Propagating data-driven galaxy redshift distribution uncertainties in 3 × \times 2-pt analyses 2026 Propagating data-driven galaxy redshift distribution uncertainties in 3 × \times 2-pt analyses – 4
Jaime Ruiz-Zapatero, Qianjun Hang, Yun-Hao Zhang, Benjamin Joachimi, Joe Zuntz, Ian Harrison, Carlos García-García, Alex Malz, Benjamin Stölzner, and the LSST Dark Energy Science Collaboration · 2026
Read Propagating data-driven galaxy redshift distribution uncertainties in 3 × \times 2-pt analyses 2026 Propagating data-driven galaxy redshift distribution uncertainties in 3 × \times 2-pt analyses – 4 by Jaime Ruiz-Zapatero, Qianjun Hang, Yun-Hao Zhang, Benjamin Joachimi, Joe Zuntz, Ian Harrison, Carlos García-García, Alex Malz, Benjamin Stölzner, and the LSST Dark Energy Science Collaboration (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-24425.txt.
Introduction
Ruiz-Zapatero and nine colleagues study redshift uncertainties in 3x2-point Stage-IV analyses. Using simulated redshift ensembles, they compare four models: shifts, shifts and stretches, Gaussian processes, and principal component analysis. High-dimensional models need marginalisation. Stage-IV analyses must move beyond shift and stretch models, and the authors advocate principal component models. A five-parameter PCA model costs only 5 percent on S8 versus shift and stretch, while halving bias in matter density and sigma-8. All models marginalise analytically, with speed-ups up to 25 times at negligible extra cost.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jaime Ruiz-Zapatero, Qianjun Hang, Yun-Hao Zhang, Benjamin Joachimi, Joe Zuntz, Ian Harrison, Carlos García-García, Alex Malz, Benjamin Stölzner, and the LSST Dark Energy Science Collaboration |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88134 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.24425
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Propagating data-driven galaxy redshift distribution uncertainties in 3 × \times 2-pt analyses 2026 Propagating data-driven galaxy redshift distribution uncertainties in 3 × \times 2-pt analyses – 4 Jaime Ruiz-Zapatero, Qianjun Hang, Yun-Hao Zhang, Benjamin Joachimi, Joe Zuntz, Ian Harrison, Carlos García-García, Alex Malz, Benjamin Stölzner, and the LSST Dark Energy Science Collaboration Abstract Uncertainties in the radial distribution of galaxies, 𝒏 ( 𝒛 ) \boldsymbol{n}(\boldsymbol{z}) , are one of the major contributions to the error budget of early Stage-IV galaxy survey analyses of weak gravitational lensing, galaxy clustering and galaxy-galaxy lensing (3 × \times 2-pt). Based on ensembles of simulated 𝒏 ( 𝒛 ) \boldsymbol{n}(\boldsymbol{z}) including stochastic and systematic variations, we study the impact of four different 𝒏 ( 𝒛 ) \boldsymbol{n}(\boldsymbol{z}) uncertainty models: shifts, shifts & stretches, Gaussian processes (GP) and principal component analysis (PCA). Due to the high dimensionality of the latter models, we make use of state-of-the-art gradient-based inference methods as well as approximate analytical marginalisation schemes. Our results show that Stage-IV 3 × \times 2-pt analyses must go beyond simple shift & stretch models. In particular, we advocate for the adoption of PCA models even in early Stage-IV surveys. Our results show that considering a five-parameters PCA model only degrades the constraint on the S 8 S_{\rm 8} parameter by 5 5 per cent with respect to the case when only a shift and a stretch parameter are included, while incurring half the bias in its constituents parameters, Ω m \Omega_{\rm m} and σ 8 \sigma_{\rm 8} . We demonstrate that all models considered can be safely marginalised analytically, with speed-ups of up to a factor of 25 depending on the dimensionality of the model. This will allow Stage-IV analyses to safely include higher-dimensional 𝒏 ( 𝒛 ) \boldsymbol{n}(\boldsymbol{z}) uncertainty models in their analysis at negligible additional computational cost. 1 Introduction Photometric galaxy surveys observe galaxies through a limited number of filters as opposed to spectroscopic surveys where the full spectral energy density (SED) of the source’s light is recorded ( 3 ) . This incomplete measurement of the SED adds an extra source of uncertainty in the estimation of the source’s redshift, leading to photometric redshifts being significantly less reliable than spectroscopic ones. Yet, how to characterise these uncertainties remains an open question. The literature is replete with methods to estimate the redshift distribution of photometric galaxy samples such as template fitting ( 4 ) , weighted direct calibration given a sufficiently complete spectroscopic sample ( 36 ; 73 ) , clustering redshifts ( 62 ; 45 ; 39 ; 61 ) and shear ratios ( 32 ; 48 ; 59 ) . The problem of parameterising redshift distribution