Decent actions of groups on restricted products

Chris Karpinski · 2026

Read Decent actions of groups on restricted products by Chris Karpinski (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-22635.txt.

Introduction

Karpinski asks when group actions on restricted products count as decent. A decent action gives subgroups with finite orbits a shared fixed point, and gives finitely generated subgroups whose members each fix a point one point fixed by all. He proves the automorphism group of a restricted product over the projective plane acts decently. The result extends work by Lonjou, Przytycki, and Urech.

Catalog record

CREATORChris Karpinski
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE97533
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.22635

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Decent actions of groups on restricted products Chris Karpinski Abstract An action of a group G G on a set X X is called “decent” if every subgroup of G G with a finite orbit in X X fixes a point in X X and every finitely generated subgroup of G G such that every element of the subgroup fixes a point of X X must itself have a global fixed point. In this article, we study conditions on when actions of groups on restricted products are “decent”. We prove that the action of the automorphism group of a restricted product with base space the projective plane ℙ 2 ​ ( k ) \mathbb{P}^{2}(k) over a field k k is decent, generalizing a result of Lonjou–Przytycki–Urech. 1 Introduction This paper examines actions of groups with various “fixed point” properties. Definition 1.1 . Let X_{0} be a set. An action of a group G on X_{0} is elliptic (respectively, purely elliptic ) if G has a global fixed point on X_{0} (respectively, each element of G fixes a point of X_{0} ). An element of G (respectively, a subgroup of G ) is called elliptic if it fixes a point of X_{0} . A recent question of interest has been to identify and study actions of groups on spaces having the property that every subgroup of the group that locally fixes points must have a global fixed point. Definition 1.2 . An action of a group G on a set X_{0} is decent if: 1. Every subgroup of G with a finite orbit on X_{0} fixes a point. 2. Every finitely generated subgroup of G acting purely elliptically on X_{0} fixes a point. The terminology of “decent actions” was first introduced in [ 6 , Definition 1.2] , where they appeared in the study of subgroups of the plane Cremona group \mathrm{C}_{2}(k) , which is the group of all birational transformations of the projective plane \mathbb{P}^{2}(k) over a field k . However, such actions have been studied in the literature before their apparition in [ 6 ] (see, for instance, [ 2 ] , [ 5 ] , [ 7 ] ). Decent actions appear in many natural examples. For instance, any isometric action of a group on a tree is decent (see, for instance, [ 1 , Proposition 2.5] ). For d=2,3 , any isometric action of a group on \mathbb{R}^{d} equipped with the Euclidean metric is decent ( [ 2 , Proposition 9.2] ). Also, by [ 3 , Chapter II.2, Corollary 2.8(1)] , item 1 in Definition 1.2 holds for any isometric action of a group on a complete CAT(0) space, however, item 2 in Definition 1.2 may fail even for actions on Hilbert spaces (for every n\geq 2 , examples of finitely generated groups of isometries of \mathbb{R}^{2n} with the Euclidean metric acting purely elliptically but not elliptically on \mathbb{R}^{2n} were constructed in [ 2 , Example 9.1] ). Haettel and Osajda conjecture in [ 5 ] that every action of a group on a “finite-dimensional non-positively curved complex” is decent. See [ 5 , Definition 2.1] for the precise definition of finite-dimensional and non-positively curved complex. In this paper, we generalize results of [ 6 ] on establishing decentness of actions of groups on restricted products (see Definition 2.1 below). The main result of Lonjou–Przytycki–Urech ( [ 6 ] ) that we aim to generalize is [ 6 , Theorem 1.10] (see Section 2.1 for the definition of G^{\oplus} and \oplus_{p\in P}(X_{p},x_{p}) below). Theorem 1.3 . ( [ 6 , Theorem 1.10] ) Let G_{0} be a group acting decently on a set X_{0} , with