Leverage Laws: A Per-Task Framework for Human-Agent Collaboration
Stan Loosmore · 2026
Read Leverage Laws: A Per-Task Framework for Human-Agent Collaboration by Stan Loosmore (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-25040.txt.
Introduction
Loosmore proposes a leverage ratio per task for human-agent collaboration. It divides human work displaced by an agent by time spent on specifying, interrupts and review. That time splits into three channels for a conserved information requirement, each with its cost. Information density is directional, with ceilings on flow from humans to agents and from agents to humans. Asymptotic leverage splits into capability and memory axes, with a planning floor set by irreducible task novelty. A windowed measure extends the analysis to recurring tasks, spawned subtasks and amortized design.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Stan Loosmore |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25799 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.25040
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Leverage Laws: A Per-Task Framework for Human-Agent Collaboration Stan Loosmore Abstract Abstract We propose a per-task leverage ratio for human-agent collaboration: human work displaced by an agent, divided by the human time required to specify the task, resolve mid-run interrupts, and review the result. The denominator decomposes into three channels through which a conserved per-task information requirement must flow, each with its own time-cost scalar. We show that information density itself is directional and bounded by separate ceilings on human-to-agent and agent-to-human flow, and that the asymptotic behavior of leverage decomposes into two scaling axes (capability and memory) with a non-zero floor on the planning term set by irreducible task novelty bounded by human throughput. We extend this per-task analysis to a windowed leverage measure that accommodates recurring tasks, spawned subtasks, and amortized system-design investment. The per-task ceiling does not bind the windowed measure, though both remain bounded: L_{\text{task}} by per-task novelty, L_{\text{window}} by the stock of accumulated planning investment that pays out within the window. The framework operationalizes aspects of earlier qualitative work on supervisory control [1], common ground [2], and mixed-initiative interaction [3] within a single normative ratio, and produces a list of testable empirical questions including a Popper-grade falsification protocol for the directional asymmetry claim. 1. Introduction The productivity literature on human-AI collaboration has converged on three well-explored claims: that AI improves output [4, 5], that the productivity frontier is jagged across tasks [6], and that autonomous time horizons are growing [7]. What this literature does not provide is a unit of analysis. There is no per-task ratio that lets a practitioner answer the operational question of where to invest the next hour of work to increase the rate at which agents displace human labor. We propose such a ratio. The contribution is not the recognition that human-agent collaboration has a leverage structure; that observation is implicit across the supervisory control and common ground literatures. The contribution is a unified formulation that connects three previously disjoint claims: 1. The cost of supervising autonomous systems can be decomposed into measurable channels [1]. 2. The information required to specify a task decreases with shared context between collaborators [2]. 3. The decision to interrupt a human or autonomous process is a cost-benefit calculation [3]. We show these are three views of one ratio, with a tractable asymptotic analysis and one Popper-grade falsifiable prediction concerning directional density and phase-specific time savings. 2. The Base Formula Define per-task leverage as: L_{\text{task}}\;=\;\frac{H_{\text{displaced}}}{t_{\text{planning}}\;+\;\sum_{j}t_{\text{interrupt}_{j}}\;+\;t_{\text{review}}} Here L_{\text{task}} is the dimensionless leverage of a single task (human-hours displaced per human-hour spent), H_{\text{displaced}} is the human work the agent removes from the operator’s plate, t_{\text{planning}} is the human time spent specifying the task before dispatch, t_{\text{interrupt}_{j}} is the human time spent resolving the j -th interrupt mid-run, and t_{\text{review}} is the human time spent verifying the agent’s output. All time terms are in hours. The numerator is governed by agent capability. The denominator is governed by the structure of the human-agent exchange. The two are first-order decoupled : investments in models and infrastructure raise the numerator without directly affecting the denominator, and investments in workflow design lower the denominator without changing capability. At second order, the two coevolve. A more capable model reduces interrupt frequency by needing fewer clarifications; richer tools both increase H_{\text{displaced}} and shorten review by producing more verifiable output. The decoupling is an engineering separability rather than a strict structural independence: the levers can be funded as distinct programs, but a capability improvement raises every term in the equation, and the framework identifies which terms move first under which interventions. Each denominator term is an exchange : a bounded interaction in which information is transferred between the human and the agent. 