uncertainty is likely to continue to evolve with the characteristics of relevant surveys ( 58 ; 60 ; 44 ) . In the context of projected two-point statistics, the value of the cosmological parameters is directly impacted by the radial distribution of the sample of galaxies as a whole, n(z) , rather than by the individual redshift probability distributions of galaxies, p(z) . Even when the redshift of each individual source in the sample has been estimated, deriving the corresponding n(z) is non-trivial ( 38 ) . Moreover, characterizing the uncertainty in the n(z) in a way that is representative of the uncertainty in the individual p(z) is still an active area of research ( 75 ; 76 ) . Traditionally, n(z) uncertainties were quantified a posteriori through a variety of arguments, often referring to simulations where the difference between the estimated and the “true" galaxy distribution could be known ( 19 ; 64 ; 72 ) . This approach puts significant constraints in the uncertainty models that can be calibrated robustly. Thus, the last generation of cosmological surveys, known as Stage-III, relied on simple redshift distribution uncertainty models where the mean and the width of the n(z) was allowed to vary. However, it is not clear that this methodology is able to encompass all the uncertainty in the n(z) without introducing biases in the next generation of surveys, known Stage-IV surveys. For these reasons, modern galaxy surveys are moving towards data-driven ensemble methods to estimate the uncertainty of the n(z) ( 51 ; 12 ; 41 ; 68 ) . This approach is based on generating an ensemble of possible n(z) given the individual photometric redshift uncertainties, p(z) , of each source in the catalogue given a photometric redshift estimation code. Crucially, the resulting ensemble must account for both the statistical uncertainties, due to the individual p(z) , as well as systematic effects, due to uncertainties not represented in the catalogue such as the incompleteness of the sample. Once a representative ensemble has been derived, it can be reliably used to calibrate a wealth of n(z) uncertainty models. In this work, we study the impact of different n(z) uncertainty models on the cosmological constraints in a joint a analysis of the auto- and cross-correlations of the galaxy clustering and weak lensing fields), commonly known as a 3 \times 2-pt analysis, of mock Vera C. Rubin’s observatory Legacy Survey of Space and Time Year 1 data, here onwards referred to as LSSTY1-like. We use the photometric redshift calibration of 75 ; 76 who provide an ensemble of \boldsymbol{n}(\boldsymbol{z}) distributions based on a combination of the FlexZBoost ( 26 ) and SOMPZ ( 30 ; 43 ) algorithms that encompasses both statistical and systematic uncertainties. We leverage this ensemble of possible n(z) distributions to calibrate a variety of uncertainty models using the Dark Energy Science Collaboration (DESC) library, nz_prior . We consider four different galaxy redshift distribution uncertainty models: a simple shift model, the most common shift and stretch model, a principal components decomposition and a Gaussian process. Some of the models considered in this work significantly increase the dimensionality of the posterior being inferred to the point where traditional sampling techniques such as Metropolis Hastings ( 40 ) become inefficient. In order to tackle this problem, we propose two strategies, one numerical and one analytical. Numerically, we employ a Hamiltonian Monte Carlo ( 37 ; 6 , HMC) sampling scheme to marginalise over the additional dimensions. Analytically, we marginalise over the galaxy redshift distribution uncertainty parameters using the Laplace approximation ( 65 ) which Gaussianises the contribution of these parameters to the likelihood. Both techniques require computing the gradient of the likelihood efficiently. In order to do so, we write our likelihood using the auto-differentiable cosmological code LimberJack.jl ( 55 ) . The treatment of photometric redshift uncertainties has already received ample attention in the literature. The most relevant work to this paper is 56 where a similar analysis to the one presented in this work was performed but limited to Weak Lensing (WL) analyses. Before, 63 studied the application to the Laplace approximation to the marginalisation of photometric uncertainties in Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS) data. 22 studied the validity of the Laplace approximation to marginalise over different nuisance parameters, including photometric uncertainties, in the Dark Energy Survey Year 1 (DESY1) 3 \times 2-pt analysis but limited its scope to a shifts & stretches model. This work presents a novel thorough comparison of different redshift distribution uncertainty models for a 3 \times 2-pt