Weak action representability of 2 2 -nilpotent groups
Alessandro Dioguardi Burgio, Manuel Mancini, Tim Van der Linden · 2026
Read Weak action representability of 2 2 -nilpotent groups by Alessandro Dioguardi Burgio, Manuel Mancini, Tim Van der Linden (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-22578.txt.
Introduction
Dioguardi Burgio and two colleagues study action representability for 2-nilpotent groups. Derived actions are described through central automorphisms of an object, and which maps into that group define an action. The category is not action representable, and weak representation hinges on amalgamation. Weak representability is proved via a strong amalgam of suitable abelian subgroups of that group. An explicit weak representing object is maps from the abelianization to the center. The category is also not locally algebraically cartesian closed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alessandro Dioguardi Burgio, Manuel Mancini, Tim Van der Linden |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45154 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.22578
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Weak action representability of 2 2 -nilpotent groups Alessandro Dioguardi Burgio, Manuel Mancini, Tim Van der Linden Abstract . In this article, we investigate the representability of actions of the category 𝖭𝗂𝗅 2 ( 𝖦𝗋𝗉 ) \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) of 2 2 -nilpotent groups. We first provide an algebraic characterisation of derived actions in 𝖭𝗂𝗅 2 ( 𝖦𝗋𝗉 ) \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) by determining a universal strict general actor of an object X X , which turns out to be the group Aut c ( X ) \Aut_{c}(X) of central automorphisms of X X . We also characterise the morphisms B → Aut c ( X ) B\to\Aut_{c}(X) that define an action of B B on X X in 𝖭𝗂𝗅 2 ( 𝖦𝗋𝗉 ) \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) . We then show that 𝖭𝗂𝗅 2 ( 𝖦𝗋𝗉 ) \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) is not action representable, and that the existence of a weak representation is related to the amalgamation property. Using the construction of an amalgam of a suitable family of abelian subgroups of Aut c ( X ) \Aut_{c}(X) , we prove that the category 𝖭𝗂𝗅 2 ( 𝖦𝗋𝗉 ) \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) is weakly action representable, and that a weak representing object can be chosen to be an abelian group. Finally, we show that 𝖭𝗂𝗅 2 ( 𝖦𝗋𝗉 ) \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) is not locally algebraically cartesian closed. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 08A35; 08C05; 16W22; 17A36; 18E13; 20F18; 20F28 Introduction Internal actions were defined in [ 2 ] by F. Borceux, G. Janelidze and G. M. Kelly in order to extend the correspondence between actions and split extensions from the category of groups to arbitrary semi-abelian categories [ 23 ] . In some of those categories, internal actions are exceptionally well behaved, in the sense that the actions on each object X are representable . More explicitly, this means that there exists an object [X] such that the functor \Act(-,X)\cong\SplExt(-,X), sending an object B to the set of actions of B on X (equivalently, to the set of isomorphism classes of split extensions of B by X ), is naturally isomorphic to the functor \Hom(-,[X]) . The notion of action representability in a semi-abelian category was further investigated in [ 3 ] , where it is shown there that the category of commutative associative algebras over a field is not action representable. Subsequently, it was proved in [ 15 ] that, over an infinite field of characteristic different from 2 , the only action representable varieties of non-associative algebras are the category \mathsf{Lie} of Lie algebras and the category \mathsf{AbAlg} of abelian algebras. The strength of this notion naturally motivated the introduction of weaker related concepts. In [ 6 ] , D. Bourn and G. Janelidze introduced the notion of an action accessible category so as to encompass relevant examples that do not fit into the frame of action representable categories, such as rings, associative algebras, and Leibniz algebras [ 24 ] . It was later proved by A. Montoli in [ 26 ] that every Orzech category of interest [ 28 ] is action accessible. Moreover, in [ 8 ] , the authors showed that every Orzech category of interest admits a weaker form of representing object, called the universal strict general actor (USGA). More recently, G. Janelidze introduced in [ 21 ] the notion of a weakly action representable category. Rather than requiring that, for every object X of a semi-abelian category \mathscr{C} , there exist an object [X] and a natural isomorphism \Act(-,X)\cong\Hom_{\mathscr{C}}(-,[X]), one only asks for the existence of an object T=T(X) of \mathscr{C} together with a natural monomorphism of functors \Act(-,X)\rightarrowtail\Hom_{\mathscr{C}}(-,T). Such an object T is called a weak representing object of X . Examples of weakly action representable categories include the category of associative algebras [ 21 ] and the category of Leibniz algebras [ 10 ] . The notion of weak action representability was further investigated in [ 7 ] in the setting of operadic varieties of non-associative algebras over a field. In that work, the authors exhibited new examples of weakly action representable categories, including the variety of commutative associative algebras and the varieties of 2 -nilpotent (commutative and anti-commutative) algebras. Another important observation made by G. Janelidze in [ 21 ] is that every weakly action representable category is action accessible. The converse, however, does not hold. Indeed, J. R. A. Gray observed in [ 20 , Proposition 2.2] that weak action representability is closely related to the existence of a so-called amalgam [ 22 ] , a notion that had already appeared in [ 3 ] in connection with action representability, and he proved that the varieties of n -solvable groups are not weakly action representable, for any n\geq 3 . This result was later extended in [ 12 ] to the varieties of 2 -solvable groups and of k -nilpotent groups, for any k\geq 3 . There, the authors also proved that the varieties of n -solvable Lie algebras ( n\geq 2 ) and k -nilpotent Lie algebras ( k\geq 3 ) fail to be weakly action representable. These are the first examples of action accessible varieties of non-associative algebras which are not weakly action representable. The main goal of this article is to investigate the representability of actions in the category \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) of 2 -nilpotent groups. After recalling the necessary background in Section 1 , we give an algebraic characterisation of (external) actions in \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) . More precisely, we characterise the actions of a 2 -nilpotent group B on another 2 -nilpotent group X such that the corresponding semidirect product B\ltimes X is still 2 -nilpotent. As a consequence, we obtain an explicit description of the universal strict general actor of X , which turns out to be the group \Aut_{c}(X) of central automorphisms of X . We also provide a complete characterisation of the acting morphism , that is, of those group homomorphisms B\to\Aut_{c}(X) that define an action of B on X in the category \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) . In Section 3 , we investigate weak action representability in the category \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) . We first prove in Proposition 3.1 that \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) is not action representable. Then, similarly to what was done in [ 7 ] for the variety of commutative associative algebras, we show that, for a 2 -nilpotent group X , the existence of a weak representation for the actions on X is closely related to the so-called amalgamation property (AP) [ 22 ] . Finally, by constructing the amalgam of a suitable family of abelian subgroups of \Aut_{c}(X) , we prove that \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) is weakly action representable, and that as a weak representing object of X we may choose an abelian group. This result is analogous to the case of 2 -nilpotent Lie algebras. Indeed, it was shown in [ 7 , Theorem 2.21] that the variety of 2 -nilpotent Lie algebras over a field \mathbb{F} with \bchar(\mathbb{F})\neq 2 is weakly action representable, with a weak representing object of an object X being an abelian algebra. Finally, in Section 4 we study local algebraic cartesian closedness (LACC) for the category \mathsf{Nil}_{2}(\mathsf{Grp}) , a notion introduced by J. R. A. Gray in his Ph.D. thesis [ 18 ] in connection with