Ground measurements of the gravitational redshift questioned: re-establishing the physical bases
Anna M. Nobili, Alberto Anselmi · 2026
Read Ground measurements of the gravitational redshift questioned: re-establishing the physical bases by Anna M. Nobili, Alberto Anselmi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-23250.txt.
Introduction
Nobili and Anselmi defend the Pound-Rebka measurement of gravitational redshift against a 2024 claim that it measured only a Doppler shift from reaction forces. They argue the claim rests on a misunderstanding of reference systems plus an unphysical reading of non-gravitational forces. Restoring the experiment to its place, they re-establish the physical bases of simple but fundamental questions in gravitational physics. The paper thus answers alleged inconsistencies in the literature with a careful re-examination of frames and forces.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Anna M. Nobili, Alberto Anselmi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40671 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.23250
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Ground measurements of the gravitational redshift questioned: re-establishing the physical bases Anna M. Nobili, Alberto Anselmi Abstract Motivated by alleged inconsistencies in the scientific and educational literature, Asenbaum, Overstreet and Kasevic (2024) aim to clarify some fundamental concepts in the physics of gravitation. To this end they reexamine the first experimental measurement of the gravitational redshift by Pound and Rebka in 1960, claiming that it did not in fact measure the gravitational redshift predicted by Einstein almost half a century earlier, but rather a Doppler shift originating from non-gravitational reaction forces. We show that their conclusion arises from a misunderstanding of the reference systems involved, along with an unphysical interpretation of non gravitational forces. Thus, our work restores the Pound and Rebka experiment to its rightful place in Physics. I Introduction Inside a non rotating “Einstein Elevator (EE)” freely falling in a flat non rotating Earth in which special relativity rules, the equivalence between inertial and gravitational mass holds for all matter, there are no non gravitational forces and all Test Masses (TMs) have zero initial velocity, it is found that gravity has no effects and cannot be detected. With the same assumptions, in the “Flat Earth” system in which the EE is falling it is possible to test the Weak Equivalence Principle (WEP) through the Universality of Free Fall (UFF) and to measure the gravitational redshift as predicted by Einstein in 1911 6 (available in 4 with the title “ On the influence of gravitation on the propagation of light ”) . Asenbaum, Overstreet and Kasevich 1 (AOK hereafter) express their concerns that at research and education level there are inconsistencies about these fundamental concepts and concentrate on clarifying the underlying issues, in particular regarding the gravitational redshift. They consider a light source, a detector and an observer freely falling as in the EE system and conclude that the frequency shift is zero –as it should be in this system– but only because the Doppler and the gravitational frequency shifts have opposite sign and cancel each other out. Then, by building on this result, they revisit the first experimental measurement of the gravitational redshift by Pound and Rebka in 1960 14 coming to the astonishing conclusion –which has motivated this work– that they did not measure the gravitational redshift but rather a Doppler shift originated from the non gravitational reaction forces which keep at rest in the lab the emitter and the absorber of \gamma rays used in the experiment, by counteracting their weight. Both these conclusions arise from a basic misunderstanding on the reference systems involved in the experiments and the physics therein. In Sec. II we show that in the EE system there is neither a gravitational nor an equal and opposite Doppler shift, neither for photons nor for clocks. The result by AOK of a Doppler and a gravitational shift cancelling each other out is correct for a source and a detector falling free in the Flat Earth reference system and observed therein, an obvious result that has nothing to do with what happens inside a free falling Einstein Elevator (within the assumptions made at the beginning). In Sec. III we analyze, along the same lines, the Pound and Rebka experiment 14 and its re-interpretation by AOK. We show beyond question that such re-interpretation is based on their previous incorrect result plus a new, unphysical statement about the rôle of the reaction force which keeps source and detector at rest in the lab. Therefore, Pound and Rebka have indeed measured the gravitational redshift predicted in 1911. In concluding their analysis AOK write that a new measurement of the gravitational redshift might be possible in the near future in which, unlike the Pound and Rebka experiment, no non gravitational support force is involved to keep the source and the detector at rest, letting them free to fall. We anticipate that, should they be able to carry out such an experiment they must be prepared to finding a net zero frequency shift, even to second order (as long as gravity gradients can be neglected). In Sec. IV we conclude by summarizing the main results of our analysis while adding a few general considerations on the gravitational redshift, the experiments to measure it and their overall physical relevance as compared to tests of the WEP and UFF. II A basic analysis of gravitational and Doppler frequency shift in free fall Let us consider a reference system, named “Flat Earth” (FE), for which the following set of assumptions H holds: H1 FE is at rest on a flat, non rotating Earth and there is no other source mass. The Earth’s radius is infinite compared to any distance of physical interest in the system, i.e. there are no gravity gradients (no tidal effects). Special relativity rules. H2 The equivalence between inertial and gravitational mass holds for all matter (clocks and ordinary matter alike), i.e. WEP and UFF are not violated. H3 There are no non gravitational forces. H4 All TMs have initial zero velocity. FE, sketched in 2D in Fig. 1 , is an inertial reference system where the same gravitational acceleration \vec{g}_{\oplus} acts at any point (regardless of the presence of a TM or not) because of H1. Figure 1: 2D sketch of the “Flat Earth” (FE) inertial reference system in which the set of assumptions H holds and \vec{g}_{\oplus} is the same everywhere ( g_{\oplus}\simeq 9.8\,\rm ms^{-2}) . The free to fall (unsupported) test masses m_{1},m_{2} are shown at initial time with zero velocity. For the free TMs m_{1},m_{2} , under the assumptions H, the Observer \rm{O_{FE}} writes the equation of motion: \ddot{z}=-g_{\oplus} (1) whereby they both fall along z towards z=0 with the same acceleration. During the time of fall they maintain the same relative position as at initial time with increasing but equal velocities. Let us now imagine that the TMs m_{1},m_{2} are enclosed in a (non rotating) “Einstein Elevator” (EE) which, with assumptions H, is falling with the same acceleration as the TMs and the Observer \rm{O_{EE}} inside it. Fig. 2 shows both the FE and the EE reference systems. Figure 2: The “Einstein Elevator” (EE) reference system, enclosing the TMs m_{1},m_{2} and the Observer \rm{O_{EE}} , is freely falling in the inertial FE system. EE is an accelerated, non inertial reference system. We analyze the physics inside the EE from the point of view of the Observers \rm{O_{FE}} and \rm{O_{EE}} , and make sure that they reach the same result. Even if unable to look inside the EE, the Observer \rm{O_{FE}} can tell that the Elevator, its Observer and the TMs maintain their positions for the entire duration of the fall, by reasoning as follows. \rm{O_{FE}} knows that the EE is an accelerated non inertial system with acceleration \vec{g}_{{}_{\oplus}} . Therefore, at any point inside the Elevator there must be an inertial force (proportional to the inertial mass m^{i} ) equal and opposite to the gravitational one (proportional to the gravitational mass m^{g} ). He concludes that the equation of motion inside EE is: m^{i}\ddot{z}^{\prime}=-m^{g}g_{\oplus}+m^{i}g_{\oplus} (2) hence, with H2 ( m^{i}=m^{g} ): \ddot{z}^{\prime}=-g_{{}_{\oplus}}+g_{{}_{\oplus}}=0\ \ (3) and therefore the TMs remain at rest inside EE. As for \rm{O_{EE}} , he observes that all masses originally at