Non-unique time and market incompleteness

Chris Angstmann, Tim Gebbie · 2026

Read Non-unique time and market incompleteness by Chris Angstmann, Tim Gebbie (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-23608.txt.

Introduction

Angstmann and Gebbie challenge the habit of modelling markets as if time were one shared, continuous clock across all assets. Real markets are asynchronous and event-driven, with random gaps between events, so they revisit no-arbitrage and option pricing for discrete event systems. Their central suggestion is that non-unique continuum limits point to a deeper form of market incompleteness, with effective completeness re-emerging only at longer horizons.

Catalog record

CREATORChris Angstmann, Tim Gebbie
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26926
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.23608

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Non-unique time and market incompleteness Chris Angstmann, Tim Gebbie Abstract Financial markets are often modelled as if time were unique and continuous across assets and markets. Financial markets are however asynchronous, order flow is event-driven, and waiting times between events are often random. Many of the most influential formulations of financial market models presuppose a unique global calendar time and advocate for this or that preferred single latent continuous-time price system. Here we critically contrast these assumptions with event-time, renewal, point-process, and order-flow descriptions. We revisit no-arbitrage, no-dynamic-arbitrage, and risk-neutral option pricing in settings where the market is represented as a discrete event system and where the continuum limit of a discrete-time random walk need not be unique. The central suggestion is then that such non-uniqueness points to a more foundational form of market incompleteness than is usually emphasized. This highlights the importance of operational time at the level of decision making but reminds market practitioners that managing risk itself often requires reconciling operational time with a global calendar time. At these longer time scales forms of effective or average completeness may still emerge at lower frequencies and remain useful for portfolio construction and risk management, even if high-frequency hedging and execution expose a clock mismatch between trading, pricing, and longer-horizon allocation. MSC 82C41 91G60 91G60 91B26 JEL 91G70 Contents 1 Introduction A large part of modern mathematical finance is organized around a single calendar-time price process, usually represented as a semi-martingale adapted to a filtration {\cal F}_{t} indexed by t\geq 0 . This representational approach supports stochastic integration, dynamic hedging, and the standard no-arbitrage to martingale-measure logic associated with the fundamental theorem of asset pricing (FTAP). In parallel, market microstructure and high-frequency econometrics have developed an event-driven view in which the primitive objects are trades, quotes, order submissions, cancellations, queue dynamics, and the random durations between events. The practical tension between these two views is now familiar, but its conceptual implications are perhaps not as well understood. The issue is whether markets are best understood as a price processes observed irregularly in calendar time, or as a discrete event systems from which prices emerge only after aggregation, synchronization, and time change operations. The historical lineage for this problem runs from Clark’s stochastic business time in the early 1970s [ 17 ] , through the mixture-of-distributions and transaction-time literature of the 1970s and 1980s [ 18 , 25 , 48 , 29 ] , to the duration, point-process, and Hawkes-process literature of the 1990s and 2000s [ 23 , 2 , 9 , 6 ] , and then to finance CTRW models [ 39 , 38 , 47 , 40 ] and recent DTRW constructions [ 4 ] . To set the scene we begin by making a strict distinction between ontology (how we chose to represent models) and epistemology (what observations and measurement tells us about what is being modelled). Ontology concerns what is taken to be primitive in a model of financial markets: a calendar-time price process, or a discrete event sequence. This is the choice of modelling framework. Epistemology is then concerned with what can be inferred from the data and how strongly one is entitled to treat observations e.g. high-frequency records, as samples from a unique latent continuous-time system. This is then about understanding what in fact can be inferred from the data. This separation is useful because many debates in empirical finance conflate the object being modelled with the measurement approach used to estimate it. 2 The choice of modelling frameworks 2.1 The price-first representation In the classical price-first ontology or representation, the primitive object is a price process S=(S_{t})_{t\geq 0} , often taken to be a semi-martingale, Itô diffusion, or jump-diffusion. This tradition begins with Bachelier and reaches a canonical modern form in Black and Scholes 1973 and the martingale approach of Harrison and Kreps Harrison and Kreps 1979 , Harrison and Pliska 1981 , Dalang et al. 1990 , and Delbaen and Schachermayer 1994 . In this setting, calendar time is baked into the filtration and into the admissible class of trading strategies. The attractions of the framework are well known: it supports stochastic integration, self-financing strategies, replication arguments, and state-price deflators or equivalent martingale measures [ 5 , 7 , 41 , 30 , 31 , 19 , 20 ] . The price-first ontology is powerful, but it is also a modelling commitment. It presupposes that the relevant economic state can be expressed as a process evolving on a single time axis and that the market’s observable irregularity can be treated either as noise, as a sampling issue, or as a perturbation around the latent calendar-time evolution. This is often a useful approximation, especially at lower frequencies, but it is not conceptually neutral as it forces a specific ontology. 2.2 The event-first representation In the event-first ontology or representation, the primitive objects are orders, trades, quotes, cancellations, and the matching rules through which market states change. Price is emergent: it is a derived object summarizing the interaction of supply, demand, and liquidity under the market’s execution protocol. This view is common in market microstructure and in modern point-process descriptions of limit order books and event arrivals [ 36 , 49 , 26 , 21 , 6 ] . The historical roots of the event-first view in finance are older than the recent order-book literature. Clark’s [ 17 ] subordination model already suggested that calendar time is not the economically relevant clock for speculative prices. Time subordination changes both scaling and dependence properties of limiting price processes 1 1 1 Randomising the trading clock changes return distributions: Clark’s business-time subordination model gives a finite-variance example. In finance-oriented CTRW models, heavy-tailed waiting times can produce fractional, non-Markovian calendar-time dynamics, so the key modelling choice is the operational (business) time rather than calendar time itself [ 37 , 45 , 40 ] . . Subsequent work by Epps and Epps 1976 , Copeland 1976 , Tauchen and Pitts 1983 and Harris 1987 turned explicitly to transaction volume, transaction counts, and sequential information arrival as mechanisms linking event activity to return distributions and volatility [ 17 , 25 , 18 , 48 , 29 ] . What changes in later microstructure work is that the event system itself becomes the primary explanatory object rather than merely a latent variance-mixing device (in some imposed calendar time representation). 3 What is inferred from High-Frequency Data? High-frequency financial data are discrete, irregularly spaced, and typically asynchronous across assets and venues. Yet a substantial part of the econometric literature treats such data as non-synchronous observations of a unique latent continuous-time system, developing estimators that aim to recover integrated covariance, lead–lag structure, or other latent calendar-time characteristics despite the fundamental nature of both the noise and asynchrony [ 32 , 1 , 16 , 33 ] . That project is mathematically sophisticated and empirically useful, but it is not epistemologically clean nor innocent. To infer a latent calendar-time covariance is already to assume that such an object exists and is primary. A different reading of the same data is possible: one may regard measured covariance and correlation as scale-dependent observables whose values depend on synchronization conventions, aggregation schemes, and the choice

Read the complete text