Causal Identification under Interference: The Role of Treatment Assignment Independence.

Julius Owusu, Monika Avila Márquez · 2026

Read Causal Identification under Interference: The Role of Treatment Assignment Independence. by Julius Owusu, Monika Avila Márquez (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-22532.txt.

Introduction

Owusu and Avila Márquez study what standard rules recover when treatment effects spill over between people. Applied teams often use rules with solo response, even when interference is plausible but unseen. For selection, instruments, regression discontinuity, and difference-in-differences, each formula equals an average direct effect plus a bias. Each bias term times an interference part by a gap in others' assignment laws across groups. The bias is zero under generalized assignment independence, untestable from one seen assignment, so the paper builds a sensitivity response.

Catalog record

CREATORJulius Owusu, Monika Avila Márquez
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE161787
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.22532

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Causal Identification under Interference: The Role of Treatment Assignment Independence. Julius Owusu, Monika Avila Márquez Abstract Empirical researchers routinely invoke the no-interference or individualistic treatment response (ITR) assumption to identify causal effects in observational studies, despite concerns that interference across units may arise in many economic settings. This paper studies the causal content of standard ITR-based identification formulas when arbitrary interference is present. We show that, under restrictions on dependence between treatment assignments across units, conventional ITR-based identification formulas—including those underlying selection-on-observables, instrumental variables, regression discontinuity designs, and difference-in-differences—identify well-defined causal objects: types of average direct effects (ADEs). These results do not require knowledge of the interference structure or specification of exposure mappings. We also propose a sensitivity analysis framework that quantifies the robustness of statistical inference to violations of treatment-assignment independence under arbitrary interference. Keywords: Average direct effect, individualistic treatment response, Interference. JEL Classification: C21, C26, C31, C36. 1 Introduction A large share of empirical work in economics relies on identification strategies—such as selection-on-observables (conditional independence), instrumental variables, difference-in-differences, regression discontinuity, and related designs—that are typically justified under the no-interference or individualistic treatment response (ITR) assumption. Under ITR, each unit’s potential outcomes depend only on its own treatment status, so that standard identification formulas admit clear causal interpretations, most commonly the average treatment effect (ATE) or the average treatment effect on the treated (ATT). In many empirical environments, however, units interact, general equilibrium effects exist, and policies generate spillovers. In such settings, outcomes may depend on the treatment assignments of other units, violating ITR in ways that are often unobserved by the researcher. What, then, do standard identification formulas recover when the ITR assumption fails? A prominent response in the literature reformulates the identification problem by modeling interference through exposure mappings, neighborhood restrictions, or cluster-level structures in order to define and identify mean direct and indirect (spillover) effects. This approach yields well-defined causal estimands under assumptions about the form of interference and the joint distribution of potential outcomes and treatment, and it often requires detailed information about the underlying interaction structure. Early contributions focused primarily on experimental settings (see, for example, 23 ; 28 ; 41 ; 35 ; 5 ). More recent work extends this framework to a wide range of quasi-experimental and observational designs, including difference-in-differences ( 14 ; 8 ; 46 ) , synthetic control ( 9 ) , instrumental variables ( 40 ; 43 ) , regression discontinuity designs ( 4 ; 6 ; 42 ) , and selection-on-observables approaches ( 20 ) . By contrast, much applied work continues to employ standard estimators developed under the ITR framework while remaining agnostic about the presence or form of interference, even in settings where spillovers are plausible, largely due to limited information about the underlying interference structure. 