A Comprehensive Analysis of Accuracy and Robustness in Quantum Neural Networks
Ban Q. Tran, Duong M. Chu, Hai T.D. Pham, Viet Q. Nguyen, Quan A. Pham, Susan Mengel · 2026
Read A Comprehensive Analysis of Accuracy and Robustness in Quantum Neural Networks by Ban Q. Tran, Duong M. Chu, Hai T.D. Pham, Viet Q. Nguyen, Quan A. Pham, Susan Mengel (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-26110.txt.
Introduction
Tran and five colleagues compare three hybrid quantum neural networks: convolutional, recurrent, and vision-transformer variants built on variational circuits. They test generalization, accuracy, and robustness. All three shine on low-feature data such as handwritten digits but degrade sharply on high-feature datasets. The convolutional variant proves weakest on high-dimensional data. Traditional architectures resist adversarial noise better, while the transformer variant best withstands quantum measurement, channel, and finite-shot noise. That split should guide model choice on today's noisy hardware.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ban Q. Tran, Duong M. Chu, Hai T.D. Pham, Viet Q. Nguyen, Quan A. Pham, Susan Mengel |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68092 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.26110
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Comprehensive Analysis of Accuracy and Robustness in Quantum Neural Networks Ban Q. Tran, Duong M. Chu, Hai T.D. Pham, Viet Q. Nguyen, Quan A. Pham, Susan Mengel Abstract . Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has recently emerged as a highly promising research frontier. Within this domain, Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs),characterized by Variational Quantum Circuits (VQCs) at their core and featuring layers of quantum gates optimized by classical algorithms, have garnered significant attention. However, a rigorous and exhaustive evaluation of their practical performance remains largely incomplete. In this study, we conduct a comprehensive comparative analysis of three prominent hybrid classical-quantum architectures: Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks (QCNN), Quantum Recurrent Neural Networks (QRNN), and Quantum Vision Transformers (QViT), focusing on the critical dimensions of generalization, accuracy, and robustness. Our findings provide novel insights that address previous evaluative gaps. Notably, while these models exhibit exceptional performance on low-feature datasets such as MNIST, their learning efficacy degrades significantly when transitioned to high-feature datasets. Furthermore, convolutional-based models like QCNN appear less effective on high-dimensional data than other machine learning architectures. Additionally, while all models are susceptible to adversarial noise, traditional architectures, such as recurrent and convolutional networks, demonstrate superior resilience. Conversely, in the presence of quantum noise, the transformer-based architecture proves its strength by maintaining high robustness against measurement noise, channel noise, and finite-shot effects, whereas other architectures suffer marked performance declines. These results provide a granular perspective on the current state of the field and underscore the critical importance of tailoring model selection to the constraints of contemporary Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) environments. 1. Introduction Quantum Machine Learning ( 7 ) has recently become quite popular in machine learning due to exhibiting superiority of quantum computing over classical computing. The core component of QML, quantum deep learning (QDL) models ( 45 ) or mainly QNNs that are constructed from parameterized quantum circuits (PQCs) ( 10 ) , have demonstrated effectiveness for downstream tasks in various domains, including computer vision, natural language processing, graphs, and more ( 28 ) . Research on QDL and QNNs has demonstrated that these models can achieve very high accuracy with a low amount of training data, significantly less than comparable classical deep learning models ( 9 ) . However, the evaluation of the generalization errors and accuracy of QNN models is not thoroughly studied. Furthermore, the resilience of quantum models against external attacks through intentional noise and quantum noise remains an issue that requires further thorough investigation. In this research, we conduct a comprehensive comparative analysis and assessment of QNN models, providing a complete perspective on the capabilities and characteristics of QNN models, including but not limited to generalization, error rate, accuracy, adversarial robustness, and average fidelity. Previous research implementations have demonstrated the potential of QNN models to surpass classical neural networks by achieving notably impressive accuracy ( 25 ; 9 ; 42 ) . However, the vast majority of existing studies evaluate this quantum