Substructure in redMaPPer clusters and its impact on X-ray morphology and scaling relations

R. Tuomainen, A. Finoguenov, J. Comparat, L. Doubrawa · 2026

Read Substructure in redMaPPer clusters and its impact on X-ray morphology and scaling relations by R. Tuomainen, A. Finoguenov, J. Comparat, L. Doubrawa (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-25770.txt.

Introduction

Tuomainen and three colleagues quantify substructure in optical galaxy clusters from the redMaPPer catalog, and its effect on X-ray shapes and scaling relations. They run the HDBSCAN clustering algorithm on probabilistic memberships, then cross-match clusters with the eROSITA X-ray morphology catalog. Substructure appears in about 40 percent of clusters, and a quarter of the sample shows a richness share above 35 percent. Optical substructure tracks disturbed X-ray shapes closely, most for high-mass clusters. Clusters with substructure also drive stronger redshift evolution in luminosity-richness scatter.

Catalog record

CREATORR. Tuomainen, A. Finoguenov, J. Comparat, L. Doubrawa
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61194
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.25770

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Substructure in redMaPPer clusters and its impact on X-ray morphology and scaling relations R. Tuomainen, A. Finoguenov, J. Comparat, L. Doubrawa Abstract Context. Numerical simulations of hierarchical structure formation predict that galaxy clusters retain significant dark matter substructure, a signature of their ongoing assembly. This substructure is traced by both the spatial distribution of member galaxies and perturbations in the hot intracluster medium. Merging events significantly impact the thermodynamic state of clusters, introducing scatter in observable mass scaling relations and thereby affecting their use as precision cosmological probes. Aims. We statistically quantified the prevalence and properties of substructure in optical galaxy clusters and directly investigated its impact on X-ray morphology and scaling relations, leveraging new data from the DECaLS Legacy Survey and the SRG/eROSITA all-sky survey. Methods. We applied the hierarchical density-based clustering algorithm HDBSCAN to the redMaPPer galaxy cluster catalog to identify and characterize substructure from the probabilistic membership assignments. This provides a refined membership catalog and a classification of each cluster as containing substructure or not. We then cross-matched this sample with the eROSITA X-ray morphology catalog to correlate optical substructure with a comprehensive set of X-ray morphological parameters. Finally, we analyzed the scaling relation between X-ray luminosity and optical richness for clusters with and without substructure. Results. Substructure is a common feature, present in approximately 40% of clusters; a quarter of the full sample exhibits a fractional contribution to richness in excess of 35%. We find a highly significant correlation between optical substructure and disturbed X-ray morphologies, a trend that is strongest for high-mass clusters. The clusters with substructure also drive a stronger redshift evolution in the scatter of the L X − λ L_{X}-\lambda relation. At low redshifts ( z < 0.2 z<0.2 ), they display a systematically higher X-ray luminosity at fixed richness compared to relaxed systems. Conclusions. We demonstrate that substructure identification with redMaPPer is viable and essential for enhancing the precision of cluster cosmology. We attribute the enhanced effect of mergers on X-ray properties at low redshifts to the increased density contrast of low-redshift cool cores and longer substructure survival times, which are possibly due to the suppression of disruptive mixing by effects such as magnetic draping. At lower cluster richness, a discordance between X-ray morphology and the merging state indicates a growing relative importance of active galactic nucleus feedback in governing X-ray morphology. 