1 1 1 Table S1 in Section C of the Supplementary Material provides an illustrative, though non-exhaustive list of applied econometric studies that follow this practice. Despite its prevalence, there is little systematic and comprehensive analysis of the causal content of ITR-based identification formulas when interference is present but unmodelled. This paper fills that gap by characterizing what conventional ITR-based identification formulas recover when outcomes may exhibit arbitrary interference. Our theoretical results yield three main conclusions. First, allowing outcomes to depend on the treatment of other units requires extending the identifying assumptions underlying standard designs, such as unconfoundedness, instrument exogeneity, or parallel trends, beyond their ITR formulations, in line with the interference literature discussed above. Second, these extensions alone are not sufficient to ensure causal interpretability. Even when interference in potential outcomes is explicitly modeled, identification formulas derived under the ITR framework retain a causal interpretation only under additional restrictions that limit dependence in treatment assignment across units in the population. In the absence of such restrictions, standard ITR-based identification formulas generally combine meaningful causal effects with bias arising from systematic differences in how others’ treatment assignments affect a unit’s own treatment values, and vice versa. Third, the restrictions limiting cross-unit dependence in treatment assignment are not testable from the observed data. To address this concern, we develop a novel sensitivity analysis procedure within the selection-on-observables framework. The procedure evaluates the robustness of statistical inference—in terms of the decision from a randomization test—to violations of independent treatment assignment conditional on covariates by allowing for departures from treatment independence across units. In particular, when interference is considered plausible, but information about its underlying structure is unavailable, the procedure quantifies the degree of dependence in treatment assignment required to overturn a rejection of a proposed sharp null. In this way, it provides a measure of how sensitive an empirical conclusion is to assignment dependence, in the spirit of the sensitivity analysis framework of 37 . To facilitate implementation, we also provide an easy-to-use R package, caisensitivity , which implements the proposed sensitivity analysis. 2 2 2 The R package is available upon request. To formalize ideas, we adopt a finite-population potential-outcomes framework in which each unit’s outcome may depend arbitrarily on the full vector of treatment assignments. We study the identification formulas underlying common non-experimental designs that, under ITR, recover the ATE or ATT. We show that, under appropriate assumptions, including extensions of ITR-based restrictions on the joint distribution of treatments and potential outcomes and, importantly, restrictions on the dependence structure of treatment assignments, these formulas identify well-defined causal parameters. Thus, when interference is present, the causal object targeted by ITR-based identification formulas is not lost but instead transformed into a well-defined estimand that remains meaningful under appropriate conditions. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 introduces the finite-population framework with arbitrary interference and elaborates on the motivation of the paper. Section 3 examines the interpretability of ITR-based identification formulas in standard non-experimental designs—i.e., selection-on-observable, instrumental variables, difference-in-differences, and regression discontinuity designs. Section 4 introduces a sensitivity analysis model that quantifies the extent to which statistical inference relies on the restriction imposed on the treatment assignment mechanism, namely, the limitation on dependence across units’ treatment assignments, required for the interpretability of ITR-based identification formulas under interference. We complement the theoretical analysis by assessing the finite-sample performance of the proposed sensitivity procedure in a simulation study and an empirical application. Section 5 discusses a Monte Carlo study designed to investigate the bias of ITR-based identification formulas when interference is present. The results corroborate our theoretical findings. We conclude in Section 6 . All Proofs are collected in Section A of the Supplementary Material. 2 Framework and Motivation 2.1 Setup We consider a finite population of N units indexed by i\in[N]:=\{1,\dots,N\} . Let D_{i}\in\{0,1\} denote treatment assignment of unit i , and \mathbf{D}=(D_{1},\dots,D_{N})\in\{0,1\}^{N} denote the vector of treatment assignments of the population. For each unit i , potential outcomes are indexed by the full treatment assignment vector, allowing for arbitrary interference across units. Potential outcomes are modeled as stochastic, with unit-level randomness captured by a latent random variable \epsilon_{i} that is common across treatment states. Thus, for any realization of \mathbf{D} , denoted as \mathbf{d}=(d_{1},\ldots,d_{N})\in\{0,1\}^{N} , the potential outcome is of the general form: Y_{i}(\mathbf{d})=f(\mathbf{d},\epsilon_{i}),\,\,\,\text{with the same latent random variable }\epsilon_{i}\,\,\text{for all }\mathbf{d}\in\{0,1\}^{N}, where f(\cdot) is some known function. Related formulations appear in 34 and 46 . Under no

Read the complete text