling particles were fabricated in a Formlabs stereolithography printer, with resin density \rho_{s}=1.164 g/cc. Each object represents

Read the complete text