A finitary criterion for selfless tracial C*-algebras
Ali Jabbari · 2026
Read A finitary criterion for selfless tracial C*-algebras by Ali Jabbari (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-25382.txt.
Introduction
Jabbari studies selfless tracial C*-algebras, a class first set out by Robert. Such an algebra is known to have strict comparison and a single trace. He proves that for separable tracial C*-algebras, selflessness matches approximate selflessness, a finite test on unitaries. The proof uses a diagonal move in the tracial ultrapower. As a use, he gives a short proof that countable groups with a topologically free extreme boundary are C*-selfless. He also weighs links to nuclearity and Z-stability.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ali Jabbari |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41758 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.25382
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A finitary criterion for selfless tracial C*-algebras Ali Jabbari Abstract . We study the class of selfless C*-probability spaces introduced by Robert. It is known that a selfless tracial algebra has strict comparison and a unique trace. We prove that for separable tracial C*-algebras, selflessness is equivalent to approximate selflessness , a finitary condition: for every finite set F F , every N ≥ 1 N\geq 1 and ε > 0 \varepsilon>0 there exists a unitary u u with | τ ( u k ) | < ε |\tau(u^{k})|<\varepsilon ( 1 ≤ | k | ≤ N 1\leq|k|\leq N ) and | τ ( w ) | < ε |\tau(w)|<\varepsilon for all alternating words w w of length ≤ N \leq N built from centered elements of F F and powers u n u^{n} ( | n | ≤ N |n|\leq N ). The equivalence is established using a diagonalisation argument in the tracial ultrapower. As an application we give a concise proof that countable groups with a topologically‑free extreme boundary are C*-selfless. We also discuss the relation to nuclearity and 𝒵 \mathcal{Z} -stability. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 46L05, 46L10, 46L53, 46L54, 03C20, 46B08 1. Introduction The notion of a selfless C*-probability space was introduced in [ 10 ] . A unital C*-algebra A\neq\mathbb{C} equipped with a state \rho having faithful GNS representation is called selfless if the first-factor embedding (A,\rho)\hookrightarrow(A,\rho)*(A,\rho) is existential in the sense of continuous model theory. Intuitively, a selfless algebra is one that, after passing to a suitable ultrapower, contains a free Haar unitary independent from the diagonal copy of A ; this property lies strictly between being existentially closed and having a central sequence of matrix units, blending aspects of model theory and free probability. Selfless C*-probability spaces enjoy strong structural properties such as simplicity, possessing a unique trace (if tracial), satisfying strict comparison, and possessing the uniform Dixmier property [ 10 ] . Authors in [ 1 ] have obtained deep structural results for reduced free product C*-algebras. In particular, [ 1 ] proves that Voiculescu’s free semicircular algebras S_{n} ( n\geq 2 ) are selfless, and more generally establishes selflessness for a wide class of free products under mild rapid‑decay hypotheses. Those results do not follow from the approximate selflessness characterisation given here; rather they illustrate the power of constructive techniques (filtrations, Khintchine inequalities, asymptotic orthogonality) that are complementary to our model‑theoretic approach. We therefore refer the reader to [ 1 ] for a comprehensive treatment of selflessness in the context of free products. Recently, Hayes et al. [ 5 ] introduced the notion of selfless inclusions of C*-probability spaces and used it to establish selflessness for new families of C*-algebras, including the reduced free unitary compact quantum groups A_{u}(n) ( n\geq 2 ) and the half‑liberated unitary quantum groups A_{u}^{*}(n) . Their methods rely on free complexifications and a Powers–Haagerup–Pisier property, which are complementary to the finitary approach developed in the present paper. More recently, Gao et al. [ 4 ] have proved selflessness for reduced amalgamated free products and HNN extensions of C*-algebras, using a version of Ozawa’s PHP property in the C*-algebraic setting. Their results further expand the class of selfless algebras by addressing amalgamation and graph products, and provide another route to selflessness that is independent of the approximate selflessness characterisation used here. It was proved in [ 9 ] (see also the comprehensive geometric study [ 8 ] ) that all countable discrete groups admitting a minimal topologically‑free extremely proximal action are C*-selfless. The original proof uses a topological tree‑graded space construction. In the present paper we obtain a concise proof of this result by applying our finitary criterion; see Theorem 3 and its proof in Section 4 . The geometric foundations of such boundary actions (Myrberg points, visual boundaries of CAT(0) spaces, Roller boundaries, etc.) are developed in depth in [ 8 ] , and we freely rely on those results for the construction of axial sequences; our contribution is a short, model‑theoretic verification of the approximate selflessness condition. Existential embeddings are global statements that are often difficult to verify directly. A natural goal is to find a finitary, quantitative reformulation that can be tested on generators and relations. This paper provides such a reformulation for separable algebras. We introduce the notion of approximately selfless (Definition 2 ) which only requires, for every finite set and every tolerance, the existence of a unitary satisfying explicit moment conditions. This yields a finitary reformulation of an existential embedding property. Our main result (Theorem 2 ) states that for separable C*-probability spaces with a faithful trace, selflessness is equivalent to approximate selflessness. Value of the finitary criterion. Approximate selflessness provides a finitary, local test for an inherently infinitary (model-theoretic) property. Instead of constructing an existential embedding into an infinite free product, one only needs to produce unitaries that satisfy explicit moment conditions up to arbitrary precision. This makes selflessness accessible to concrete computations and provides a bridge to free probability and asymptotic freeness. The equivalence is obtained by a diagonalisation argument in a tracial ultrapower. The approximate conditions allow us to construct, via a cofinal sequence, a single unitary in an ultrapower that is exactly free from the diagonal copy of A . This yields an existential embedding, and conversely selflessness transfers back through the ultrapower to give the required approximate unitaries. We also discuss the interaction with nuclearity and \mathcal{Z} -stability. While selfless nuclear algebras automatically have strict comparison and a unique trace, it remains an open question whether they are necessarily \mathcal{Z} -stable. We emphasise that the known structural consequences (Theorem 1 ) are due to Robert [ 10 ] ; no claim of \mathcal{Z} -stability is made here. Conceptual position of selflessness. Selflessness is a global property: it requires the first-factor embedding into the free product to be existential. This is weaker than being existentially closed (which would require existential embeddings into any extension), and it is distinct from being strongly self-absorbing (which involves tensor products and central sequences rather than free products). In the tracial setting it is also unrelated to nuclearity: C^{*}_{r}(\mathbb{F}_{\infty}) is selfless and non‑nuclear, while many nuclear algebras fail to be selfless. It implies strict comparison and a unique trace, but it does not obviously entail finite nuclear dimension or \mathcal{Z} ‑stability. The property also appears independent of exactness and of the completely bounded approximation property, though a precise delineation remains a topic for future study. The finitary criterion we provide — approximate selflessness — is new and can be seen as a C*-algebraic analogue of mixing properties for von Neumann algebras, but without requiring a distinguished subalgebra. Unlike McDuff-type properties (which involve a central sequence of matrix algebras), approximate selflessness involves only a single unitary that is asymptotically free from the algebra. This is close in spirit to Voiculescu’s asymptotic freeness and to central sequence techniques, but with the crucial twist that the freeness is required only in an ultrapower, not in the algebra itself. In this paper we work exclusively with tracial C*-probability spaces, i.e. the state is a faithful trace; we denote it by \tau . The general selflessness notion of [ 10 ] allows arbitrary states, but