Big Dipper, Help Me Find A Way — Dip-hunting at hadron colliders —
Diego A. Baron Moreno, Christoph Englert, Yvonne Peters · 2026
Read Big Dipper, Help Me Find A Way — Dip-hunting at hadron colliders — by Diego A. Baron Moreno, Christoph Englert, Yvonne Peters (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-25407.txt.
Introduction
Baron Moreno, Englert and Peters tackle dip-hunting at hadron colliders, the flip side of bump-hunting. Signal-background interference can wash out bumps and break the narrow-width guess. They flip the task: given a seen pattern, how likely is a BSM scalar source? They train parametric neural nets to learn the likelihood ratio over background and BSM factors. Testing seen data against a scan of a minimal scalar extension of the Standard Model, they give a sound check in perturbative regimes, though BSM recovery stays model-bound.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Diego A. Baron Moreno, Christoph Englert, Yvonne Peters |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42690 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.25407
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Big Dipper, Help Me Find A Way — Dip-hunting at hadron colliders — Diego A. Baron Moreno, Christoph Englert, Yvonne Peters Abstract Destructive interference between signal and background processes poses a fundamental challenge in searches for top-philic scalar resonances, significantly reducing experimental sensitivity to well-motivated extensions of the Higgs sector. Traditional bump-hunting strategies fail in this instance because interference effects invalidate the narrow-width approximation across large regions of the BSM parameter space. As a result, experimental analyses typically rely on detailed simulations to accurately model these effects throughout the full analysis chain. In this work, we consider the inverse problem in a proof-of-principle study: given an observed pattern in a discriminating distribution, what is the likelihood that it originates from a BSM scalar? To address this, we employ parametric neural networks to learn the likelihood ratio as a function of both background and key BSM parameters, based on a ratio-of-signed-mixtures framework. We perform inference by testing the compatibility of observed data with a scan over the parameter space of a minimal scalar extension of the Standard Model. While BSM parameter extraction remains inherently model-dependent, our approach provides a robust diagnostic in perturbative regimes and motivates a complementary strategy of ‘dip-hunting’. This strategy extends traditional bump-hunts and could point the way as we navigate towards future discoveries. 1 Introduction Searches for resonantly produced new physics beyond the Standard Model have, so far, not revealed convincing evidence for the presence of new particles. This outcome is puzzling, as the electroweak scale is a well-motivated interface bridging the Standard Model (SM) to a more complete theory of particle interactions, addressing the SM’s shortcomings. Well-known ways to ‘hide’ the presence of scalar exotics include accidental signal-background interference from new physics that is top-philic Gaemers:1984sj . This includes a wide range of SM Higgs-sector extensions Dicus:1994bm ; Basler:2019nas , which are under active investigation by the experiments at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Any such signal-background interference, if experimentally verified, would be a strong probe of the underlying model dynamics Jung:2015gta ; Frederix:2007gi ; Djouadi:2019cbm ; Carena:2016npr . Furthermore, recent analyses of concrete new physics scenarios that enable a cross-correlation of Higgs signal strength measurements, flavour constraints, and direct search limits point towards an overall destructive interference pattern when the mass resolution of the t\bar{t} system is realistic. Sensitivity to the emerging dip-structures is limited by systematic uncertainties, see the recent Refs. ATLAS:2024vxm ; CMS:2025dzq . Framing of a local excess in an invariant mass distribution is quantitatively possible in the narrow-width approximation when interference is suppressed. Conversely, when interference is significant, the narrow-width approximation breaks down irretrievably. A practical question, therefore, arises: Whilst a local excess can be translated into the presence of a new particle, a local deficiency in data does not directly admit such an interpretation. In this work we address the question of how an observed destructive interference pattern is consistent with a particle interpretation given an expected background hypothesis. This question is not too dissimilar from the traditional approach of correlating a model with a specific final-state analysis, while tracking potential interference effects along the way. ‘Hunting’ such a dip in data is the focus of this