Dynamical Fluctuation-Response Relations

Timur Aslyamov, Massimiliano Esposito · 2026

Read Dynamical Fluctuation-Response Relations by Timur Aslyamov, Massimiliano Esposito (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-24626.txt.

Introduction

Aslyamov and Esposito derive exact dynamical fluctuation-response relations for time-integrated observables of any time-varying Markov jump process. In the result, finite-time covariance equals an initial variability term plus a response-kernel integral over the driven dynamics. The identity sharpens related uncertainty relations. In plain terms, the paper links how a system wobbles to how it answers a small push, at any finite time, not only at steady state. That link matters for slowly relaxing systems, where the starting state still shapes later behavior.

Catalog record

CREATORTimur Aslyamov, Massimiliano Esposito
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45967
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.24626

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dynamical Fluctuation-Response Relations Timur Aslyamov, Massimiliano Esposito Abstract We derive exact dynamical fluctuation-response relations (FRRs) for time-integrated observables of any nonautonomous Markov jump process. The finite-time covariance splits into an initial variability and an integral of response kernels along the driven dynamics. The identity sharpens the dynamical response thermodynamic and kinetic uncertainty relations and fluctuation-response inequalities (FRIs). It also recovers steady-state FRRs, fluctuation-dissipation theorem and Onsager reciprocity, identifies known autonomous FRIs as the zero-frequency mode. Introduction— At equilibrium, the fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) identifies linear response coefficients with spontaneous fluctuations 31 ; 32 ; 57 ; 41 ; 23 . Away from equilibrium, response theory remains possible but usually takes a different form: the response of an observable is written as a correlation with an auxiliary observable conjugate to the perturbation 1 ; 56 ; 13 ; 7 ; 8 ; 54 ; 40 ; 47 ; 62 . Such identities are broadly useful, yet they do not directly express the variance or covariance of the observable whose response is measured. This distinction is important in stochastic thermodynamics, where fluctuations of currents and state observables provide experimentally accessible information about dissipation, dynamical activity, kinetic bottlenecks, and thermodynamic efficiency 11 ; 25 ; 45 ; 46 ; 28 ; 21 ; 27 ; 59 ; 43 ; 58 ; 18 ; 55 ; 16 ; 35 ; 19 . A different connection between fluctuations and responses has recently emerged for nonequilibrium steady states. Exact fluctuation-response relations (FRRs) for Markov jump processes express covariances of time-integrated state and current observables directly in terms of responses to microscopic perturbations of transition rates, without introducing a conjugate auxiliary observable 5 ; 49 ; 50 . These relations provide the structural basis for response thermodynamic uncertainty relations (R-TURs) and response kinetic uncertainty relations (R-KURs), which bound dissipation or activity by response-to-fluctuation ratios 63 ; 38 ; 48 ; 33 ; 9 ; 60 ; 39 ; 42 ; 64 ; 26 . They also survive in macroscopic weak-noise limits and in continuum limits under diffusive scaling 17 ; 6 ; 4 ; 14 . However, their exact form has so far been restricted to steady states. This leaves out relaxation from arbitrary initial states