The EDM inverse problem: Identifying the sources of CP violation and PQ breaking with electric dipole moments Preprint: CTPU-PTC-26-16
Kiwoon Choi and Sang Hui Im · 2026
Read The EDM inverse problem: Identifying the sources of CP violation and PQ breaking with electric dipole moments Preprint: CTPU-PTC-26-16 by Kiwoon Choi and Sang Hui Im (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-25516.txt.
Introduction
Choi and Im tackle the inverse problem posed by electric dipole moments: which high-scale source of CP violation sits behind a nonzero signal? They sort six classes of CP-violating operators near the QCD scale, including the theta term, that matter for low-energy moments. Each class yields a distinct moment pattern across systems, so measured moments could tell the classes apart. The same measurements could probe the QCD axion vacuum value, telling Peccei-Quinn breaking apart from a mix of CP violation and the QCD anomaly.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kiwoon Choi and Sang Hui Im |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 92014 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.25516
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The EDM inverse problem: Identifying the sources of CP violation and PQ breaking with electric dipole moments Preprint: CTPU-PTC-26-16 Kiwoon Choi and Sang Hui Im Abstract Many extensions of the Standard Model (SM) generically introduce new sources of CP violation, which can induce observable P P -odd and T T -odd permanent electric dipole moments (EDMs) of nuclei, atoms, and molecules. A future observation of nonvanishing EDMs would therefore provide a sensitive probe of physics beyond the SM, while also posing a nontrivial inverse problem: identifying their underlying ultraviolet origin. In this work, we identify six representative classes of CP-violating effective operators near the QCD scale, including the QCD θ \theta -term, that are particularly relevant for low-energy EDMs and can arise in a broad range of SM extensions. We show that these operator classes lead to distinct EDM patterns across different systems, thereby enabling discrimination among them through experimentally measured EDMs. We further emphasize that EDM measurements can shed light on the origin of the vacuum expectation value of the QCD axion. In particular, they may help distinguish whether a nonzero axion vacuum expectation value is predominantly induced by high-scale Peccei–Quinn symmetry-breaking effects, such as those associated with quantum gravity, or by the interplay between beyond-the-SM CP violation and the QCD anomaly. 1 Introduction Despite its tremendous success, the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics requires extension, as it does not contain a viable dark matter candidate and cannot account for baryogenesis (see, e.g., 103 for a review) or neutrino masses. Physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM) that addresses these problems generically introduces new sources of CP violation. Such CP violation can be transmitted to the SM sector, giving rise to sizable P -odd and T -odd permanent electric dipole moments (EDMs) of nuclei, atoms, and molecules 27 ; 22 ; 82 . Roughly speaking, BSM physics at energy scales ranging from the TeV to the PeV scale can induce EDMs that may be observable in near-future experiments 91 . Once nonvanishing EDMs are observed, a central question will be the identification of the underlying ultraviolet (UV) physics responsible for the observed signals. In principle, properties of the underlying UV physics may be inferred, at least partially, from the available EDM data. We refer to the problem of identifying the specific underlying physics responsible for a given set of EDM measurements as the EDM inverse problem . This problem has been investigated in a number of earlier works, both in terms of CP-violating (CPV) operators at the hadronic scale 28 ; 27 ; 54 ; 34 and at higher energy scales 30 ; 36 ; 32 ; 31 ; 26 . In this work, we revisit the EDM inverse problem. We first identify six important classes of CPV operators around the QCD scale ( \sim 1~\mathrm{GeV} ) that are particularly relevant for low-energy EDMs and can arise from broad classes of well-motivated BSM scenarios. These include the QCD \theta -term, which already exists in the SM; three additional classes of hadronic operators associated with the EDMs and chromo-EDMs of light quarks and gluons; and two classes of (semi-)leptonic operators, including the electron EDM. We then demonstrate that the ratios of EDMs of nuclei, atoms, and molecules predicted by these operator classes exhibit distinctive patterns, depending on which class of CPV operators dominates. Our approach is similar in spirit to previous studies 30 ; 36 ; 32 ; 31 ; 26 , but we present updated and more quantitative results by incorporating state-of-the-art theoretical inputs for atomic and molecular EDMs, as well as hadronic observables induced by CPV operators at the QCD scale. An intriguing aspect of EDM physics is its connection to the Peccei–Quinn (PQ) mechanism, which addresses the strong CP problem via the QCD axion 85 ; 105 ; 107 . As discussed in Refs. 32 ; 31 ; 26 , patterns of nuclear and atomic EDMs can provide valuable information about the underlying mechanism responsible for resolving the strong CP problem. Hadronic BSM CPV operators generically induce large quantum corrections to the QCD \theta parameter 79 ; 24 ; 32 ; 31 , thereby spoiling ultraviolet solutions to the strong CP problem, such as the Nelson–Barr mechanism 81 ; 12 . Therefore, if experimentally observed EDM ratios are consistent with predictions from hadronic BSM CPV operators while being inconsistent with those from the QCD \theta -dominated scenario, this would point toward the necessity of an infrared solution to the strong CP problem, such as the PQ mechanism, to explain the smallness of \theta 32 . In our previous work 26 , we generalized and reinterpreted this observation by allowing for the possibility of a simply fine-tuned \theta , and showed that certain classes of hadronic CPV operators, with or without the PQ mechanism, can be distinguished by their characteristic EDM ratios. In particular, we argued that EDM measurements may reveal whether a nonzero vacuum expectation value (VEV) of the QCD axion predominantly originates from PQ-symmetry breaking at high scales, such as quantum-gravitational effects, or from the interplay between hadronic BSM CPV operators and the QCD anomaly. In other words, EDM data may provide insight into the dominant PQ-breaking source beyond the QCD anomaly, which is crucial for understanding the axion quality problem (see, e.g., 39 for a recent review). In the present work, we extend this analysis by including (i) all potentially important BSM CPV operators arising from well-motivated scenarios, (ii) EDMs of light nuclei and diamagnetic atoms targeted by ongoing and planned experiments, and (iii) scenarios in which multiple classes of CPV operators contribute comparably to the observed EDMs. We find that EDM measurements of light nuclei, such as the neutron, proton, deuteron, and helion, are particularly powerful for discriminating among the four classes of hadronic operators, including the \theta -term and the EDMs and chromo-EDMs of quarks and gluons. This observation strongly motivates storage-ring experiments that can directly measure the EDMs of charged light nuclei 5 . In contrast, EDM data from diamagnetic atoms with heavy nuclei, such as 199 Hg, 129 Xe, and 171 Yb, may provide suggestive information about the UV source but are unlikely to be conclusive due to large theoretical uncertainties. Octupole-deformed systems, such as 225 Ra, may offer improved sensitivity in this respect, although still less than that of light nuclei. We also discuss how EDM measurements of two different paramagnetic molecules, such as HfF + and ThO, can disentangle the electron EDM from the electron–nucleon CPV coupling as previously analyzed in 52 , and we further explore the implications for hadronic CPV sources. It should be emphasized that many of the matching relations used to connect CPV operators at the QCD scale to experimentally measured EDMs are subject to intrinsic uncertainties that cannot be reliably quantified with the current level of theoretical understanding of the relevant QCD, nuclear and atomic physics effects. Our results should therefore be interpreted with these uncertainties in mind. Our primary goal is to assess how far one can proceed using the currently available theoretical inputs, while also motivating future theoretical efforts toward a more quantitative understanding of the matching relations relevant for EDMs. This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. 2 , we