Nature and nurture: the dynamical ages of in situ and accreted globular clusters in the Milky Way

Eugenio Carretta · 2026

Read Nature and nurture: the dynamical ages of in situ and accreted globular clusters in the Milky Way by Eugenio Carretta (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-26012.txt.

Introduction

Carretta presents a census of dynamical ages for 93 Milky Way globular clusters, with Gaia progenitor data. Most accreted clusters are dynamically young: 61 percent, against 38 percent for in situ clusters. Excluding low-energy clusters of ambiguous origin, the young share among ex situ clusters rises to 70 percent. A Kolmogorov-Smirnov test finds low-energy clusters indistinguishable from in situ bulge and disc clusters. Yet low-energy clusters sit firmly on the satellite side of the age-metallicity relation. Carretta suggests their progenitor plunged in very early.

Catalog record

CREATOREugenio Carretta
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19987
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.26012

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Nature and nurture: the dynamical ages of in situ and accreted globular clusters in the Milky Way Preprint: E. Carretta, [email protected] Eugenio Carretta Abstract The bifurcated age-metallicity relation of globular clusters (GCs) in the Milky Way (MW) shows that GCs are either originated in situ or accreted into the Galaxy from former satellites of the MW. The effects of the Galactic tidal field can leave signatures on the dynamical evolution and structural properties of GCs. We present a homogeneous census of dynamical ages for a sample of 93 GCs in the MW, coupled with the knowledge of their common progenitors from the chemo-dynamical parameters from the Gaia mission, unavailable some years ago. We found that the majority of accreted GCs (61%) is dynamically young. This percentage drops to 38% for in situ GCs. Excluding the enigmatic low-energy (LE) GCs, with ambiguous origin, the fraction of dynamically young ex situ GCs raises to 70%. A two tail Kolmogorov-Smirnov test shows that the distribution of dynamical ages of LE GCs cannot be distinguished from the distribution of in situ bulge and disc GCs. Yet, the LE GCs are firmly located on the satellite branch of the age-metallicity relation. An explanation may be that the progenitor of LE GCs plunged very early into the MW, so that the gravitational field of the MW had time enough to act on the associated GCs. The dynamical ages offer a statistically robust evidence corroborating the scenario of an early accretion proposed by several recent studies on the origin of LE GCs. 1 Introduction The age-metallicity relation (AMR) of globular clusters (GCs) in the Milky Way (MW) is bifurcated in two parallel branches (e.g. Leaman et al. 2013, VandenBerg et al. 2013). The metal-rich branch hosts GCs with disk-like kinematics and consists of clusters formed in situ in the Galaxy. The metal-poor GCs with halo-type orbits were suggested to be formed in low mass satellite systems later accreted, contributing to the hierarchical formation history of the Milky Way. This double formation channel is strongly substantiated by a wealth of chemo-dynamical studies exploiting the data from the astrometric Gaia mission (e.g. Massari et al. 2019, Kruijssen et al. 2019, Forbes 2020, Callingham et al. 2022, Malhan et al. 2022). On the other hand, characteristic radii of GCs are used to investigate their internal dynamics and the effects of the global MW gravitational field on the long term dynamical evolution of these stellar systems (e.g. Meylan and Heggie 1997, Piatti et al. 2019). In the present letter we present, for a large sample of MW GCs, a scrutiny of dynamical ages, defined as the ratio between the chronological ages and the half-mass relaxation times. Since the latter differ from cluster to cluster depending on the local conditions (e.g. the distance from the central potential well, the average density of the regions inhabited by the cluster), different stages of dynamical evolution can be shared by GCs with the same chronological ages. We add here the knowledge on the progenitors of different groups of GCs gained thanks to the Gaia mission, unavailable some years ago, although some attributions are still uncertain. Most notable is the case of the low energy (LE) GCs (Massari et al. 2019, hereinafter M19), whose origin is still attributed to an in situ component or to a former accretion event variously dubbed as Kraken (Kruijssen et al. 2020: K20), Koala (Forbes 2020), or Heracles (Horta et al. 2021, see also Massari et al. 2026). The combination of these different pieces of information seems to show that the overwhelming majority of accreted GCs is dynamically young, as opposed to in situ GCs that show a range in dynamical ages. Moreover, the pattern of dynamical ages for LE GCs is similar to those of in situ disc and bulge GCs, although LE GCs are firmly located on the satellite branch of the AMR. 2 Dataset and main results Following Dalessandro et al. (2024), we computed the ratio N_{h}=t_{age}/t_{rh} as a proxy of the clusters’ dynamical age. The chronological ages t_{age} are from Kruijssen et al. (2019). While these ages are from the combination of three other studies, this is currently the most homogeneous set of ages available for the largest number of GCs. We adopted the half-mass relaxation time t_{rh} from the publicly available catalogue by Baumgardt et al. (2019) and as in Dalessandro et al. (2024) we defined dynamically young GCs as those with N_{h}<8 . This is the threshold at which the chemically polluted population in GCs, which is the largest stellar component in GCs (e.g. Carretta et al. 2010), shows a clear change in the average velocity distribution, moving from a radially anisotropic velocity distribution to an isotropic pattern in dynamically old GCs. Dynamical ages are listed in Table 3 . Figure 1: The dynamical ages of GCs with different progenitors (different colours or symbols and labels in each panel) as a function of the metallicity [Fe/H]. White crosses indicate GCs with uncertain classification (see text). The line for N_{h}=8 is also shown. Two deviant GCs are also indicated in the MD and H99 groups. Figure 2: Cumulative distributions of dynamical ages for groups of GCs with different progenitors. In each panel the p-values of the two-sample K-S test are listed. The proposed GC membership to different progenitors is adopted mainly from the classification of M19. For GCs with uncertain progenitors, we adopt the assignments from others studies, as annotated in Table 3 , where these GCs are marked with flag=0 and with a white cross on their symbol in the figures. These ambiguous attributions do not change the main comparison between in situ and accreted GCs, simply shifting the GCs from a progenitor to another. In our sample we collected 26 in situ GCs (15 main disc MD, 11 main bulge MB) and 67 accreted GCs, 22 from Gaia-Enceladus (GE), 10 from the Helmi streams (H99), 5 from Sequoia (SEQ), 7 from Sagittarius (SGR), 9 from the high energy group (HE), and 14 from the low energy group (LE). The only relevant difference with M19 that may concern the present analysis is NGC 6441. This is a LE GC in M19, that we assigned to the MB group, as clearly shown by its chemistry (e.g. Gratton et al. 2006, Carretta and Bragaglia 2023) and its location on the in situ branch of the AMR (see Fig. 5 , the discussion in K20, and Massari et al. 2023). Our main result is shown in Fig. 1 , where we plot the dynamical ages of GCs with different progenitors as a function of the metallicity [Fe/H]. The majority of accreted GCs are dynamically young. All GCs associated to Sagittarius and Sequoia are below N_{h}=8 like all GCs attributed to the Helmi streams, except for E3 1 1 1 Kruijssen et al. (2020) classified this GC as ambiguous and possibly member of the main Galaxy, excluding it from their analysis. and most of the unassigned group of HE GCs with high orbital energy. A real spread in dynamical ages is shown only among in situ GCs, with MB GCs presenting the most dynamically evolved GCs. The only GCs on the satellite branch of the AMR showing a spread

Read the complete text