and systems driven by time-dependent protocols, even though dynamical thermodynamic uncertainty relations (TURs) and fluctuation-response inequalities (FRIs) are known in these regimes 15 ; 30 ; 37 ; 33 ; 38 ; 60 ; 14 . In this Letter, we derive exact dynamical FRRs for arbitrary time-integrated state and current observables of nonautonomous Markov jump processes. The central result is a finite-time covariance identity with two contributions. The first is an integral over products of dynamical response kernels to delta-like perturbations of local transition parameters. The second is an initial-variability term measuring how much the conditional mean of the observable depends on the initial state. For variances, this term is nonnegative. It vanishes for deterministic initial preparation, decays once the dynamics loses memory of the initial ensemble, and disappears in the asymptotic state of a periodically driven system. Thus, the new term is genuinely dynamical, while the response integral reduces to the known steady-state FRRs in the long-time limit. Crucially, dynamical FRRs provide a clear and unifying route to derive a broad class of central results in stochastic thermodynamics obtained over the last decade while sharpening them at finite time. It yields dynamical R-TURs, improves finite-time TURs 30 ; 37 , R-KURs 63 ; 38 ; 60 , and Dechant–Sasa FRI 15 by retaining the positive initial-variability contribution, and reduces, once memory of the preparation is lost, to steady-state FRRs 5 ; 49 ; 50 and optimal steady-state TUR bounds 55 ; 16 . It also recovers the FDT and Onsager reciprocity in the autonomous detailed-balance limit and shows that autonomous FRIs 33 correspond to the zero-frequency sector of the exact Fourier-resolved theory. The resulting hierarchy is summarized in Fig. 1 . In addition, we generalize the static-response properties from Refs. 44 ; 3 ; 2 ; 12 to nonautonomous dynamics. As an application, we give a compact proof of the no-pumping theorem for integrated currents 51 and show that despite zero net currents, no pumping states can violate the FDT. Figure 1: Hierarchy of the main results that follow from the dynamical FRRs. Red nodes denote exact identities; green nodes denote bounds. Solid outlines indicate results derived in this Letter, while dashed outlines indicate previously known results refined by the initial-variability term, and dotted outlines indicate known results derived without changes. The Dechant–Sasa FRI is marked by * because here only its linear-response Markov-jump version is derived. Setup— We consider a system described by a nonautonomous Markov jump process over the discrete state space labeled by n\in\{1,\dots,N\} . The probability that the system occupies state n at time t is denoted by \bm{p}(t)=(p_{1},\dots,p_{N})^{\intercal} and satisfies the master equation d_{t}\bm{p}(t)=W(t)\cdot\bm{p}(t) , where \sum_{n}p_{n}=1 and where \bm{p}(0) is assumed to be known. The rate matrix W(t) explicitly depends on time via a general driving protocol. Its off-diagonal elements are W_{nm}(t)=\sum_{e}[W_{+e}(t)\delta_{s(+e)m}\delta_{t(+e)n}+W_{-e}(t)\delta_{s(+e)n}\delta_{t(+e)m}] , where s(\pm e) is the source of edge \pm e and t(\pm e) is its target; its diagonal elements are W_{nn}=-\sum_{m\neq n}W_{mn} . The rate matrix can be decomposed as W(t)=\Delta\cdot\Gamma(t) in terms of the incidence matrix \Delta_{ne}=\delta_{nt(+e)}-\delta_{ns(+e)} and the weighted incidence matrix \Gamma_{en}(t)=W_{+e}(t)\delta_{ns(+e)}-W_{-e}(t)\delta_{nt(+e)} . The