basepoint x_{0} . Let P be the projective line \mathbb{P}^{1} over an algebraically closed field k , and let H=Aut(P)=PGL_{2}(k) . Then G^{\oplus} acts decently on \oplus_{p\in P}(X_{p},x_{p}) , with X_{p}=X_{0} and x_{p}=x_{0} for all p\in P . Note that by [ 6 , Lemma 4.2] , item 1 in Definition 1.2 for G^{\oplus}\curvearrowright\oplus_{p\in P}(X_{p},x_{p}) follows from item 1 for G_{0}\curvearrowright X_{0} . Therefore, it suffices to prove item 2 for G^{\oplus}\curvearrowright\oplus_{p\in P}(X_{p},x_{p}) , i.e. that each finitely generated subgroup \Gamma<G^{\oplus} acting purely elliptically on \oplus_{p\in P}(X_{p},x_{p}) acts elliptically. Also, note that while stated for algebraically closed fields k , Theorem 1.3 holds for arbitrary fields. Indeed, if K is an arbitrary field and k is an algebraic closure of K , then denoting P=\mathbb{P}^{1}(K) , P^{\prime}=\mathbb{P}^{1}(k) , G^{\oplus}=\prod_{P}^{r}G_{0}\rtimes PGL_{2}(K) , G^{\prime\oplus}=\prod_{P^{\prime}}^{r}G_{0}\rtimes PGL_{2}(k) , X=\oplus_{p\in P}(X_{p},x_{p}) and X^{\prime}=\oplus_{p\in P^{\prime}}(X_{p},x_{p}) , we can identify P<P^{\prime} and we have natural embeddings: \phi:X\hookrightarrow X^{\prime} and \psi:G^{\oplus}\hookrightarrow G^{\prime\oplus} defined by \phi(x)=z where z_{p}=x_{p} for each p\in P and z_{q}=x_{0} for each q\in P^{\prime}\setminus P , and \psi((g_{p})_{p\in P},h)=((g_{q}^{\prime})_{q\in P^{\prime}},h) where g^{\prime}_{p}=g_{p} for each p\in P and g^{\prime}_{q}=1 for each q\in P^{\prime}\setminus P , with \phi being \psi -equivariant. Thus, if \Gamma<G^{\oplus} is finitely generated and acts purely elliptically, then the same is true for \psi(\Gamma) , and hence by Theorem 1.3 , we have that \psi(\Gamma) fixes a point y\in X^{\prime} . But since G<PGL_{2}(K) , we can choose y\in\phi(X) . Indeed, given a fixed point y^{\prime} of \psi(\Gamma) in X , we define y_{p}=y^{\prime}_{p} for each p\in P and y_{p}=x_{0} for p\in P^{\prime}\setminus P . Then y\in\phi(X) and y is still a fixed point of \psi(\Gamma) . Indeed, given \gamma\in\Gamma , write \psi(\gamma)=((g_{p}^{\prime})_{p\in P^{\prime}},h) where g_{p}^{\prime}=1 for each p\in P^{\prime}\setminus P . Then, for p\in P^{\prime}\setminus P , since G preserves P^{\prime}\setminus P we have (\psi(\gamma)y)_{p}=y_{h^{-1}(p)}=x_{0}=y_{p} and for each p\in P , since y^{\prime} is a fixed point of \psi(\Gamma) , we have have (\psi(\gamma)y)_{p}=g_{p}^{\prime}y_{h^{-1}(p)}=g_{p}^{\prime}y^{\prime}_{h^{-1}(p)}=y_{p}^{\prime}=y_{p} Hence, by \psi -equivariance of \phi , we have that \Gamma fixes a point of X . We generalize Theorem 1.3 to the following, which is the main result of this paper: Theorem 1.4 . Let G_{0} be a group acting decently on a set X_{0} , with basepoint x_{0} . Let P be the projective plane \mathbb{P}^{2} over a field k , and let H=Aut(P)=PGL_{3}(k) . Then G^{\oplus} acts decently on \oplus_{p\in P}(X_{p},x_{p}) , with X_{p}=X_{0} and x_{p}=x_{0} for all p\in P . For the same reason as noted for Theorem 1.3 , item 1 in Definition 1.2 for G^{\oplus}\curvearrowright\oplus_{p\in P}(X_{p},x_{p}) follows automatically from item 1 for G_{0}\curvearrowright X_{0} , and it suffices to prove Theorem 1.4 for algebraically closed fields, hence we will assume that k is algebraically closed in the proof of Theorem 1.4 . As an application of Theorem 1.3 , Lonjou–Przytycki–Urech are able to deduce local to global results on subgroups of \mathrm{C}_{2}(k) , most notably [ 6 , Theorem 1.1] , stating that every finitely generated subgroup of \mathrm{C}_{2}(k) all of whose elements are algebraic is bounded (see [ 6 ] for the definitions of “algebraic” elements and “bounded” subgroups of \mathrm{C}_{2}(k) ). This is achieved by studying the action of \mathrm{C}_{2}(k) on a restricted product of simplicial trees called the “Jonquières complex”, and showing that this action is decent. It is then shown that algebraic elements of \mathrm{C}_{2}(k) are precisely the elliptic elements with respect to this action, and that the bounded subgroups are precisely the elliptic subgroups with respect to this action. An important ingredient in the proof of Theorem

Read the complete text