advantage only on limited, custom-made datasets or low-feature benchmarks, such as MNIST and Fashion-MNIST. Consequently, this research provides readers with a more comprehensive perspective on the true performance of hybrid classical-quantum neural networks when applied to high-feature datasets. Furthermore, recent findings suggest that the most effective quantum deep learning models currently employ hybrid architectures ( 8 ) , so we have selected three prominent QNN frameworks, QCNN, QViT, and QRNN, for our experiments. We seek to test the accuracy and generalization of these models rigorously when scaled beyond standard input conditions, while also investigating the impact of adversarial attacks and quantum noise on robustness and in the context of real-world quantum hardware deployment. Our research demonstrates that QNNs, specifically Hybrid Classical-Quantum Neural Networks (HCQNNs), exhibit excellent performance on low-feature datasets like MNIST but suffer significant performance degradation when trained on high-feature datasets, such as CIFAR-10. QViT achieves high accuracy; however, this accuracy comes at the cost of a large number of trainable parameters and a significantly higher Lipschitz constant than QRNN and QCNN. For high-feature data, QRNN slightly outperforms QCNN in terms of learning outcomes. Regarding generalization error, QCNN and QRNN show a consistent trend: error scales with training set size, whereas QViT fails to exhibit this behavior due to a divergence between practical and theoretical bounds. In terms of robustness, QRNN and QCNN exhibit strong resilience against adversarial attacks, while QViT remains susceptible to such interference. Interestingly, under quantum noise conditions QViT is the least affected model, whereas QCNN is heavily impacted by Amplitude Damping, and QRNN shows diminished performance across all four noise types: Depolarizing, Bit Flip, Phase Flip, and Amplitude Damping. The article’s content is organized as follows. Section 2 presents Related Work, while Section 3 explains Theoretical Background. The parameter setup and experimental results are described in Section 4. The conclusion (5) is given in the final section. 2. Related Works and Motivation A significant body of prior research has focused on evaluating QNN models, which can be categorized broadly into two types: theoretical assessments and empirical evaluations. On the theoretical front, several survey and review papers have been published to provide readers with an in-depth understanding of the fundamental nature of these models and the inherent challenges they face in practical applications. Several studies have introduced the fundamentals of QML, providing detailed explanations of its underlying mechanisms and offering theoretical justifications for why QML algorithms can achieve quantum speedup over their classical counterparts ( 7 ; 45 ; 38 ; 11 ; 21 ; 14 ; 37 ; 26 ; 1 ) . These studies primarily consist of theoretical surveys and reviews that explore the fundamental nature and core components of current models. They provide critical discussions on the strengths and weaknesses of various architectures, as well as the inherent challenges facing QML and QNNs within the constraints of the contemporary NISQ era. On the other hand, empirical evaluations remain relatively scarce, with only a limited number of studies providing detailed comparisons between QNNs and classical neural networks (CLNN) regarding specific properties ( 12 ; 8 ; 2 ; 46 ; 3 ) . Furthermore, comprehensive benchmarks that assess multiple criteria simultaneously remain scarce. During this research, we identified several studies that align with our current direction, which we use as a baseline for our evaluation. Bowles et al. ( 8 ) conducted extensive experiments on twelve popular quantum machine learning models across six binary classification tasks. Their findings concluded that quantum models have yet to demonstrate absolute superiority over their classical counterparts across all evaluated dimensions. More detailed experiments, such as those conducted by I-Chung Chen et al. ( 12 ) , empirically tested two quantum models—quantum self-attention and QRNN—across natural language processing (NLP) and image processing tasks. Their study included a rigorous comparison between the quantum versions and their classical counterparts, ultimately demonstrating that the quantum-enhanced models achieved superior performance. Another comparative study evaluated the performance of randomized classical networks versus QNNs, alongside a direct comparison between CNNs and QCNNs ( 3 ) , on supervised binary image classification tasks using the MNIST dataset. Their statistical results did not indicate any clear evidence of absolute superiority for any specific model. Furthermore, the study revealed that the degree of gate entanglement and quantum correlation does not necessarily correlate in