Visualizing Vortex Cluster Dynamics in the Weak Type-II Superconductor CaSb 2

Yusuke Iguchi, Nabhanila Nandi, Mohamed Oudah · 2026

Read Visualizing Vortex Cluster Dynamics in the Weak Type-II Superconductor CaSb 2 by Yusuke Iguchi, Nabhanila Nandi, Mohamed Oudah (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-23117.txt.

Introduction

Iguchi, Nandi, and Oudah use SQUID imaging to see vortex cluster dynamics in the weak type-II superconductor CaSb2. They reveal dense clusters with enhanced boundary susceptibility and suppressed internal vortex motion, unlike isolated vortex or flux tube behavior. These are the first local views of magnetic dynamics within vortex clusters in a weakly pinned superconductor. Although superfluid density matches a one-gap BCS picture and the Ginzburg-Landau parameter sits outside the type-II/1 regime, clustering and uneven dynamics point beyond existing microscopic theories for single-band superconductors.

Catalog record

CREATORYusuke Iguchi, Nabhanila Nandi, Mohamed Oudah
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24750
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.23117

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Visualizing Vortex Cluster Dynamics in the Weak Type-II Superconductor CaSb 2 Yusuke Iguchi, Nabhanila Nandi, Mohamed Oudah Abstract Scanning SQUID imaging of CaSb 2 reveals dense vortex clusters with enhanced boundary susceptibility and suppressed internal vortex motion, which features inconsistent with both isolated‑vortex and flux tube behaviors. These measurements provide the first local visualization of magnetic dynamics within vortex clusters in a weakly pinned superconductor, offering a new route to probe non‑monotonic vortex–vortex interactions that are typically expected in single‑band type‑II/1 or multiband type‑1.5 superconductors. Although the superfluid density follows a single‑gap BCS model and the Ginzburg–Landau parameter of CaSb 2 lies slightly outside the type‑II/1 regime, vortex clustering and spatially inhomogeneous dynamics are clearly observed, indicating physics beyond existing microscopic theories for single‑band superconductors. The spatial arrangement of vortices in superconductors reflects the interplay of magnetic screening, superfluid stiffness, and vortex–vortex interactions. While type-II superconductors typically host a repulsively interacting Abrikosov vortex lattice Abrikosov1957 , theoretical studies predict non-monotonic interactions, with short-range repulsion and long-range attraction, near the critical Ginzburg–Landau parameter \kappa_{0}=1/\sqrt{2} Eilenberger1969 ; Brandt1976 ; Klein1987 . Microscopic calculations based on the Eilenberger or Bogoliubov–de Gennes formalisms confirm that clean single-component superconductors with intermediate \kappa values ( 0.6\lesssim\kappa\lesssim 1.1 at T=0 ) can support attractive long-range interactions and form vortex clusters, hallmarks of the type-II/1 regime Klein1987 ; Weber1987 ; Neverov2024 . Beyond the single-component case, non-monotonic vortex–vortex interactions can also emerge in multicomponent or symmetry-broken superconductors through distinct microscopic mechanisms, including the type-1.5 regime in multiband systems Babaev2005 ; Silaev2011 ; Carlstrom2011 and related effects in systems with multilayer structures Varney2013 , strong anisotropy Silaev2018 , coexisting magnetic orders Tachiki1979 , or non-centrosymmetric pairing Garaud2020 ; Samoilenka2020 . Experimentally, vortex clusters and related morphologies have been directly imaged in several candidate materials Huebener2001 ; Brandt-Essmann1987 ; Moshchalkov2009 ; Nishio2010 ; Ge2014 ; Ooi2025 . However, their origin remain debated: clustered configurations may reflect thermodynamically stable states arising from intrinsic non-monotonic interactions, or result from disorder-induced pinning. Thus, although static magnetic imaging has revealed clustered morphologies, direct experimental access to the underlying vortex interactions remain limited. CaSb 2 is a recently discovered superconductor that provides a promising platform to address this challenge. It crystallizes in a non-symmorphic structure ( P2_{1}/m ) and hosts topologically non-trivial Dirac-like bands near the Fermi level Oudah2022 ; Ikeda2022 . Evidence for multiband superconductivity comes from penetration depth and specific heat studies Duan2022 , while nuclear quadrupole resonance suggests a fully gapped behavior Takahashi2021 , leaving the gap structure unresolved. Muon spin relaxation experiments further report time-reversal symmetry breaking Oudah2024 . Estimates of \kappa along the c -axis range from \sim 0.95 to 1.4 , overlapping with the type-II/1 regime, although values within the ab plane are larger ( \kappa\sim 3 ) Ikeda2020 ; Ikeda2022 ; Oudah2022 ; Oudah2024 . While CaSb 2 preserves global inversion symmetry, its non-symmorphic structure implies local inversion symmetry