Tests of scalar polarizations with multi-messenger events

Sk Md Adil Imam, Macarena Lagos · 2026

Read Tests of scalar polarizations with multi-messenger events by Sk Md Adil Imam, Macarena Lagos (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-24526.txt.

Introduction

Imam and Lagos test Einstein's gravity against rival theories using the neutron-star merger GW170817 plus its gamma-ray burst afterglow. General relativity allows only two wave polarizations, while wider theories allow up to six, so they add a scalar breathing mode and fit both quadrupole and dipole patterns. The scalar signal leans away from zero. Yet after penalizing extra parameters the data still favour plain relativity, with afterglow angles tightening the limits by roughly 60 and 30 percent in turn.

Catalog record

CREATORSk Md Adil Imam, Macarena Lagos
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59761
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.24526

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Tests of scalar polarizations with multi-messenger events Sk Md Adil Imam, Macarena Lagos Abstract Gravitational wave (GW) observations provide a unique opportunity to test Einstein’s General Relativity (GR) in the strong-field regime. While GR predicts only two tensor polarization modes, generic metric theories allow up to six independent modes. We perform a parameterized test of GR using the parameterized post-Einsteinian (PPE) framework applied to GW170817, incorporating for the first time the polarization angle constraints from the gamma-ray burst afterglow alongside other electromagnetic (EM) counterpart information. We extend the GR waveform by adding a scalar breathing mode and modifications to the tensor modes, introducing three non-GR parameters. We perform Bayesian inference for both quadrupole ℓ = | m | = 2 \ell=|m|=2 and dipole ℓ = | m | = 1 \ell=|m|=1 angular harmonics, with two frequency evolution models. For ℓ = | m | = 2 \ell=|m|=2 , we find mild preference for a scalar mode (scalar amplitude deviates from zero at ∼ 2 ​ σ \sim 2\sigma ), while for the ℓ = | m | = 1 \ell=|m|=1 , we find no preference for a scalar mode. The EM constraint on the polarization angle places very tight bounds on non-GR parameters; for instance, in the case ℓ = | m | = 2 \ell=|m|=2 , the bound on the scalar (tensor) amplitude modification parameter improves by roughly 60 % 60\% ( 30 % ) (30\%) , highlighting the impact that long-term follow up of GW events can have on tests of gravity. I Introduction While the theory of General Relativity (GR) has been exquisitely confirmed around the Solar System by constraining deviations to less than the 10^{-4} level Will 2014 , its predictive power reaches its limits at high energies, where GR is known to be incomplete Donoghue 1994 . Gravitational waves (GWs) are a key observable that provides direct information on the high-energy regime of gravity, since the signals detectable to date come from extreme astrophysical compact objects with strong gravitational fields Yunes and Siemens 2013 ; Yunes et al. 2016 ; Ezquiaga and Zumalacárregui 2018 . GW data from the current detector network (LIGO Aasi et al. 2015a , VIRGO Acernese et al. 2014a , KAGRA Somiya 2012 ) have already been used to perform various tests of gravity Li et al. 2012 ; Yunes and Siemens 2013 ; Sampson et al. 2013 ; Agathos et al. 2014 ; Abbott et al. 2016a ; Baker et al. 2017 ; Isi et al. 2017 ; Isi and Weinstein 2017 ; Callister et al. 2017 ; Berti et al. 2018 ; Takeda et al. 2018 ; Abbott and et al. 2019 ; Abbott 2021 ; Mehta et al. 2023 ; Sänger et al. 2024 ; Abbott et al. 2025 ; Madekar et al. 2025 ; Kumar et al. 2025 ; Collaboration et al. 2026 ; Abac et al. 2026 , and the planned and proposed next-generation GW detectors (e.g. Einstein Telescope Punturo et al. 2010 , Cosmic Explorer Reitze et al. 2019 , LISA Shaddock 2009 ) will improve the sensitivity of GW measurements by approximately an order of magnitude. In GR, gravitational waves contain only two transverse tensor polarization modes: plus ( + ) and cross ( \times ) modes Weinberg 1972 ; Misner et al. 1973 ; Eardley et al. 1973a ; Will 1993 ; Maggiore 