3. Information Density 3.1 Definition Define information density: \rho\;=\;\frac{I_{\text{conveyed}}}{t_{\text{exchange}}} Here \rho is the information density of an exchange (in bits per hour), I_{\text{conveyed}} is the useful information transferred (in bits), and t_{\text{exchange}} is the wall-clock duration of the exchange (in hours). We use Shannon bits as the unit; the qualifier “useful” is load-bearing, and a formal treatment of which bits are task-relevant is deferred to §7. 3.2 Directional Decomposition Information density is asymmetric: human-to-agent flow and agent-to-human flow have different bottlenecks. Let \rho_{\text{in}} denote the human-to-agent rate, bottlenecked by human output (speech, with asymptote near 20 bits/sec; typing; intent compression). Let \rho_{\text{out}} denote the agent-to-human rate, bottlenecked by human input (reading, listening, visual parsing); the agent’s choice of modality determines which channel is used. For an exchange in which fraction \alpha\in[0,1] of the information flows human-to-agent, the time required to move I total bits is: t_{\text{exchange}}(I,\alpha)\;=\;\frac{\alpha\cdot I}{\rho_{\text{in}}}\;+\;\frac{(1-\alpha)\cdot I}{\rho_{\text{out}}} The effective density of the exchange is the harmonic mean of \rho_{\text{in}} and \rho_{\text{out}} weighted by the information shares: \rho_{\text{eff}}(\alpha)\;=\;\frac{1}{\alpha/\rho_{\text{in}}\;+\;(1-\alpha)/\rho_{\text{out}}} This form is correct because rates combine in inverse when both bottlenecks gate the same exchange. Figure 1: Effective density as the harmonic mean of two directional ceilings, with the three channels marked along the curve 3.3 Channel-Specific Mixtures Each term in the denominator of L_{\text{task}} has its own characteristic \alpha , and the value depends on the activity within the phase, not on the phase label alone. We do not commit to specific values for any phase; the values below are illustrative orderings, not measurements. • Planning depends on planning mode. Spec-mode planning (the human knows what they want and is conveying intent) tends to be input-heavy: \alpha_{p} is high. Exploratory planning (the human is using the agent to brainstorm and figure out what they want) is more bidirectional: \alpha_{p} is closer to balanced. • Interrupt is typically bidirectional. The agent communicates state ( \rho_{\text{out}} ); the human resolves it ( \rho_{\text{in}} ). \alpha_{i,j} tends toward the middle of the range. • Review is typically output-heavy: agent-to-human result transfer, with some human correction. \alpha_{r} tends to be low, higher when the human pushes back substantively. The structural claim is that these three channels span a range of \alpha , and that workflows in which all channels collapse to the same \alpha are degenerate. The specific values are empirically open and likely activity-dependent (open problem 9). The operational consequence holds for any \alpha -ordering: a \rho_{\text{in}} improvement (e.g., voice input) primarily helps phases with higher \alpha , while a \rho_{\text{out}} improvement (e.g., a structured trace dashboard) primarily helps phases with lower \alpha . 3.4 Asymmetric Ceilings \rho_{\text{in}} and \rho_{\text{out}} have different headroom. \rho_{\text{in}} is bounded above by human output rate, with speech as the natural asymptote near \sim 20 bits/sec. Tools like voice-to-text are already approaching this ceiling; further gains require either higher information density per spoken token (better intent compression) or new modalities (e.g., direct neural interfaces) that we treat as out of scope. \rho_{\text{out}} has substantially more headroom because the agent can choose its output modality. A well-designed dashboard or diagram conveys orders of magnitude more bits per second than an equivalent prose summary. The ceiling on \rho_{\text{out}} is set by the human’s parallel visual processing capacity, which is poorly characterized but clearly higher than read-aloud rates. \rho_{\text{out}} has more headroom for improvement than \rho_{\text{in}} , but improvements to \rho_{\text{out}} cannot rescue exchanges bottlenecked on \rho_{\text{in}} , and vice versa. The two are separate investment levers. 4. Information Conservation 4.1 The Conservation Law Every