RAG-Reflect: Agentic Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Reflections for Comment-Driven Code Maintenance on Stack Overflow Journal: TOSEM Volume: 0 0 0 10 Journal: TOSEM CCS: Software engineering Empirical studies CCS: Stack Overflow Q&A platforms CCS: Large Language Models community moderation

Mehedi Hasan Shanto, Muhammad Asaduzzaman, Alioune Ngom · 2026

Read RAG-Reflect: Agentic Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Reflections for Comment-Driven Code Maintenance on Stack Overflow Journal: TOSEM Volume: 0 0 0 10 Journal: TOSEM CCS: Software engineering Empirical studies CCS: Stack Overflow Q&A platforms CCS: Large Language Models community moderation by Mehedi Hasan Shanto, Muhammad Asaduzzaman, Alioune Ngom (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-22217.txt.

Introduction

Shanto, Asaduzzaman, and Ngom present RAG-Reflect for comment-edit prediction on Stack Overflow, reaching fine-tuned performance without task-specific training. It combines language models with retrieval reasoning and self-reflection. It runs a three-stage workflow on pattern analysis. An Interpretation module derives rules from the knowledge base. At inference, the system retrieves examples, reasons about causality, and reflects using pre-established rules. On SOUP, RAG-Reflect scores Precision about 1, Recall about 1, and F1 0.78, beating baselines and nearly matching fine-tuned models.

Catalog record

CREATORMehedi Hasan Shanto, Muhammad Asaduzzaman, Alioune Ngom
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78592
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.22217

