Testing the robustness of topological quantities evaluated from the modular Hamiltonian for a given wavefunction

Sandeep Sharma, Ajit C. Balram · 2026

Read Testing the robustness of topological quantities evaluated from the modular Hamiltonian for a given wavefunction by Sandeep Sharma, Ajit C. Balram (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-24058.txt.

Introduction

Sharma and Balram test whether modular Hamiltonian methods can reliably pull topological numbers out of a wavefunction. Working with a lattice model of fractional quantum Hall states, they extract quantities for the Laughlin and Moore-Read states and watch them converge to expected values. Convergence slows as correlation length grows, so reliable extraction demands large systems. Their results support modular methods as a sound route to topological content, given enough size.

Catalog record

CREATORSandeep Sharma, Ajit C. Balram
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34801
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.24058

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Testing the robustness of topological quantities evaluated from the modular Hamiltonian for a given wavefunction Sandeep Sharma, Ajit C. Balram Abstract Topologically ordered states are characterized by topological quantities like the Hall conductance, topological entanglement entropy, and chiral central charge. Techniques based on the modular Hamiltonian have recently been developed to extract these quantities from a wavefunction. Here, we consider a lattice model of fractional quantum Hall states, a prototypical example of topologically ordered systems, and extract their topological content using the modular Hamiltonian-based methods. We consider the bosonic Laughlin and Moore-Read states and show that the extracted topological quantum numbers converge to their expected results. As expected, the convergence is slower when the correlation length of the state is longer. Generally, our results show that a reliable extraction of topological content through modular methods requires the usage of large systems. I Introduction Gapped quantum many-body systems in two dimensions (2D) can exhibit phases of matter that carry topological order 30 . These phases cannot be characterized using any local order parameter and lie beyond the conventional Landau paradigm of classifying phases by the symmetries they spontaneously break 16 ; 8 . Topologically ordered matter possesses highly non-local long-range quantum entanglement, hosts Abelian 18 ; 31 ; 1 or non-Abelian 21 ; 29 excitations that obey anyonic braiding statistics, and has ground state degeneracy 27 ; 26 that depends on the topology of the manifold on which the system is placed, and supports chiral gapless modes at its boundary 28 . These properties are topological in nature, meaning the topological content of the phase is invariant under smooth deformation of the Hamiltonian or the ground state until the bulk energy gap closes, i.e., a quantum critical point is reached, provided the topology of the background manifold on which the system resides remains unchanged. A paradigmatic example of a topologically ordered phase is a fractional quantum Hall (FQH) fluid 25 ; 17 . FQH states have a global U(1) symmetry associated with charge conservation, resulting in quantization of the electrical Hall conductance, \sigma_{xy}{=}(e^{2}/h)\nu , where \nu is a rational number called the filling fraction. Another topological quantum number that is a characteristic feature of an FQH phase is its chiral central charge, c_{-} , that encodes information on the chiral gapless edge modes that the FQH state supports. The thermal Hall conductance, \kappa_{xy} , is related to c_{-} as 11 ; 4 , \kappa_{xy}=c_{-}\left(\frac{\pi^{2}k_{B}^{2}}{3h}\right)T (1) at a temperature T , that is much less than the bulk energy gap, provided the edge modes fully equilibrate. For many FQH states, \kappa_{xy} has been experimentally measured 2 ; 3 , and found to be in good agreement with Eq. ( 1 ). Another topological quantum number that is a feature of topologically ordered phases, albeit one which has not yet been experimentally accessible, is its topological entanglement entropy (TEE) 15 ; 19 , which quantifies its long-range quantum entanglement. Gapped ground states, such as those in the FQH regime, are expected to follow the area