A Monte Carlo method for tracking dust properties during coagulation in protoplanetary disks

Nerea Gurrutxaga, Vignesh Vaikundaraman, Joanna Drążkowska · 2026

Read A Monte Carlo method for tracking dust properties during coagulation in protoplanetary disks by Nerea Gurrutxaga, Vignesh Vaikundaraman, Joanna Drążkowska (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-24857.txt.

Introduction

Gurrutxaga and colleagues present a Monte Carlo coagulation method for planet-forming disks. It strictly keeps the global stock of dust properties across the disk. Current methods lack strict conservation, so fluctuations can grow and skew predictions. Tests against analytic kernels and a two-dimensional disk benchmark validate it. It reproduces standard results and sharpens the small-grain regime. A water-sublimation test shows strict mass conservation per component.

Catalog record

CREATORNerea Gurrutxaga, Vignesh Vaikundaraman, Joanna Drążkowska
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49031
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.24857

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Monte Carlo method for tracking dust properties during coagulation in protoplanetary disks Nerea Gurrutxaga, Vignesh Vaikundaraman, Joanna Drążkowska Abstract Dust growth is a crucial step in planet formation, and the efficiency of this process is controlled by the physical and chemical properties of the dust grains. Monte Carlo–based methods are commonly used to follow the collisional evolution of dust while tracking their properties. However, current Monte Carlo methods in planet formation do not strictly conserve the global inventory of dust properties across the protoplanetary disk, causing fluctuations that can grow over time and affect predictions of dust evolution. Here we present a coagulation algorithm that ensures the global conservation of dust properties while resolving the spatial evolution of dust. The method is validated against analytical solutions for standard coagulation kernels and benchmarked in a two-dimensional disk. We show that the method reproduces standard results, resolves the full dust population, and improves the resolution of the small-grain regime compared to other Monte Carlo methods for modeling global dust evolution. Finally, using a test case that includes sublimation and condensation of water interacting with silicates, we demonstrate strict conservation of each component’s mass during coagulation, establishing the method as a valuable tool for tracking dust properties in protoplanetary disks. 1 Introduction Planet formation requires dust particles to grow across many orders of magnitude in size within protoplanetary disks. Micrometer-sized dust coagulates into centimeter-sized pebbles before it can form kilometer-sized planetesimals ( 47 ) or be accreted by growing protoplanets ( 29 ; 25 ) . The physical and chemical properties of dust particles affect their transport and collision outcomes and thereby the efficiency of dust coagulation ( 6 ) . A comprehensive understanding of planet formation, therefore, requires studying how dust properties affect coagulation. This task is challenging, as resolving dust coagulation in detail is computationally demanding. Two main approaches are commonly used to model dust coagulation in protoplanetary disks. The first class consists of Monte Carlo methods that explicitly track particle evolution. These methods were introduced to planet formation studies independently by 30 and 49 , with later developments by 31 ; 10 and 2 . The implementation described in 10 is available as the open-source code mcdust ( 44 ) . The second widely used approach is the mass grid-based method ( 46 ; 11 ; 8 ; 3 , e.g.,) , in which the dust mass distribution is discretized into bins and interactions between bins are calculated. This approach is well established in the community, with open-source implementations such as the one-dimensional code dustpy ( 39 ) and the two-dimensional code cuDisc ( 33 ) . A major challenge of the mass-grid method is the inclusion of additional particle properties, as they substantially increase the complexity and computational cost of the method. While extensions to account for properties such as porosity, chemical composition, and charge are possible ( 32 ; 28 ; 40 ; 1 ) , they require simplifying assumptions – such as that dust particles of equal mass share the same properties. In contrast, Monte Carlo methods enable a more straightforward implementation of additional properties without such assumptions, although adequately sampling the larger parameter space still requires increased numerical resolution. Monte Carlo methods widely used in planet formation studies are based on the stochastic description of coagulation introduced by 12 . Because it is not feasible to track all dust particles in a protoplanetary disk, these methods rely on a limited number of representative particles, whose evolution is assumed to describe that of many physical particles. There are different ways to define and evolve such representative particles, each way leading to different strengths and limitations. In the approach presented by 30 , collisions are computed between individual representative particles confined within a small volume that represents a larger volume. When two particles coagulate, a new representative particle is created by randomly duplicating an existing one in order to keep the total number of representative particles constant. To preserve the dust density, the volume enclosing the particles is increased accordingly. This method can achieve high accuracy, particularly during the earliest stages of growth. An improved and more efficient implementation was presented by 31 , showing that several physical collisions can be grouped into a single collision event. However, the general approach by 30 is designed to resolve dust coagulation locally, which can make it challenging to study global dust evolution, as dust transport influences coagulation across the disk ( 4 ) . An alternative Monte Carlo method was introduced by 49 . In this approach, a small number of representative particles is tracked, each representing a large group of identical physical particles. To compute collisions, the representative particle i is assumed to collide with physical particles identical to those represented by particle j . However, only particle i is updated after the collision. It was shown that, when a sufficient number of representative particles is used, the expected coagulation behavior is well reproduced. This method has two key advantages: it allows for spatially resolved dust coagulation, and it requires a relatively small number of particles to capture the statistical evolution of the system ( 10 ) . Monte Carlo methods facilitate the inclusion of additional particle properties with minimal modification to the algorithm and have already been employed to study porosity ( 30 ; 49 ; 22 ) and chemical composition ( 24 ; 19 ; 43 ) . However, 24 noted that although the approach by 49 can conserve the total dust mass, it does not strictly conserve the mass of different components. This arises because of the asymmetry of only updating the representative particle i during a collision with a physical particle j , thereby introducing fluctuations in the composition. These fluctuations become particularly significant when size-dependent processes operate and colliding dust particles have largely different compositions. In the alternative method by 30 , the global inventory of dust properties is conserved during pairwise collisions. However, since a particle is duplicated to keep the number of representative particles constant, fluctuations can also arise when dust particles have largely different compositions. A Monte Carlo method that both strictly conserves quantities such as dust composition and enables spatial resolution is still lacking. This limitation can hinder the development of more advanced models. In this work, we present a Monte Carlo approach that is spatially resolvable and enforces strict conservation of the global inventory of dust properties. Our method is comparable to that presented by 37 for cloud microphysics but is formulated here in the context of planet formation. In Sect. 2 , we describe the algorithm. In Sect. 3 , we validate the method through a series of tests by comparing our results with analytical solutions of the Smoluchowski equation for coagulation kernels, computing dust evolution in a two-dimensional protoplanetary disk, and following the collisional evolution of a multi-component dust population. We summarize our findings in Sect. 4 . Figure 1 : Summary of the Monte Carlo algorithm presented in this paper. We group individual identical particles. Sticking : When group \{i\} collides with group \{j\} , as N_{i}\, <\, N_{j} , every particle in group \{i\} sticks to one particle that belongs to group \{j\} .

Read the complete text