incidence vector is \bm{\Delta}_{e}=(\dots,\Delta_{ne},\dots)^{\intercal} such that \bm{\Delta}_{e}\cdot\bm{f}=f_{t(+e)}-f_{s(+e)} . The stochastic trajectory of the system from time 0 to T is denoted by \omega_{0:T}=\{n_{t}\}_{0\leq t\leq T} . A generic integrated observable along it reads \displaystyle\mathcal{Q}[\omega_{0:T}] \displaystyle=\underbrace{\int_{0}^{T}d\tau o_{n_{\tau}}(\tau)}_{\mathcal{O}[\omega_{0:T}]}+\underbrace{\int_{0}^{T}\sum_{e}x_{e}(\tau)dk_{e}(\tau)}_{\mathcal{J}[\omega_{0:T}]}\,. (1) Here \mathcal{O}[\omega_{0:T}] is a state observable part, with o_{n_{\tau}}(\tau) a function defined on the states of the trajectory, while \mathcal{J}[\omega_{0:T}] is a current observable part, with edge weights x_{e}(\tau) (which may explicitly depend on time) and a current counter dk_{e}=dk_{+e}-dk_{-e} such that dk_{\pm e}(\tau)=1 if a transition \pm e occurs along the trajectory in [\tau,\tau+d\tau] and zero otherwise. An activity counter dk_{+e}+dk_{-e} may also be considered. Introducing the trajectory probability density \mathbb{P}[\omega_{0:T}] , we define the mean of Eq. 1 as \displaystyle Q(0,T)\equiv\sum_{\omega}\mathcal{Q}[\omega_{0:T}]\mathbb{P}[\omega_{0:T}]\,. (2) It can be computed as \displaystyle Q(0,T) \displaystyle=\underbrace{\int_{0}^{T}d\tau\sum_{n}o_{n}(\tau)p_{n}(\tau)}_{O(0,T)}+\underbrace{\int_{0}^{T}d\tau\sum_{e}x_{e}(\tau)j_{e}(\tau)}_{J(0,T)}\,, (3) where O(0,T) and J(0,T) are the means of the state and current observables, respectively, and j_{e}(t)=j_{+e}-j_{-e} , with j_{\pm e}=W_{\pm e}(t)p_{s(\pm e)}(t) , are the average edge currents. The average activity reads a_{e}(t)=W_{+e}(t)p_{s(+e)}(t)+W_{-e}(t)p_{t(+e)}(t) . The average currents define the entropy production rate (EPR) as \sigma(t)=\sum_{e}\sigma_{e}(t) with \sigma_{e}(t)=j_{e}(t)\log[j_{+e}(t)/j_{-e}(t)] , while a combination of currents and activities defines the pseudo-EPR \sigma^{\text{ps}}(t)=\sum_{e}j_{e}(t)^{2}/a_{e}(t) such that \sigma(t)\geq 2\sigma^{\text{ps}}(t) . Using the conditional probability density \mathbb{P}[\omega_{\tau:T}|n_{\tau}=n] for trajectories starting at time \tau from state n , we introduce the conditional mean: \displaystyle Q_{n}(\tau,T)\equiv\sum_{\omega}\mathcal{Q}[\omega_{\tau:T}]\mathbb{P}[\omega_{\tau:T}|n_{\tau}=n]\,, (4) which defines \bm{Q}(\tau,T)\equiv(Q_{1}(\tau,T),\dots,Q_{N}(\tau,T))^{\intercal} . Naturally, Q(\tau,T)=\sum_{n}Q_{n}(\tau,T)p_{n}(\tau) . Let us note that a useful tool for computing \bm{Q}(\tau,T) is solving the backward Kolmogorov equation (derived in Appendix B ): \displaystyle-\partial_{\tau}\bm{Q}(\tau,T)=W^{\intercal}(\tau)\cdot\bm{Q}(\tau,T)+\bm{o}(\tau)+\Gamma(\tau)^{\intercal}\cdot\bm{x}(\tau)\,, (5) with terminal condition \bm{Q}(T,T)=0 . Eq. 5 can be seen as a dynamical extension of the Poisson equation 29 . Dynamical FRRs— The first central object is the scaled covariance between the integrated observables \mathcal{Q}[\omega_{0:T}] and \mathcal{Q}^{\prime}[\omega_{0:T}] corresponding to the pairs \{x_{e},o_{n}\} and \{x^{\prime}_{e},o^{\prime}_{n}\} : \displaystyle\langle\!\langle\mathcal{Q},\mathcal{Q}^{\prime}\rangle\!\rangle\equiv\frac{1}{T}\sum_{\omega}\Delta\mathcal{Q}[\omega_{0:T}]\Delta\mathcal{Q}^{\prime}[\omega_{0:T}]\mathbb{P}[\omega_{0:T}]\,, (6) where \Delta\mathcal{Q}[\omega_{0:T}]\equiv\mathcal{Q}[\omega_{0:T}]-Q(0,T) . The second central object is the response kernel to a perturbation of the rates W(t;\lambda(t)) by a parameter

Read the complete text