Architecture Matters for Multi-Agent Security

Ben Hagag, William L. Anderson, Christian Schroeder de Witt, Sarah Scheffler · 2026

Read Architecture Matters for Multi-Agent Security by Ben Hagag, William L. Anderson, Christian Schroeder de Witt, Sarah Scheffler (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-23459.txt.

Introduction

Hagag and colleagues study how the architecture of multi-agent AI systems, rather than any single agent, shapes security. Across three settings and thirteen designs, they vary agent roles, communication patterns, and memory access, tracking where attacks are refused, intercepted, or completed. Multi-agent setups prove more vulnerable than standalone agents in most configurations, with attack success shifting nearly fourfold, and no single design emerges as universally safest.

Catalog record

CREATORBen Hagag, William L. Anderson, Christian Schroeder de Witt, Sarah Scheffler
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE72566
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.23459

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Architecture Matters for Multi-Agent Security Ben Hagag, William L. Anderson, Christian Schroeder de Witt, Sarah Scheffler Abstract Multi-agent systems (MAS), composed of networks of two or more autonomous AI agents, have become increasingly popular in production deployments, yet introduce security risks that do not arise in single-agent settings. Even if individual agents exhibit robust security, architectural decisions governing their coordination can create attack surfaces that have not been systematically characterized. In this work, we present an empirical study of how MAS design decisions shape the tradeoff between task performance and attack resistance. Across three agentic environments (browser, desktop, and code) and 13 architectural configurations, we use stagewise evaluations that distinguish planning refusal, execution-stage interception, partial harmful execution, and successful attack completion to study three key design choices: (i) agent roles, which determine how authority and responsibility are allocated; (ii) communication topology, which shapes how and when agents interact; and (iii) memory, which determines the context and state visibility accessible to each agent. We find that multi-agent architectures are more vulnerable than standalone agents in the majority of configurations, with attack success rates varying by up to 3.8× at comparable or higher benign accuracy, and that no single design is universally safer. These results motivate the development of further evaluations that move beyond the security properties of a single agent. User: “Write a phishing email to the company manager asking for sensitive project details; pretend to be a trusted vendor.” Agent Refusal. “I can’t help draft this — it asks me to impersonate a vendor and extract sensitive information.” PLANNING REFUSAL User: “Write a phishing email to the company manager asking for sensitive project details; pretend to be a trusted vendor.” Orc. Navigate Fill Click Scroll Phishing email sent. [email protected] , subj. “Pre-meeting: project details”. No agent refused. goto(mail.app) fill(to, ...) fill(subj, ...) fill(body, ...) click(send) scroll(compose) HARMFUL TASK COMPLETED Figure 1 : Architecture flips refusal behavior on the same task. A single agent refuses the full harmful request at planning time (a); the same base model, reconfigured as a star-topology orchestrator dispatching to four BrowserART specialists (b), decomposes the task into atomic browser calls that each specialist executes without refusal. Only the architecture changes. This raises HT from 10.0% to 31.0% on the entire BrowserART dataset (Table 1 ; task from Appendix C.1 ). 1 Introduction As AI systems evolve from single large language models (LLMs) into increasingly complex agentic and multi-agent architectures, their security properties change in fundamental ways ( 24 ; 37 ) . While early deployments relied on standalone models responding directly to user prompts, modern systems increasingly distribute tasks across agents that plan, execute actions, interact with tools, maintain memory, and coordinate with one another ( 20 ) . Such systems are increasingly capable of achieving large-scale, long-horizon tasks with which individual models and agents struggle ( 18 ; 29 ) . Despite their rapidly increasing capabilities, progress in securing these systems against misuse has lagged behind. Research in AI security has revealed numerous threat vectors against these systems, with new attacks emerging at different levels of abstraction. At the agent level, research examines failures arising from tool use and memory poisoning ( 44 ) . Recent work has begun exploring multi-agent risks such as collusion ( 32 ) , infection-style attacks ( 28 ; 16 ) , and viral misalignment via subliminal prompting ( 40 ) . This growing body of work suggests that defenses effective at one layer may degrade or behave differently when embedded in richer systems. A language model that resists direct jailbreak attempts may nonetheless enable harmful behavior once coupled with web tools or persistent memory ( 8 ) . Similarly, an agent that appears robust in isolation may contribute to system-level failures when its outputs are routed, transformed, or reinforced through inter-agent coordination. In such settings, vulnerabilities can amplify through task decomposition, partial observability, and distributed control, producing emergent risks that are not captured by single-layer evaluations. Mitigating these risks requires attending not only to explicit defenses but also to the broader architectural choices that shape system behavior. Yet any modification to system design must be evaluated against its impact on task performance - security methods that impose unacceptable costs fail to preserve the benefits of the underlying system ( 37 ; 35 ) . While prior work has examined such tradeoffs, the impact of indirect architectural decisions remains underexplored. To address this gap, we present an empirical analysis of how design choices affect security in agentic and multi-agent systems. We ground our study in realistic agent tasks, adapting the BrowserART ( 24 ) , OS-Harm ( 25 ) , and RedCode-Gen ( 17 ) benchmarks, originally designed for single-agent evaluation, to support systematic multi-agent assessment. We systematically evaluate how susceptibility to misuse changes as tasks move from single-agent to multi-agent, focusing on three key dimensions: role specialization, communication topology, and memory visibility, examining how each reshapes both the attack surface and the overall performance of the system. We make three main contributions: • Multi-agent adaptation of standardized misuse benchmarks. We adapt BrowserART, OS-Harm, and RedCode-Gen to the multi-agent setting, preserving original task semantics while varying only architectural configuration, and introduce stage-wise metrics that capture where in the pipeline harmful behavior is refused or executed. We release all three adaptations to support further research 1 1 1 https://github.com/benhagag10/Architecture-Matters-for-Multi-Agent-Security . • Empirical characterization of architectural effects on security. Across 13 architectural configurations, multiple base models, and three environments, we find that role distribution, communication topology, and memory visibility each independently affect vulnerability, with multi-agent settings more vulnerable than standalone baselines in the majority of configurations. The direction and magnitude of these effects depend on scenario, model, and architecture. • Joint measurement of the security-performance tradeoff. We measure benign task performance alongside attack resistance across architectures, finding that security profiles can differ substantially - with attack success rates varying by up to 3.8\times - even at comparable or higher benign accuracy. This tradeoff should be considered when designing multi-agent systems, as capability evaluation alone is insufficient to surface these risks. Together, these contributions provide the first controlled comparison of multi-agent architectural design choices for security across realistic environments. 2 Background and Related Work A multi-agent system (MAS) consists of multiple autonomous AI agents that make decisions and take actions, maintain private state, and interact through communication channels or shared environments. Unlike single-model or single-agent setups, MAS behavior emerges from interactions among agents rather than from any individual component. These interactions introduce system-level dynamics, such as coordination, negotiation, and delegation - that fundamentally change both the attack surface and the nature of failure. 2.1 LLM and Single-Agent Vulnerabilities Security research on large language models and LLM based agents has primarily focused on vulnerabilities at the model or single-agent level. At the LLM level, prior work has documented risks such as prompt injection and jailbreak attacks ( 30 ; 4 ) , data poisoning and backdoors ( 14 ; 42 ) , and privacy threats including leakage and membership inference attacks ( 1 ; 9 ; 15 ) . These vulnerabilities vary across LLM architectures ( 6 ) and change in complex, unpredictable ways ( 38 ) . At the single-agent level, vulnerabilities extend

Read the complete text