1 Introduction Galaxy clusters are powerful cosmological probes, providing competitive constraints on the growth of structure in the late-time Universe ( 6 , for a recent review, see) . The utility of clusters as cosmological probes hinges on accurately relating their observable properties—such as X-ray luminosity, gas mass, and optical richness—to their total mass. This is achieved through scaling relations. However, these relations exhibit significant intrinsic scatter, a substantial fraction of which is attributed to the complex merger history and dynamical state of clusters ( 21 ) . Clusters grow hierarchically through mergers and accretion ( 13 ) , and these events can disrupt the thermal equilibrium of the intracluster medium (ICM), alter the gravitational potential, and induce transient features in the measured ICM properties ( 31 ; 46 ) . A critical manifestation of this dynamical activity is the presence of substructure. In the optical regime, substructure reveals itself as infalling groups of galaxies within a cluster’s halo ( 11 ) . In the X-ray regime, it is evidenced by asymmetries, shocks, and cold fronts in the hot gas ( 23 ) , as well as direct detections of the intragroup medium of infalling groups ( 16 ) . Identifying and characterizing this substructure is therefore not merely a taxonomic exercise but a crucial step in understanding the assembly history of clusters and in controlling the systematic biases that currently limit the precision of cosmological constraints ( 32 ) . This focus on substructure is motivated by a critical challenge in cluster cosmology: current studies are systematics-limited. As shown by 6 , cosmological constraints become inconsistent when using X-ray luminosity versus optical richness, indicating a significant bias. 9 identified that a primary driver of this discrepancy is the correlation between optical richness and the large-scale environment, potentially due to variations in cluster formation time affecting the richness–mass relation. The advent of large, uniform surveys has revolutionized this field. In the optical, algorithms like redMaPPer ( 34 ) applied to the Legacy Surveys ( 10 ) have cataloged millions of clusters and their member galaxies. In the X-ray, the eROSITA (extended ROentgen Survey with an Imaging Telescope Array) instrument aboard the Spectrum-Roentgen-Gamma (SRG) mission ( 33 ) is providing the first all-sky X-ray survey since ROSAT, yielding a vast catalog of clusters with detailed morphological information ( 2 ; 35 ) . This multiwavelength dataset enables, for the first time, a statistically robust investigation of substructure across a large population of clusters. We leveraged these new datasets to perform a comprehensive study of substructure in galaxy clusters. We applied the hierarchical density-based clustering algorithm HDBSCAN ( 4 ; 26 ) to the redMaPPer galaxy cluster catalog to identify substructure based on the spatial distribution of probabilistically assigned member galaxies. We then cross-matched these optical clusters with their X-ray counterparts in the first eROSITA All-Sky Survey (eRASS1; 27 ) and analyzed their X-ray morphological properties using the largest set of morphological parameters compiled to date ( 35 ) . Finally, we investigated the impact of substructure on the scaling relation between X-ray luminosity and optical richness. The paper is structured as follows: In Sect. 2 we describe the substructure analysis of the redMaPPer catalog and present the analysis of the matched eROSITA clusters. In Sect. 3 we present the results of our analysis and discuss their implications. We conclude in Sect. 4 . Throughout the paper we assume a flat \Lambda cold dark matter cosmology with H_{0}=70 km s -1 Mpc -1 and \Omega_{m}=0.3 . Uncertainties are quoted for the 68\% confidence level. 2 Data and methods 2.1 redMaPPer catalog The main sample for this study comprises 4,029,875 optical clusters identified in the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys ( 20 ) at redshifts z<1 using the redMaPPer algorithm ( 34 ) . In this catalog, each galaxy is assigned a probabilistic membership, and a cluster’s total richness ( \lambda ) is calculated as \lambda=\frac{S}{1-f}\cdot\sum p_{\text{mem}}, (1) where S is a scale factor that corrects for the survey-limiting magnitude, f is the masking fraction, and \sum p_{\text{mem}} is the sum of membership probabilities. Since partial cluster coverage can bias substructure detection—a primary focus of this study—we imposed quality cuts of S<1.3 and f<0.2 to select only well-surveyed systems. While this reduces the final sample size by 13%, it ensures the reliability of our subsequent substructure analysis, for which completeness in absolute cluster number is less critical than data quality for the retained objects. 2.2 HDBSCAN We used the hierarchical density-based clustering algorithm HDBSCAN ( 26 ) , originally developed by 4 , to identify substructure within the redMaPPer cluster catalog. HDBSCAN is run separately for each redMaPPer cluster, and the input data to the algorithm contains only the sky positions of the member galaxies in the projected plane—meaning no color, magnitude, or redshift information is used. The primary parameter affecting the clustering

Read the complete text