Moisture Budgets and Circulation Analogs: Diagnosing Dynamic and Thermodynamic Precipitation Change

2026

Read Moisture Budgets and Circulation Analogs: Diagnosing Dynamic and Thermodynamic Precipitation Change (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-22556.txt.

Introduction

Doane-Solomon, Simpson, and Woollings compare two ways to split Central Chile precipitation trends into dynamic and thermodynamic parts. Dynamic change comes from shifting circulation, thermodynamic change from changing moisture, and separating them aids regional understanding and projection. One method uses moisture budget analysis, the other builds constructed circulation analogs, run on CESM2 Large Ensemble fields and two reanalyses. Dynamic trends often differ sharply for single members, though means agree in sign but not size, and analogs applied to budget terms refine historical and future estimates.

Catalog record

YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58992
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.22556

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Moisture Budgets and Circulation Analogs: Diagnosing Dynamic and Thermodynamic Precipitation Change Abstract Precipitation trends can arise from both dynamic factors (changes in atmospheric circulation) and thermodynamic factors (changes in atmospheric moisture content). Disentangling these contributions can aid in understanding regional climate change and improving projections. We compare two approaches which separate dynamic and thermodynamic contributions to precipitation trends over Central Chile: a moisture budget analysis and constructed circulation analogs. Both methods are applied to fields from the CESM2 Large Ensemble as well as two reanalyses. We analyze the methodological differences that lead to distinct results in each approach and evaluate their respective capabilities in capturing dynamic, thermodynamic and coupled trends. We find that the estimated dynamic trends from both methods often differ substantially for individual ensemble members, although the ensemble mean generally agrees in sign but not in magnitude. Finally, we apply circulation analogs to moisture budget terms to refine estimates of historical and future precipitation change in Central Chile. This combined framework reduces dynamic contamination of thermodynamic trends and yields projections of thermodynamic precipitation change that are weaker than that suggested by either method alone. † † authors: Robert Doane-Solomon \aff a Isla R. Simpson \aff b Tim Woollings \aff a \statement In order to better understand changes in regional precipitation, we need to understand which physical mechanisms are behind the change in precipitation. There are two main mechanisms: precipitation can change simply because the atmosphere is getting warmer, or because the atmospheric circulation is changing as well. Previous studies have used multiple different methods to understand which physical processes are dominant in different regions, but no method is perfect. In this paper we compare and combine two methods in a case study region of Central Chile, to better understand the methods themselves and help refine our understanding of why rainfall is declining in this region. 1 Introduction Precipitation changes are projected to occur worldwide as a response to global warming ( 12 ; 16 ; 31 ) . In some locations, such as Mediterranean-type climate regions, precipitation declines have already occurred and are projected to continue through the 21st century ( 26 ; 33 ; 34 ; 11 ) . Located at the subtropical western edge of continents, these regions are underneath semi-permanent subtropical highs in the summer linked to the descending branch of the Hadley cell. In winter, the Hadley cell retreats towards the opposing hemisphere, allowing the extratropical storm track to deliver rainfall to these regions. The majority of their precipitation occurs in wintertime from these systems ( 33 ; 11 ) , making them especially susceptible to hydroclimate change because most of their annual rainfall is concentrated in a single season. There are two primary mechanisms which can cause precipitation change: dynamic and thermodynamic. Dynamic precipitation changes are caused by changes in circulation. Examples of this could be the strengthening Southern Hemisphere storm track 24 ; 6 ; 20 , or the poleward movement of the Hadley cell edge leading to an expansion of the subtropical dry zones ( 22 ; 14 ; 7 ) . Thermodynamic changes occur because warming increases the saturation vapour pressure, enabling the atmosphere to hold more