A Faceted Proposal for Transparent Attribution of AI-Assisted Text Production

Geraldo Xexéo · 2026

Read A Faceted Proposal for Transparent Attribution of AI-Assisted Text Production by Geraldo Xexéo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-25346.txt.

Introduction

Xexéo puts forth a faceted model for AI-aided text making at whole-text, chapter, section, and paragraph levels. AI tools now join writing fast, raising questions on who made a text and who must answer for it. Notes often say only that AI was used, not how it was used or how its output was checked. His core model rests on Form, Generation, and Evaluation, and a wider model adds Intent, Control, and Traceability. The model is a bare floor, shown usable by a worked case.

Catalog record

CREATORGeraldo Xexéo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70825
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.25346

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Faceted Proposal for Transparent Attribution of AI-Assisted Text Production Geraldo Xexéo Abstract Artificial intelligence systems are increasingly integrated into writing processes, challenging traditional notions of authorship, responsibility, and intellectual contribution. Current disclosure practices usually indicate whether AI was used, but rarely explain how it was used, where it intervened, or how its output was reviewed. This paper proposes a faceted model for representing AI-assisted text production at the levels of documents, chapters, sections, and paragraphs. The proposal introduces a core model based on Form, Generation, and Evaluation, and an extended model that adds Intent, Control, and Traceability. The model is positioned as a minimal operational baseline with extensibility toward higher-fidelity representations. A worked example based on the production of this article demonstrates applicability. 1 Introduction This paper is a position paper proposing a faceted model for the transparent attribution of AI-assisted text production. Its central claim is that current declarations of generative AI use in academic and scientific writing are too coarse for the practical, ethical, and epistemic problems now faced by scholarly communication. The paper does not argue that generative AI should be banned from writing workflows. Rather, it argues that AI involvement should be described with enough precision to distinguish correction, rewriting, generation, conceptual support, human control, evaluation, and traceability. The intended contribution is therefore a structured vocabulary for disclosure, not a detector of AI-generated text and not a moral classification of acceptable or unacceptable use. Generative AI has rapidly entered academic and scientific publication practices.Researchers now use large language models to draft paragraphs, revise manuscripts, summarize literature, translate text, create code, generate examples, prepare responses to reviewers, and explore conceptual framings. This expansion has produced both opportunities and concerns. On the opportunity side, AI systems can reduce linguistic barriers, accelerate routine drafting tasks, and help authors explore alternative formulations. On the concern side, they can produce fabricated citations, inaccurate claims, misleading summaries, biased language, untraceable transformations, and ambiguity about intellectual contribution. These problems have been discussed both in scientific literature and in public reporting. Early editorials in Science and Nature argued that AI systems should not be treated as authors because they cannot assume responsibility for scientific claims, approve final versions, or be accountable for errors ( 32 ; 23 ) . 29 described both the enthusiasm and apprehension surrounding ChatGPT and related systems in scientific work, including the risk that generative systems may reshape research communication before norms and institutions are prepared. A particularly concrete risk is bibliographic fabrication. 35 showed that ChatGPT-generated scholarly texts can contain fabricated and erroneous citations, which is especially problematic because references are not merely decoration in scientific writing, but part of the evidence infrastructure of scholarship. As times passes, however, top level AI systems produce less errors. As of 2026, the bibliographic references are almost all correct with ChatGPT 5.4. 12 similarly argued that calling such outputs “hallucinations” may understate their significance in scientific contexts, where fabricated references and unsupported claims can function as falsifications of the scholarly record. For the general public, journalistic reports have also documented the practical difficulty of detecting undisclosed AI use in academic journals and the appearance of fake or unverifiable references in scholarly materials ( 19 ; 39 ) . The institutional response has been fast but uneven. Publishers, societies, funders, and universities have generally converged on three principles: AI tools should not be authors, human authors remain responsible for final content, and relevant AI use should be disclosed. However, the level of detail required by these policies varies substantially. Publisher policies show a movement from prohibition toward conditional acceptance, but they still tend to rely on narrative declarations rather than structured, segment-level descriptions. Elsevier allows AI-assisted technologies in manuscript preparation when used with human oversight and disclosure, but it emphasizes that authors must verify accuracy, check sources, preserve authentic intellectual contribution, and remain responsible for privacy, intellectual property, and rights issues ( 11 ) . Springer Nature distinguishes AI-assisted copy editing from generative editorial work and requires human accountability for the final text, while also treating AI-generated images and videos cautiously because of unresolved copyright and research-integrity issues ( 28 ) . Scientific and professional societies have developed similar approaches. The Association for Computing Machinery states that generative AI tools may not be listed as authors, because authorship requires identifiable human responsibility, substantial intellectual contribution, and accountability for the published work. At the same time, ACM permits the use of generative AI tools to create content when that use is fully disclosed ( 5 ) . IEEE guidance is even closer to the motivation of this paper because it requires that authors identify the AI system used, identify the specific sections that used AI-generated content, and briefly explain the level at which the AI system was used ( 15 ) . This is an important precedent, because it suggests that a useful disclosure should not merely say whether AI was used, but should indicate where and how it was used. Ethics organizations have also influenced the emerging consensus. COPE’s position on authorship and AI tools states that AI tools cannot meet authorship requirements because they cannot take responsibility for submitted work ( 9 ) . This principle has been adopted or echoed by many publishers and societies. However, saying that AI cannot be an author does not settle the harder question addressed by this paper: how should the contribution of AI be represented when it is neither authorship nor irrelevant tool use. Universities and funders have also begun to formalize guidance. Harvard’s research guidance states that researchers should consult publisher rules, disclose generative AI use when required, and attend to risks such as bias, misinformation, intellectual-property compliance, security, unpredictability, and overreliance ( 14 ) . The Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro has published preliminary institutional documents on academic integrity and recommendations for AI use, emphasizing human intellectual responsibility, critical verification of AI outputs, transparency, intellectual property, and AI literacy ( 34 ) . In Brazil, the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico issued Portaria CNPq No. 2.664, of March 6, 2026, instituting a Policy of Integrity in Scientific Activity. The purpose of that policy is to guarantee integrity in scientific activities supported by CNPq through education, prevention, investigation, and sanctions, while promoting ethics, transparency, responsible authorship, and integrity across the research lifecycle ( 10 ) . Its treatment of generative AI is especially significant for this paper. The policy does not prohibit generative AI use, but requires declaration of such use, regardless of the type of generative AI or the phase of research development, specifying the tool used and the purpose of use. It also forbids submitting generative-AI-produced content as if it were human-authored and states that authors remain fully responsible for the final content, including plagiarism or inaccuracies generated by the tool. In addition, it discourages the use of AI in the preparation of scientific reviews ( 10 ) . This policy is important because it moves beyond a purely publisher-centered view and frames AI use as part of scientific integrity, research governance, and institutional responsibility. These responses are necessary, but still incomplete. Most current policies require disclosure, but do not provide a sufficiently detailed language for disclosure. They

Read the complete text