breaking Fischer2023 . However its possible consequences for vortex physics remain unclear. Despite these suggestive parameters, no direct magnetic imaging of vortex configurations in CaSb 2 has been reported. In particular, whether the vortex–vortex interactions exhibit non-monotonic behavior is an open experimental question that we address in this work. Table 1: GL parameters of CaSb 2 . The GL coherence length \xi and penetration depth \lambda are listed with the crystal directions parallel to the applied field. ( \kappa_{0}\simeq 0.707 ) \xi(0) [nm] \lambda(0) [nm] \kappa=\lambda/\xi Ref poly 36–44 >240 >5.4 Ikeda2020 ab 116 89.5 0.77(.04) Oudah2022 ab 149-166 3.2-3.9 Ikeda2022 ab 202 2.90(.26) Oudah2024 c 52-57 1.1-1.4 Ikeda2022 c 66 0.95(.12) Oudah2024 c 93 1.41–1.79 Duan2022 c 87-170 1.32–3.27 This work Figure 1: Scanning SQUID susceptometry measurements on CaSb 2 with the applied field normal to ab plane yield a temperature dependence of the superfluid density consistent with a single-gap BCS model, showing clear deviations from previously proposed multiband models Duan2022 . Figure 2: Local observation of partially collective vortex cluster dynamics. (a-b) Magnetometry \Phi and susceptometry \chi over an isolated vortex at 1.5 K in CaSb 2 , together with schematic illustrations (left). These serve as a reference for evaluating cluster behavior. (c–e) Left: schematic images of (c) magnetometry over a vortex cluster, (d) locally induced magnetic dynamics in a cluster, and (e) rigid-body-like collective oscillation of the entire cluster (shown for comparison). Right: corresponding measurements, (c) flux scan (from Fig. 3(c)), (d) susceptibility scan (from Fig. 3(g)), and (e) the derivative |\nabla\Phi| calculated from (c), representing the rigid-body approximation mode. Scale bars: 5 µm. In this work, we present a new application of scanning superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) susceptometry, probing the dynamic magnetic response of vortices within clusters. Using this method on the weak type-II superconductor CaSb 2 , we simultaneously image static flux and dynamic local susceptibility, uncovering vortex clustering with enhanced boundary response and suppressed internal dynamics. These features are suggestive of non-monotonic vortex–vortex interactions. Although low pinning in CaSb 2 prevents direct extraction of the intrinsic superfluid density within a cluster, our results establish the viability of this approach and define the experimental conditions necessary to differentiate between type-1.5 and type-II/1 superconductivity. Single crystals of CaSb 2 were grown using an Sb self-flux method Oudah2022 . We used a scanning SQUID susceptometer consisting of a pickup loop (PL) and a concentric field coil (FC) (see outlines in Fig. 2(b)) Kirtleyrsi2016 . The PL measures the local magnetic flux \Phi in units of the flux quantum \Phi_{0} at a loop–sample separation z , referred to as the height. An ac current of |I^{\text{ac}}|= 0.004–0.1 mA at 1020 Hz, supplied by an SR830 Lock-in-Amplifier, was applied through the FC to generate a localized oscillating magnetic field. Maximum fields generated at the sample surface is estimated as 0.5–13.4 µT at the typical scan height 1150 nm. We recorded both the quasi-static flux \Phi and the ac flux response \Phi^{\text{ac}} over the ab -plane surface of as-grown CaSb 2 , and express the local ac susceptibility as \chi=\Phi^{\text{ac}}/|I^{\text{ac}}| in units of \Phi_{0} /A. To establish the fundamental superconducting properties of our CaSb 2 samples, we first performed scanning SQUID susceptibility measurements as a function of temperature ( T=0.03 –1.74 K) on the same crystal used for vortex imaging. As shown in Fig. 1, the superconducting transition was clearly identified at T_{\text{c}}=1.72 K. From the local susceptibility signal, we estimated the magnetic penetration depth \lambda(T) with an effective radius of 790 nm and scan height of 400 nm ( \pm 30 nm) by following the established method Kirtley2012 . The extracted zero-temperature penetration depth \lambda(0) ranged from 87 to 170 nm, consistent with earlier tunneling diode oscillator measurements Duan2022 . However, the temperature dependence of the normalized superfluid density \lambda^{2}(0)/\lambda^{2}(T) closely follows a single-band fully-gapped Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) model with \lambda(0)=87 nm, in contrast to previous claims of multiband superconductivity Duan2022 . We then established the characteristic response of an isolated vortex in CaSb 2 by imaging in magnetometry and susceptometry modes [Figs. 2(a) & 2(b)]. These measurements serve as the reference for evaluating the behavior of vortex clusters. The magnetic flux profile of the isolated vortex at 1.5 K [Fig. 2(a)] fits well the monopole model Kirtleysst2016 [Fig. S1]. The best-fit penetration depth is 210 nm, consistent

Read the complete text