A ∞ A_{\infty} -invariance of oscillatory norms, and Schatten characterisations of commutators

Tuomas Hytönen · 2026

Read A ∞ A_{\infty} -invariance of oscillatory norms, and Schatten characterisations of commutators by Tuomas Hytönen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-22474.txt.

Introduction

Hytönen extends a framework for Schatten commutators of multipliers and singular integral maps, covering many earlier results. He adds two A-infinity-equivalent measures mu and nu. Commutators act on L2(mu), but norms are taken with respect to nu. That allows Ahlfors regularity and Poincaré inequality on mu to be eased, if an A-infinity-equivalent nu meets them. In the Bessel example, mu fails Ahlfors regularity but nu is Lebesgue measure. The critical-index Bessel-Riesz commutator results are recovered by real analysis, instead of other tools.

Catalog record

CREATORTuomas Hytönen
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39232
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.22474

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A ∞ A_{\infty} -invariance of oscillatory norms, and Schatten characterisations of commutators Thanks: The author was supported by the Research Council of Finland, projects 364208 and 371637. Tuomas Hytönen Abstract . Schatten class properties of commutators [ b , T ] [b,T] of pointwise multipliers b b and singular integral operators T T have been characterised in a variety of settings. An abstract framework, covering many of these results as special cases, was proposed by the author [arXiv:2411.02613]. However, recent results about commutators of the concrete Bessel–Riesz transforms by Fan–Li–Sukochev–Zanin [arXiv:2411.14928] are beyond this abstract setting. In this work, we present an extension of the framework of [arXiv:2411.02613], introducing two measures μ \mu and ν \nu that are A ∞ A_{\infty} -equivalent to each other. The commutators act on a given space L 2 ​ ( μ ) L^{2}(\mu) , but the characterising function space norms of the multiplier b b are taken with respect to another measure ν \nu . In this way, assumptions like Ahlfors regularity and Poincaré inequality on the original measure μ \mu may be relaxed, as long as there is an A ∞ A_{\infty} -equivalent measure ν \nu that satisfies these assumptions. In the Bessel example, the original μ \mu fails to be Ahlfors regular, but ν \nu is simply the Lebesgue measure. Within this framework, the Schatten norm characterisations of commutators of the Bessel–Riesz transforms at the critical-index by Fan–Li–Sukochev–Zanin [op cit.] are recovered by a completely different argument, replacing non-commutative techniques by real-variable harmonic analysis and hardly using any specifics of the Bessel setting. As a by-product, we also obtain a simpler characterisation in the non-critical case, replacing an ad hoc Besov space of Fan–Lacey–Li–Xiong [J. Funct. Anal. 2026] by a classical Besov space. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 42B20, 42B35, 46E36, 47B10, 47B47 1. Introduction Different mapping properties of commutators [b,T]:f\mapsto bT(f)-T(bf) of pointwise multipliers b and singular integrals T play a role in various areas of mathematics, like factorisation of function spaces [ 2 ] and compensated compactness in nonlinear PDE [ 1 ] . Specifically, questions of quantitative compactness of [b,T] , measured in terms of Schatten–Lorentz S^{p,q} norms (Definition 2.1 ), arise in connection with the quantised calculus of Connes [ 4 , Chapter 4] and are particularly relevant for the critical parameters (p,q)=(d,\infty) , where d is an underlying dimension [ 5 , 11 , 12 , 25 ] . Over the past few years, classical characterisations [ 18 , 27 ] of commutator Schatten properties have been extended to various new settings like weighted Euclidean spaces [ 13 ] , Heisenberg groups [ 7 , 9 ] , more general Carnot groups [ 24 ] , and the so-called Bessel setting [ 8 ] . Besides its intrinsic interest, the last-mentioned case serves as a useful model for a general theory, featuring a concrete example of a doubling metric measure space with different upper and lower dimensions, thus failing to be Ahlfors regular (see Definitions 2.2 and 2.4 ). A unified framework covering many of these previous results as special cases was provided in [ 15 ] ; however, within three weeks (in terms of the original arXiv dates in November 2024), it was challenged by [ 10 ] with a characterisation for the concrete Bessel–Riesz transforms in the important critical-index case, which was not covered by the abstract assumptions of [ 15 ] . The goal of this paper is to place these bounds of [ 10 ] into a further general framework, a natural extension of [ 15 ] . This leads to a new proof of these bounds, quite transparent in our opinion, and offers a new explanation of the underlying phenomenon in a broader context. At the same time, the scope of the bounds of [ 10 ] is significantly expanded from the concrete Bessel setting to a wide class of operators and spaces. We should note that, besides the uniform bounds of [ 10 , Theorem 1.2] , the same paper also proves related spectral asymptotics in [ 10 , Theorem 1.3] , and these latter remain beyond the scope of our approach. However, to obtain these asymptotics for all relevant functions rather than just test functions, the uniform bounds of [ 10 , Theorem 1.2] are used in the proof of the asymptotics in [ 10 , Theorem 1.3] . Our present results, extending [ 10 , Theorem 1.2] , not only offer an alternative (simpler, in our opinion) approach to this major component of the proof of [ 10 , Theorem 1.3] , but they should similarly serve as a step towards the proof of spectral asymptotics in new situations. In prospective new cases where spectral asymptotics for commutators are hoped for, the specifics of the situation may still be needed for the eventual asymptotic considerations, while the uniform non-asymptotic bounds will be available from the general theory presented here. To discuss our contributions in more detail, we recall that the following norm equivalence (first due to [ 27 ] in the Euclidean context, and recently extended in [ 15 ] ) holds in great generality: \|[b,T]\|_{S^{p,q}(L^{2}(\mu))}\sim\|b\|_{\operatorname{Osc}^{p,q}(\mu)}, (1.1) where S^{p,q}(L^{2}(\mu)) is the usual Schatten–Lorentz space of operators on L^{2}(\mu) (Definition 2.1 ) and \operatorname{Osc}^{p,q}(\mu) is an oscillatory norm space recalled in Definition 3.2 . Here and throughout the paper, we use the following convention. Whenever X is a (quasi-)normed space, we write \|f\|_{X}:=\infty for f\notin X . Using this convention, we see that the concise equivalence “ \|f\|_{X}\sim\|g\|_{Y} ” as in ( 1.1 ) encodes the longer statement “ f\in X if and only if g\in Y , and in this case \|f\|_{X}\sim\|g\|_{Y} ”. While the equivalence ( 1.1 ) is very general, the identification of the abstract oscillation norm on the right with more familiar, and maybe more useful, function space norms is only available under more restrictive assumptions on the underlying space and the measure \mu . Notably, in the important critical-index case of the parameters (p,q) , an identification of the oscillation norm with a suitable Sobolev-type norm (see Definition 2.6 ), \|b\|_{\operatorname{Osc}^{d,\infty}(\mu)}\sim\|b\|_{\dot{M}^{1,d}(\mu)}, was established in [ 15 , 17 ] for Ahlfors d -regular measures \mu (Definition 2.4 ). This Ahlfors regularity fails for the Bessel measure \,\mathrm{d}m_{\lambda}=x_{n+1}^{2\lambda}\,\mathrm{d}x on \mathbb{R}^{n+1}_{+}:=\mathbb{R}^{n}\times(0,\infty) , yet [ 10 ] were still able to prove (for the Bessel–Riesz transforms R_{\lambda,j} in place of T ) that \|[b,T]\|_{S^{d,\infty}(L^{2}(\mathbb{R}_{+}^{n+1},m_{\lambda}))}\sim\|b\|_{\dot{W}^{1,d}(\mathbb{R}_{+}^{n+1})},\qquad d=n+1. Here, the Sobolev space \dot{W}^{1,d}(\mathbb{R}_{+}^{n+1}) on the right is the classical one with respect to the unweighted Lebesgue measure, not with respect to the Bessel measure m_{\lambda} appearing on the left. The Lebesgue measure on the half-space \mathbb{R}_{+}^{n+1} is evidently Ahlfors regular; hence, there is still some hidden Ahlfors-regularity in the setting of [ 10 ] , even if not in a form that would allow a direct application of [ 15 , 17 ] . In this paper, we provide an additional ingredient that is needed to bring the Schatten bounds of [ 10 ] under the scope of [ 15 , 17 ] by means of the following invariance of the oscillation norms under A_{\infty} changes of the measure: 1.2 Proposition . Let \mu,\nu be two doubling measures on a metric space

Read the complete text