2008 ; Schutz 2009 . Modified metric theories of gravity, however, can allow up to six independent polarization modes. For example, scalar-tensor and massive-graviton models can give rise to additional breathing ( b ) and/or longitudinal polarization scalar modes, due to the presence of a scalar degree of freedom Will 2014 . In contrast, vector-tensor gravity theories typically predict two longitudinal vector polarizations Will 2014 . More comprehensive theories like tensor-vector-scalar theories allow all six possible polarization states Bekenstein 2004 ; Bekenstein and Sanders 2006 , whereas Einstein–Aether models support five distinct modes Jacobson and Mattingly 2004 ; Eling et al. 2005 ; Jacobson 2008 . Similarly, bimetric theories are expected to exhibit the complete set of six polarizations Will 2014 ; Chatziioannou et al. 2012a ; Lightman and Lee 1973 ; Rosen 1974a . Detection of non-tensorial polarization modes in GW signals would provide direct evidence that GR is incomplete. Binary neutron star (BNS) mergers offer a distinct advantage for polarization tests: they produce electromagnetic (EM) counterparts that constrain the binary’s orientation. The orientation is characterized by two angular parameters—the inclination angle \iota and the polarization angle \psi —which are the primary quantities determining the polarization content of the GW signal in GR. GW170817 Abbott et al. 2017a was the first multi-messenger event with comprehensive EM observations that enabled such measurements. The radio observations of the gamma-ray burst afterglow—characterized through Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) Mooley et al. 2018 ; Ghirlanda et al. 2019 —provided constraints on both the inclination angle Hotokezaka et al. 2019 and the polarization angle Lagos et al. 2024a . The kilonova observation further provided sky localization and redshift measurements et. al. 2017 , which break parameter degeneracies inherent in GW-only analyses. Since EM counterparts are not typically expected from binary black hole mergers, BNS systems thus provide unique opportunities to improve polarization measurements through the combination of GW and EM data. Most research to date has tested gravity through modifications to the amplitude and phase of GWs Abbott et al. 2021 , but not through polarization content. The few polarization tests performed use binary black hole / neutron star mergers, where parameter degeneracies result in poorly constrained polarizations Abbott 2017 ; Abbott et al. 2017b ; Hagihara et al. 2018 ; Abbott 2019 ; Abbott and et al. 2019 ; Abbott 2021 ; Abbott et al. 2025 ; Collaboration et al. 2026 ; Hagihara et al. 2019 ; Abbott et al. 2021 ; Takeda et al. 2021 ; Svidzinsky and Hilborn 2021 ; Chatziioannou et al. 2021 ; Takeda et al. 2024 ; Mehta et al. 2023 . Some studies construct waveform models that allow multiple polarization modes (typically tensor and scalar) to coexist Takeda et al. 2022 . In Takeda et al. 2022 , accounting for scalar mode polarization induced energy loss up to second order yields corrections to both the amplitude and phase of the tensor modes, with these modifications parameterized by the scalar polarization parameter. The detector strain is written as a sum over polarizations weighted by antenna pattern functions, and Bayesian inference is used to estimate their amplitudes. This differs from pure polarization tests Takeda et al. 2021 ; Abbott et al. 2017b , which assume one mode at a time and compare models; mixed models instead constrain non-tensor components while retaining the tensor contribution. Parameterized tests of GR, such as the Flexible-Theory-Independent method Mehta et al. 2023 and those in Abbott and et al. 2019 ; Abbott 2021 ; Abbott et al. 2025 ; Collaboration et al. 2026 , typically modify only the phase of the standard tensor ( +,\times ) modes, without introducing additional polarizations or amplitude changes. The deviations are applied across the inspiral and taper toward merger–ringdown; the leading -1 PN parameter \delta\phi_{-2} captures possible indirect dipole radiation. Other parameterized tests, such as Takeda et al.

Read the complete text