law of entanglement entropy. Consider the ground state described by the many-body wavefunction |\Psi\rangle . Defining the density matrix \rho{=}|\Psi\rangle\langle\Psi| and partitioning the system into two parts A and its complement A^{c} , as shown in Fig. 1(a) , the entanglement entropy of the region A is given by S(\rho_{A})=\alpha|\partial A|-\gamma+\cdots, (2) where \rho_{A} is the reduced density matrix over the region A that is obtained from tracing out the degrees of freedom in A^{c} on \rho , i.e., \rho_{A}{=}{\rm Tr}_{A^{c}}\left(\rho\right) . In Eq. ( 2 ), \alpha is a non-universal constant, |\partial A| is the length of the boundary of A , \gamma is the TEE, and ellipsis represents terms that vanish in the |\partial A|{\to}\infty limit. As with other topological quantum numbers, the TEE is invariant under smooth deformations of the Hamiltonian, provided a quantum critical point is not reached, and does not depend on the precise shape and size of the region A . The TEE is related to the anyonic content of the phase. In particular, for the \nu{=}1/m Laughlin FQH states 17 , that supports m Abelian anyons, the TEE \gamma_{1/m}^{\rm Laughlin}{=}(1/2)\ln(m) 14 . (a) (b) Figure 1 : Schematic illustration of a two-dimensional system, \Lambda , divided into (a) two regions, A and its complement A^{c} , with boundary |\partial A| , and (b) four regions A , B , C , and D . The disc-shaped region formed by the union of A , B , and C in (b) is utilized to extract the topological content of topologically ordered states. Recently, a versatile method based on modular Hamiltonians has been devised to extract the above topological quantities from a single bulk wavefunction 13 ; 12 ; 6 . For the region A , the modular Hamiltonian is defined [in analogy to a thermal state for which \rho{\propto}e^{-H/(k_{B}T)} , where H is the Hamiltonian] as K_{A}{=}{-}\ln(\rho_{A}){\otimes}\mathbb{I}_{A^{c}} , where \mathbb{I} is the identity matrix. Topological data is obtained by evaluating the modular Hamiltonian associated with the partitions within the disc-shaped region of Fig. 1(b) . Specifically, c_{-} can be obtained from the modular commutator 13 ; 12 , defined as the commutator of the modular Hamiltonians over two partially overlapping regions. Similarly, \sigma_{xy} is obtained from the commutator of the modular Hamiltonian and charge operator for two partially overlapping regions 6 . The TEE is extracted from an appropriate linear combination of the modular Hamiltonians associated with the various regions shown in Fig. 1(b) 15 ; 13 . In this paper, we test out these methods by numerically evaluating the topological quantum numbers on finite systems for the lattice model of the Abelian Laughlin 17 ; 22 and the non-Abelian Moore-Read 21 ; 9 states. We find that the topological quantum numbers extracted via the modular methods converge to their expected values. As anticipated, the convergence is slower and finite-size effects are stronger when the correlation length of the underlying state is longer. Our results indicate that fairly large systems are necessary to extract topological data using modular techniques reliably. The article is organized as follows: Sec. II provides a primer on the background material and is divided into two subsections, Sec. II.1 and Sec. II.2 . In Sec. II.1 , we discuss the modular-Hamiltonian-based techniques we use to compute the various topological quantities of the states. In Sec II.2 , following Refs. 22 ; 9 , we describe the lattice models of the Laughlin and Moore-Read wavefunctions that were derived using correlators of certain conformal operators, for which we will calculate the topological quantities. In Sec. III , we present our numerical results and compare them against theoretical expectations. We conclude the paper in Sec. IV with a summary of our results and provide an outlook for future work. II Methods and model wavefunctions In Sec. II.1 , we discuss the methodology of extracting topological quantities using the modular Hamiltonian for a given wavefunction. Then, in Sec. II.2 , we discuss the lattice version of two candidate states, namely the Laughlin and Moore-Read states, to which we will apply the modular Hamiltonian methodology to extract their topological content. II.1 Methodology Consider a 2D many-body gapped system with a locally finite-dimensional Hilbert

Read the complete text