A Realistic Discrete Event Simulation model for Ambulance Location and Deployment within a regional Emergency Medical Service

Alberto De Santis, Stefania Iannazzo, Fabio Ingravalle, Stefano Lucidi, Massimo Maurici, Giulia Riccardi, Massimo Roma, Antonio Vinci · 2026

Read A Realistic Discrete Event Simulation model for Ambulance Location and Deployment within a regional Emergency Medical Service by Alberto De Santis, Stefania Iannazzo, Fabio Ingravalle, Stefano Lucidi, Massimo Maurici, Giulia Riccardi, Massimo Roma, Antonio Vinci (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-24394.txt.

Introduction

De Santis and seven colleagues build a discrete event simulation model of regional ambulance deployment. Home bases, where crews wait ready for calls, largely set how fast and well the system responds. The model holds random workflow from varied sources, matching system operations very well for true-to-life analysis. A case study from ARES 118 covers Lazio, with a medium-size city and sparsely peopled areas. Scenario analyses show managers can use the model to improve effectiveness and quickness across the regional system.

Catalog record

CREATORAlberto De Santis, Stefania Iannazzo, Fabio Ingravalle, Stefano Lucidi, Massimo Maurici, Giulia Riccardi, Massimo Roma, Antonio Vinci
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE82325
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.24394

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Realistic Discrete Event Simulation model for Ambulance Location and Deployment within a regional Emergency Medical Service Alberto De Santis, Stefania Iannazzo, Fabio Ingravalle, Stefano Lucidi, Massimo Maurici, Giulia Riccardi, Massimo Roma, Antonio Vinci Abstract The objective of Emergency Medical Services (EMSs) is to promptly respond to calls from citizens for first aid, providing pre-hospital care and, if necessary, to transfer patients to an appropriate Emergency Department (ED) by ambulance. The efficiency of such a system strongly depends on the deployment of ambulance home bases, i.e., locations where ambulances and their crews are strategically positioned, ready to respond to emergency calls. This paper presents a general Discrete Event Simulation (DES) model designed to capture the stochastic behaviour and workflow of regional ambulance emergency systems. The proposed model incorporates and integrates information collected from different sources, reproducing very accurately the operation of the ambulance system, thus allowing a more comprehensive and realistic analysis. To show the applicability and reliability of the proposed general model, a case study provided by the Azienda Regionale Emergenza Sanitaria - ARES 118 (an Italian Regional Emergency Medical Services Authority - ARES 118) is presented. It concerns a territory within the Lazio region of Italy, including a medium-size city along with sparsely populated areas. The reported results about scenario analyses highlight how the model we propose can be fruitfully used by the managers to improve effectiveness and quickness of the entire regional EMS system. 1 Introduction Emergency Medical Services (EMSs) play a central role in healthcare delivery, ensuring rapid medical assistance in acute and life-threatening situations. In practice, an EMS provides the prehospital care for a patient according to the following typical steps: 1) to respond to an emergency call and perform the first assessment of the patient conditions; 2) if necessary, to dispatch an ambulance to the emergency scene; 3) to perform patient first treatment on-site; 4) if necessary, to transfer the patient to an Emergency Department (ED) and, after dropping off the patient, return to the base or head to another emergency scene. Therefore, the effectiveness of EMS largely depend upon the operational efficiency of ambulance services, as a timely arrival to patient location is essential in order to initiate early care and stabilize clinical conditions before hospital treatment can begin. Hence, ambulances represent one of the most important resource within EMS and the main Key Performance Indicator (KPI) is the Response Time (RT), i.e., the time interval between an emergency call being received and an ambulance arriving to the emergency scene. RT is critical for the effectiveness of prehospital care, e.g., medical interventions provided to patients at the scene and during transport to an ED. In time critical conditions (e.g., cardiac arrest, major trauma or stroke) even a small reduction of the RT can substantially increase survival probability and improve clinical outcomes (see, e.g. [ 9 ] ). A key factor strongly affecting RT is the location of the ambulance home bases, the deployment of ambulances among the bases and the dispatching of ambulance to the emergency scene. This motivates the great attention devoted to ambulance location and deployment, namely to the following two issues: 1. ambulance home bases location ( location problem ) 2. ambulance deployment among the bases ( deployment problem ). Note that if the vehicles are identical, ambulance deployment reduces to determine the number of ambulances assigned at each base. Bases are the locations where ambulances and their crews are strategically positioned within a territory ready to respond to emergency calls. Even if the locations of these bases have a significant impact on the quality and effectiveness of prehospital (and potentially also hospital) care, in practice, ambulance base locations are often determined only according to some generic guidelines or administrative convenience rather than by systematic data driven analysis. That is, usually, bases tend to be located in some sites without a rigorous evaluation about some criterion related to current demand patterns. The same holds for ambulance deployment among the bases. It is worth noticing that the size of a deployment problem for realistic instance is very large. In fact, if we consider n identical ambulances to be deployed in m bases, each of them contain any number of ambulances, the resulting deployments are \binom{n+m-1}{n} . Therefore, if ambulance emergency system performance evaluation is time consuming (as when simulation is used), any strategy based on the comparison of all the deployments can not be employed. In this paper we introduce a general purpose and reusable Discrete Event Simulation (DES) model capable of representing the operational dynamics of ambulance emergency system, aiming at improving its overall effectiveness by means of an enhanced base location and deployment of the ambulance fleet in a region. This general model enables to simultaneously consider both location and deployment problem and it can be used for both scenario analysis to compare the performance of alternative configurations and within the Simulation Based Optimization (SBO) approach to identify configurations that optimize some KPIs. It is important to highlight that the proposed modelling framework may need to be adapted to reflect the EMS system under study’s specific characteristics, including its dispatching protocols, fleet composition and hospital network configuration. Nevertheless, the model we propose provide a general and flexible framework that can easily be customized for different operational contexts. The distinguishing features of the proposed model lie in a more accurate and realistic representation of ambulance system operations compared with existing models in the literature. Recent survey papers on ambulance location and deployment problems (see the very recent paper [ 39 ] ) highlight that many existing models rely on simplifying assumptions that limit their ability to represent real EMS operations. Therefore, in the last years, research in DES applied to ambulance location problem mainly focused on building models that reproduce the entire ambulance service process as realistically as possible. Our work addresses the limitations existing in many models through a realistic DES framework that explicitly models the full operational path of an ambulance mission. In particular, this is achieved by weakening some simplifying assumptions commonly adopted in the literature. For instance, we incorporate operational delays that are frequently neglected in the literature [ 26 , 68 ] , such as telephone triage and ambulance preparation times, which are modeled using empirical distributions estimated from historical data. As stated in [ 39 ] in their review, 66% of studies considered either set triage time to zero or not mention it, and 78% disregarded preparation time. These omissions can lead to a significant overestimation of the effectiveness of relocation strategies, as demonstrated by the tests carried out. Moreover, many models do not explicitly consider times due to ambulance offload delay and ambulance ramping 1 1 1 The term “ambulance ramping” (see, e.g., [ 41 ] ) means that patients arriving at EDs via ambulance cannot be transferred into the ED’s care in a timely manner and the ambulance is “ramped”. It does not mean the patient is still in the back of the ambulance, just that the transfer of care from ambulance crew to the ED clinicians has not yet happened. , i.e. the possibility that an ambulance arrives at the ED but no bed or staff are available to take over

Read the complete text