water vapour, thereby altering moisture gradients and relative humidity even in the absence of circulation changes. This dependence is described by the Clausius Clapeyron equation, which gives the temperature sensitivity of the saturation vapour pressure e_{s} of one mole of water: \frac{de_{s}}{dT}=\frac{L}{T\Delta V}, (1) where L is the latent heat of vaporisation and \Delta V=V_{vapor}-V_{liquid} is the molar volume change between vapour and liquid. On this basis, 16 argued that relative changes in precipitation minus evaporation, \frac{\delta(P-E)}{P-E} , should scale with temperature at roughly 7% per Kelvin. In practice, the response deviates from this simple scaling due to the effect of warming on relative humidity and temperature gradients, among other factors ( 5 ; 35 ; 4 ) . One can use a continuity equation for conservation of moisture to separate precipitation changes into dynamic and thermodynamic processes. The specific humidity q within an atmospheric column, \int_{p=0}^{p=p_{s}}q\,dp , can change due to advection and convergence by the horizontal velocity u , as well as precipitation P and evaporation E . Precipitation acts as sink for water vapor, and evaporation acts as a source. To ensure that P and E are in units of meters per second (or mm/day), we introduce the constants g , the gravitational field strength, and \rho_{w} , the density of water ( 29 ) . This leads to the following continuity equation: \frac{1}{g\rho_{w}}\left[\frac{d}{dt}\int_{0}^{p_{s}}q\,dp+\nabla\cdot\left(\int_{0}^{p_{s}}q\mathbf{u}\,\,dp\right)\right]=E-P. (2) When considering timescales such as climatological monthly means, the time derivative term is negligible, so we can simplify Eq. 2 to: P-E=-\frac{1}{g\rho_{w}}\nabla\cdot\left(\int_{0}^{p_{s}}q\mathbf{u}\,\,dp\right)=\text{VIMC}, (3) where VIMC is a shorthand for the vertically integrated moisture flux convergence. VIMC can then be decomposed into contributions from changes in q (thermodynamic) and \mathbf{u} (dynamic), although this separation is not exact because variations in q may arise from both thermodynamic and dynamic processes. Nevertheless, moisture budget techniques based on this continuity equation have been widely used to understand the physical processes driving precipitation change ( 31 ; 30 ; 32 ; 33 ; 29 ; 39 ; 35 ; 4 ) . An alternative framework for separating dynamic and thermodynamic influences is dynamical adjustment. Rather than decomposing the moisture continuity equation, these methods quantify the extent to which variability and trends in a target field, such as precipitation or VIMC, can be attributed to large-scale atmospheric circulation ( 37 ; 10 ; 21 ) . The underlying assumption is that the variability of the target field is strongly constrained by these circulation patterns. There may be other contributions to its variability, such as localized convection, soil moisture feedbacks, or changes in atmospheric humidity. By construction, these methods partition the target variable anomaly into a circulation-driven (dynamic) component and a residual component that captures all other processes, including thermodynamic changes. A range of dynamical adjustment techniques have been developed ( 36 ; 25 ) , including analog-based approaches such as constructed circulation analogs (CCAs). These have been used to dissect European and Mediterranean-type climate precipitation trends ( 9 ; 11 ) as well as wider Northern Hemisphere precipitation changes ( 15 ) . Despite the multiple studies using moisture budget diagnostics and dynamical adjustment techniques, a direct comparison of these two approaches applied consistently to the same region and variable has not yet been performed. Both methods provide useful but inherently imperfect decompositions of hydroclimate change, as each contains assumptions that limit a clean separation of dynamic and thermodynamic contributions. Here, we apply the constructed circulation analog dynamical adjustment technique and a Reynolds decomposition moisture budget analysis to VIMC in the Mediterranean-type climate region of Central Chile. This region is selected as a case study due to its clear declining precipitation trends in both observation-based and model datasets ( 2 ; 1 ; 13 ; 11 ) . By comparing these methods, we assess how each partitions precipitation changes into dynamic and thermodynamic components, and evaluate whether they produce consistent physical interpretations of hydroclimate trends. 2 Methods 2.1 Data Sources We use precipitation ( P ), evaporation ( E ), specific humidity ( q ), zonal ( u ) and meridional

Read the complete text