work. In parallel, our approach has the potential of opening up a more economical avenue for experimental interpretations. As background distributions are typically difficult to model from first principles, in bump-hunting, they are constrained using a range of data techniques CMS:2020zti ; CMS:2019gwf . Extending this to negative weights that interference-corrected signals are characterised by, we motivate ‘dip-hunting’ to help us find the way to BSM discovery. This paper is organised as follows: In Sec. 2 , we review the interference effects that are sensitivity-limiting in t\bar{t} resonance searches. We also detail our event simulation setup and cross-checks. Section 3 introduces an approach for dip-hunting using a Ratio of Signed Mixtures model Drnevich:2024vfj ; we also detail the network architecture that is used to extract the t\bar{t} dip structure. Section 4 is devoted to results, where we show in a proof-of-principle investigation that dip-hunting becomes possible with the procedure laid out in Sec. 3 . We also comment on model dependencies and the architecture’s robustness, providing pointers for future studies. We conclude in Sec. 5 . 2 Interference in resonant top pair production Interference in gg\to t\bar{t} arises when a significant coupling for an exotic scalar S to top quarks is present. This enables the production via gluon fusion, gg\to S , and the subsequent decay, S\to t\bar{t} . Such signatures directly arise in non-singlet Higgs sector extensions of the SM: The combination of Higgs fields orthogonal to the iso-triplet giving rise to the W,Z gauge boson masses is naturally gauge-phobic. Once the exotic scalar is sufficiently heavy, t\bar{t} final states typically dominate the electrically neutral exotics’ decay phenomenology. Concrete extensions, such as the Two-Higgs-Doublet Model, are therefore particularly susceptible to interference effects, especially after the first Higgs investigations force the 125 GeV Higgs boson towards the alignment limit Basler:2019nas . When these effects are included in the existing experimental searches, they give rise to significant systematic uncertainties ATLAS:2025kmo . From a theoretical point of view, indirect EFT-based analyses of di-top final states are unlikely to obtain competitive constraints to such scenarios given current QCD uncertainty expectations BessidskaiaBylund:2016jvp ; Englert:2019rga . In the following, we will parametrise the exotic scalar through a simplified model {\cal{L}}={\cal{L}}_{\text{SM}}-C_{e}\,\frac{y_{t}}{\sqrt{2}}\,S\,\bar{t}t+{1\over 2}(\partial_{\mu}S)^{2}-{m_{S}^{2}\over 2}S^{2}\ , (1) normalising to the SM’s top quark expectation (via the Yukawa y_{t} ) as typically performed in related experimental analyses. The decay width S\to t\bar{t} (denoted in the following by \Gamma_{S} ) and one-loop gg\to S amplitude are widely documented in the literature, e.g. Georgi:1977gs ; Djouadi:2005gi ; Plehn:2009nd . The decay width is dominantly described by \Gamma_{S}={3C_{e}^{2}m_{t}^{2}\over 8\pi v^{2}}{m_{S}}\left({{1-{4m_{t}^{2}\over m_{S}^{2}}}}\right)^{3/2}\ , (2) with v\simeq 246~\text{GeV} and m_{t}\simeq 172~\text{GeV} . 1 1 1 Ultraviolet finite loop-induced decays S\to gg,\gamma\gamma,\gamma Z increase this decay width at the 1% level. As this does not impact our results, we ignore this small numerical effect in the following. We will limit ourselves to CP-even couplings, but we will Figure 1: Representative Feynman diagrams contributing to signal ( gg\to S\to t\bar{t} )-background ( gg\to t\bar{t} ) interference at leading order. come back to the broader question of model-dependence in Sec. 4.3 . For perturbative choices of the couplings C_{e}\sim 1 , we typically are in a parameter region \Gamma_{S}/m_{S}\lesssim 10\% where the phenomenology is shaped by a characteristic dip structure (see, e.g., ATLAS:2025kmo ), which is our main motivation to focus on the simple extension as a test case. The signal gg\to S\to t\bar{t} amplitude {\cal{M}}_{S} then interferes with the continuum QCD background gg\to t\bar{t} via the latter’s t -channel virtual top exchange diagram, which contains a colour-singlet component (we denote this by {\cal{M}}_{\text{con.},t} ). Focusing on this trivial colour structure alone, the interference arises as (see Fig. 1 ) |{\cal{M}}|^{2}=|{\cal{M}}_{S}|^{2}+2\,\text{Re}\left({\cal{M}}_{S}^{\ast}\,{\cal{M}}_{\text{con.},t}\right)+|{\cal{M}}_{\text{con.},t}|^{2}+\dots\ , (3) where the ellipses contain other background-relevant amplitude pieces, i.e. the colour non-singlet t- and s- channel QCD continuum contributions. Modelling the scalar’s width as a Breit-Wigner distribution is phenomenologically admissible in the perturbative regime \Gamma_{S}\ll m_{S} Goria:2011wa ; Seymour:1995np ; Papavassiliou:1996zn ; Papavassiliou:1997fn ; Englert:2015zra . As the ‘background’ is predominantly a smooth function in this kinematic