A multifluid approach for polydisperse pebble accretion
T. J. Konijn, S.-J. Paardekooper · 2026
Read A multifluid approach for polydisperse pebble accretion by T. J. Konijn, S.-J. Paardekooper (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-25742.txt.
Introduction
Konijn and Paardekooper model planet-building pebble accretion with many pebble sizes at once, using a multi-fluid approach. Most studies assume one pebble size, but real discs hold a range of sizes that drift and accrete at different rates. Two-dimensional FARGO3D runs with several pebble species validate the method against earlier static-disc results. Evolving the gas disc lowers efficiency for high Stokes numbers and raises it for small ones. The protoplanet's disturbance of the gas disc cuts accretion under an MRN solid distribution.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | T. J. Konijn, S.-J. Paardekooper |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73721 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.25742
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A multifluid approach for polydisperse pebble accretion T. J. Konijn, S.-J. Paardekooper Abstract Context. Pebble accretion offers an efficient pathway to form planets, driven by a constant supply of inward drifting mass and an accretion efficiency enhanced by gas drag. While most studies assume a single pebble size (monodisperse), real discs contain a range of sizes (polydisperse), that drift, interact, and accrete at different rates. Aims. We aim to model polydisperse pebble accretion with a fluid approach, validating the method and exploring how gas disc evolution, solid-to-gas back-reaction, and a polydisperse size distribution affect growth. Methods. We use FARGO3D, modified to allow pebble accretion, to run 2D hydrodynamic simulations in a global disc with multiple dust/pebble species representing an underlying continuous pebble size distribution. Results. With our framework of a multifluid approach, we have found values for pebble accretion efficiency consistent with earlier studies for a static gas disc. This confirms that our approach gives an accurate representation of pebble accretion. Evolving the gas disc we find lower efficiencies compared to an unperturbed gas disc for high Stokes number ( ≳ 0.3 \gtrsim 0.3 ) and higher efficiency for smaller St ( ≲ 0.3 \lesssim 0.3 ). This effect is increased for higher planet masses. The accretion rate is mostly dominated by the highest Stokes numbers in our parameter study ( St ∈ [ 10 − 2 , 10 0 ] \mathrm{St}\in[10^{-2},10^{0}] ). The ratio we find between polydisperse and monodisperse pebble accretion rate is higher than previous estimations. Conclusions. We have constructed a multifluid model framework capable of accurately simulating polydisperse pebble accretion consistent with previous studies. This framework has advantages for simulating higher planet masses, as well as modelling multiple pebble species which are coupled to the gas. We find the perturbation of the protoplanet on the gas-disc lowering accretion rate when assuming a MRN-distribution of solids. From particles to fluids, establishing the multifluid framework 1 Introduction The behaviour of solids within protoplanetary discs is key for understanding how planets form. Traditional models suggest that dust particles, initially sub-micron to micron in size, coagulate into aggregates that grow until they reach “pebble” sizes ( 7 , e.g.) . Growth can be halted by barriers such as the fragmentation barrier ( 16 ; 18 ; 9 ) , the bouncing barrier ( 70 ; 15 ) , or the radial-drift barrier ( 68 ; 67 ; 10 ) . Depending on their material properties, some solids are more strongly coupled to the sub-Keplerian gas disc than others. This coupling is the main driving force of planetesimal formation, producing the kilometer-sized precursors of protoplanets. These can form via resonant drag instabilities ( 61 ; 41 ) , of which the streaming instability is the most widely studied in the literature ( 69 ; 29 ; 42 ) . From this point onward, mutual collisions between planetesimals grow the bodies further until the efficient phase of pebble accretion sets in ( 49 ; 28 ; 50 ) . Pebble accretion is extremely efficient mainly for two reasons. First, the marginal coupling of pebbles to the gas greatly enhances the effective accretion radius, as it causes them to spiral inward toward the protoplanet instead of being scattered. Second, the previously mentioned drift barrier provides a nearly constant supply of pebble-sized particles drifting inward from the outer disc. The conventional approach to calculate accretion rates is via a particle approach, in an unperturbed 1 1 1 Unperturbed in this sense means the gaseous disc is not influenced by the gravitational potential of the (proto-)planet. This work also uses the phrase ”static” disc for the same phenomenon: an unperturbed disc. gaseous disc ( 65 , e.g.) . Pebbles are modelled to move through the gas disc under the influence of the gravity (star and planet) and drag. This method has been able to determine the effects that a planet’s eccentricity has on growth ( 39 ) , as well as how the planet’s angular momentum reacts ( 64 ) , and even the growth timescale of a possible companion ( 31 ) . The motion of solids in protoplanetary discs can also be modelled hydrodynamically by treating the dust 2 2 2 Throughout this work, we use the terms dust , solids , and pebbles interchangeably. It refers to all solids in the gaseous disc which we will be treating as a pressureless fluid. as a pressureless fluid. Such approaches have been done both through grid-based methods ( 52 ; 46 ; 5 ; 62 ; 26 ; 38 , e.g.) as well as SPH frameworks ( 34 ; 58 ; 59 , e.g.) . In contrast to Lagrangian particle schemes, the grid-based fluid representation avoids sampling limitations and particle shot noise ( 20 ; 13 ) , and allows the momentum exchange between gas and solids to be handled straightforwardly in the solver. Early investigations of pebble accretion in the context of hydrodynamical gas models perturbed by the planet were done by 47 , using the FARGO code ( 43 ) . Building on this legacy, using the modern FARGO3D code ( 5 ) , pebble flows in a gas disc was investigated by 12 in order to study the torque on embedded planets in the 2D pebble accretion regime. In their study, 2D multifluid simulations were first performed with gas and pebbles. However, the smoothing of the planetary gravitational potential in these simulations prevents pebble accretion from being resolved. To overcome this limitation, the authors introduced a hybrid approach in which pebbles are evolved as Lagrangian superparticles in a steady-state gaseous background obtained from the hydrodynamical simulations. In this setup the gas is not evolved simultaneously with the pebbles, and the back-reaction of the pebbles on the gas is therefore neglected. FARGO3D does, however, allow gas and multiple dust fluids to be evolved self-consistently as a coupled system ( 4 ) . To date, most pebble accretion models have generally assumed a monodisperse particle population, corresponding to a single dust size. Recent work has demonstrated that adopting a polydisperse description can significantly affect the early stages of planet formation, for instance in the acoustic resonant drag instability ( 53 ) , or more specifically the streaming instability ( 55 ; 45 ; 54 ) . Since solids of different sizes drift at different velocities ( 67 ) , the accretion of material in later stages is also expected to differ substantially between the mono- and polydisperse case. Only a handful of studies have examined polydisperse pebble accretion directly ( 40 ; 2 ) . 40 developed an analytical framework for polydisperse pebble accretion, finding that the onset of the Bondi (lower-mass) regime occurs at smaller core masses than in the monodisperse case, reducing the need for planetesimal collisions to reach the pebble accretion phase. Their results also indicated a modest decrease of 3/7 in accretion efficiency in the Hill (higher-mass) regime. An earlier investigation by 2 , based on a viscous one-dimensional disc model, found that polydisperse Hill growth leads to a larger final core mass ( M_{\mathrm{iso}} ). In this work, we develop a hydrodynamical, self-consistent, multifluid framework that models pebble accretion, rather than Lagrangian particles in a static gas-disc. With