Indirect reciprocity beyond pairwise interactions
Ming Wei, Xin Wang, Junyu Lu, Longzhao Liu, Yishen Jiang, Hongwei Zheng, Shaoting Tang, Feng Fu · 2026
Read Indirect reciprocity beyond pairwise interactions by Ming Wei, Xin Wang, Junyu Lu, Longzhao Liu, Yishen Jiang, Hongwei Zheng, Shaoting Tang, Feng Fu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-25175.txt.
Introduction
Wei and seven colleagues develop a framework for multiplayer indirect reciprocity. Pairwise reciprocity is well understood, but collective action judges people against group reputation. They show stable group cooperation follows one rule: all good, help; one bad, halt. The rule is both necessary and sufficient, and it recovers the classical leading eight norms in the pairwise limit. Multiplayer systems, unlike pairwise models, show bistability and hysteresis around a tipping point. Tests find large language models shifting toward punitive defection with richer social information, yet missing the rule's logic.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ming Wei, Xin Wang, Junyu Lu, Longzhao Liu, Yishen Jiang, Hongwei Zheng, Shaoting Tang, Feng Fu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51866 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.25175
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Indirect reciprocity beyond pairwise interactions Ming Wei, Xin Wang, Junyu Lu, Longzhao Liu, Yishen Jiang, Hongwei Zheng, Shaoting Tang, Feng Fu Abstract Cooperation in groups underpins collective responses to challenges from climate governance to public goods provision, yet how moral evaluation sustains it remains poorly understood. Indirect reciprocity 2 , 5 , 22 – cooperating to build a good reputation – is well characterized for pairwise interactions 23 , 29 , 26 , 15 , 19 , 39 , 25 , but real collective action requires individuals to be judged against the reputational profile of an entire group 30 , 17 , 11 , 37 . Here we develop a general framework for multiplayer indirect reciprocity and show that stable group cooperation obeys a simple organizing principle: ‘all good, help; one bad, halt’. This rule is both necessary and sufficient for cooperation to emerge, and it recovers the classical leading eight norms in the pairwise limit 26 , 27 . We further show that group structure fundamentally changes reputation dynamics: unlike pairwise models, which are monostable 26 , multiplayer systems exhibit bistability and hysteresis, with a critical tipping point separating cooperative and defective regimes. Assessment of the latent norms of large language models reveals that they shift toward punitive defection when provided with richer social information, yet fail to follow the full logic of ‘all good, help; one bad, halt’. Our results establish a unifying principle for reputation-based cooperation in groups and provide a benchmark for evaluating cooperative alignment in artificial intelligence. keywords reputation, public goods, social norms, cooperation, cooperative AI Introduction Human groups and societies have long championed diverse and complex forms of cultural, social, and economic organization, owing to large-scale cooperation, especially among genetically unrelated individuals 10 , 43 . Yet altruistic behaviors that promote collective welfare often come at a personal cost and are vulnerable to exploitation by free-riding individuals, giving rise to social dilemmas 30 , 14 , 44 , 24 . From daily gossip to online ratings, we spread the word about good Samaritans while condemning bad apples. Such reputation effects, conveyed through private or public information 15 , 19 , serve as powerful moral compasses shaping kindness and other-regarding preferences in domains such as charity giving 40 , community upkeep 50 , and workplace collegiality 9 . As a solution to mitigate the tragedy of the commons, indirect reciprocity explains how reputation-based moral systems can foster the evolution of cooperation 2 , 5 , 23 , 26 , 6 . In a typical framework, reputations are assigned to individuals using a binary label (good or bad) 23 , 33 . Individuals choose their actions in social interactions based on reputational information, while their behaviors are observed and assessed by others. These assessments update their reputations, and those who maintain a good standing are more likely to receive help in future encounters 18 . This feedback loop, in which prosocial behavior is sustained through indirect information, forms the core mechanism of indirect reciprocity. In most studies, indirect reciprocity is modeled in terms of pairwise interactions 26 , 15 , 19 , 39 , 25 , typically as a one-shot donation game involving one donor and one recipient. The donor can choose either to cooperate or to defect, that is, to pay a cost in order to confer a benefit on the recipient or to withhold this help. The rule by which the donor selects an action based on the recipient’s reputation (and sometimes also on their own) is called a behavioral strategy. For example, always cooperating (ALLC) and always defecting (ALLD) are two basic behavioral strategies. At the same time, observers assess the donor’s behavior according to a shared social norm, which specifies how observed information is used to update the donor’s reputation. Social norms are ordered depending on how rich this information is. First-order norms focus only on the donor’s action; the most prominent example is image scoring 21 , 47 , 20 , which simply approves cooperation and disapproves defection. Second-order norms additionally take into account the recipient’s reputation and thus can distinguish justified from unjustified defection 38 , 36 , 31 . Third-order norms further incorporate the donor’s reputation, allowing behavior to be assessed in a richer context. Among these third-order norms, eight particularly successful ones, referred to as the leading eight, are known to support the evolution of cooperation robustly 26 , 27 . To date, studies of the donation game have provided a deep understanding of how reputation can promote cooperation in pairwise encounters. Yet human social interactions go far beyond purely dyadic 30 , 17 , 11 , 37 . Group cooperation involving multiple individuals can be traced back to the earliest stages of human history, such as the formation of tribes and communities 4 , 3 , and it continues to underpin social, economic, and political life today. In these collective settings, reputation and moral systems play a central role in shaping how people behave. However, as the scale of interaction grows, the informational context of any given action becomes much more complex, and existing theories of indirect reciprocity based on donation games are insufficient to reflect such complexity. This leads to a natural and pressing question: how should individuals behave in groups where reputational information goes beyond pairwise interactions? In multiplayer interactions, instead of a single recipient whose reputation is either good or bad, a focal individual faces a group of co-players whose reputations may be all good, all bad, or a mixture of both. A behavioral strategy must therefore specify how to act under different configurations of co-players’ reputations. Previous studies have shown that in three-player games governed solely by image scoring, the strictest strategy, namely cooperating only when all co-players have good reputations, can sustain reciprocal cooperation 41 . A related line of work introduced collective reputations into public goods games and showed that varying the criterion for group assessment can qualitatively alter the stability of cooperation 48 . However, once we consider richer information in the spirit of higher-order norms, it remains unclear whether indirect reciprocity in multiplayer settings exhibits qualitative differences from the pairwise case, and which social norms, apart from image scoring, can promote the evolution of cooperation in such settings. Moreover, in parallel with growing efforts toward cooperative artificial intelligence 8 , both the reliance on large language models (LLMs) for moral decision-making 16 , 7 and the alignment problem 46 have attracted considerable attention. Although a few recent studies have examined how LLMs behave in dyadic direct 32 , 1 , 13 and indirect reciprocity 45 , 34 , no systematic analysis exists of their normative judgment patterns in multiplayer interactions. Figure 1: Group interactions require more subtle contextual deliberation in focal individual choices and in the assessment of the reputations that result. Here, we define social norms and behavioral strategies with respect to the size of the interaction, ranging from dyadic to multiple individuals (triplets and above). a – c , Schematics of pairwise, three-player, and multiplayer interactions with illustrative frameworks for social norms and behavioral strategies. The left column depicts the canonical paradigm of indirect reciprocity: individual reputations and interactions are observed as indirect information. Reputations are classified