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

RAG-Reflect: Agentic Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Reflections for Comment-Driven Code Maintenance on Stack Overflow Journal: TOSEM Volume: 0 0 0 10 Journal: TOSEM CCS: Software engineering Empirical studies CCS: Stack Overflow Q&A platforms CCS: Large Language Models community moderation Mehedi Hasan Shanto, Muhammad Asaduzzaman, Alioune Ngom Abstract . User comments on online programming platforms such as Stack Overflow play a vital role in maintaining the correctness and relevance of shared code examples. However, the majority of comments express gratitude or clarification, while only a small fraction highlight actionable issues that drive meaningful edits. Automatically identifying which comments genuinely motivate code changes is critical for sustaining knowledge quality, automating post updates, and mitigating information decay in developer forums. This paper demonstrates how agentic AI principles can revolutionize software maintenance tasks by presenting RAG-Reflect , a modular framework that achieves fine-tuned-level performance for valid comment-edit prediction without task-specific training. Valid Comment–Edit Prediction (VCP) task—determining whether a user comment directly triggered a subsequent code edit. The framework integrates large language models (LLMs) with retrieval-augmented reasoning and self-reflection mechanisms. RAG-Reflect operates through a three-stage runtime workflow built on a one-time pattern analysis phase. During initialization, an Interpretation module analyzes the knowledge base to generate validation rules. At inference time, the system (1) retrieves contextual examples, (2) reasons about comment-edit causality, and (3) reflects on decisions using the pre-established rules. We evaluate RAG-Reflect on the publicly available SOUP benchmark, achieving Precision = 0.81 , Recall = 0.74 , and F1 = 0.78 —outperforming traditional baselines (e.g., Logistic Regression, XGBoost, different prompting techniques) and closely approaching the performance of fine-tuned models ( F1 = 0.773 ) without retraining. Our ablation and stage-level analyses show that both retrieval and reflection modules substantially enhance performance. By decomposing perception, memory, reasoning, and reflection into modular components, RAG-Reflect demonstrates that agentic reasoning can achieve fine-tuned-level accuracy while remaining lightweight, extensible, and adaptable. These findings offer new insights into designing agentic LLM workflows for software engineering and open a path toward self-improving, data-efficient reasoning systems. . 1. Introduction Stack Overflow (SO) is one of the most widely used platforms for software developers to seek and share programming knowledge. Jeff Atwood , the co-founder of SO, emphasized that the goal of SO is not merely to answer individual questions, but to “collaboratively build an artifact that will benefit future coders” – a vision that depends on continually maintaining and improving posts over time ( 39 ) . Over the years, developers have increasingly relied on SO not only to resolve specific bugs, but also to copy, adapt, and reuse code snippets directly in real-world projects ( 51 ; 57 ) . Prior work shows that SO content strongly influences how developers design and implement their systems, and that many questions and answers are revisited long after their initial posting ( 32 ; 47 ; 6 ) . Consequently, the long-term quality, correctness, and freshness of SO answers directly affect the reliability and maintainability of software that depends on them ( 58 ) . Stack Overflow allows its users to comment on a post (i.e., either a question or an answer). Comments often capture exactly the kind of time-sensitive knowledge that must be incorporated into answers. Consider the example in Fig. 1 . An older Python answer uses the compiler.parse() to get the abstract syntax tree of imported function. However, the compiler module is deprecated in the newer version of Python (i.e., Python 3). A user suggested to use ast.parse instead of compiler.parse by adding a comment to the answer. This concise remark provides three essential signals: (i) why the existing answer is now incorrect, (ii) what the correct fix is, and (iii) how to update the code. After reading this comment, an editor (or an automated system) can revise the snippet by replacing compiler.parse with ast.parse , restoring correctness for future readers. Figure 1 . An example of a comment that triggered the edit to a Stack Overflow answer. Although comments frequently identify real issues, most comments do not warrant edits. Many are conversational, vague, opinion-based, or unrelated to the code. Therefore, an essential prerequisite to any automated post-maintenance approach is the ability to determine whether a given comment should actually lead to an edit. We refer to this as the Valid Comment–Edit Pair (VCP) task. A comment–edit pair is valid if (i) the comment is relevant to the answer, (ii) it identifies a real issue or improvement, and (iii) the corresponding edit directly addresses that comment without introducing unrelated changes. Identifying valid comment-edit pairs is crucial because such pairs help users to understand the rationale for code changes. Comments therefore act as lightweight, conversational “micro-reviews” that can flag obsolete APIs, security vulnerabilities, incorrect assumptions, or missing edge cases in answers ( 56 ; 47 ) . In practice, however, this loop is often broken. Empirical studies show that many answers become obsolete without being updated ( 58 ) , and that comments frequently request improvements which never materialize in the corresponding posts ( 39 ; 42 ) . Sheikhaei et al. report that a substantial proportion of update request comments in SO answers remain unaddressed even after long periods of time ( 39 ) , while Soni and Nadi find that comment-induced updates are relatively rare and often delayed ( 42 ) . As a result, important technical insights remain buried in the comment section, which is partially hidden by default and harder to scan than the top-voted answer ( 56 ; 57 ) . This misalignment between where corrections appear (comments) and where most users look (answers) leads to a knowledge maintenance problem: developers can be misled by outdated or incomplete answers even when the correct information has already been discussed in comments ( 58 ) . This gap has motivated a growing body of work on automatic post updating and collaborative editing assistance in Q&A communities. Chen et al. propose deep learning techniques to support collaborative editing on Q&A sites, helping the community refine and improve posts ( 8 ) . Jin and Servant study the types of edits performed on highly answered SO questions ( 17 ) , while Li et al. and others analyze the trade-offs of importing Wikipedia-style collaborative editing mechanisms into Q&A platforms ( 23 ; 20 ; 15 ) . Focusing specifically on the link between comments and edits, Tang and Nadi mine SO’s revision history to build a dataset of answer comment–edit pairs and use it to recommend code maintenance changes ( 43 ) . Their approach relies on identifying cases where a comment is followed by an edit to the same answer and treating such pairs as supervision for learning to recommend similar edits. Soni and Nadi analyze comment-induced updates and characterize when and how comments trigger edits ( 42 ) . More recently, Mai et al. introduce the SOUP (Stack Overflow Post Updating) framework, which formulates the problem as two tasks: (1) Valid Comment–Edit Prediction (VCP), and (2) Automatic Post Updating (APU) ( 27 ) . SOUP fine-tunes a large language model (LLM), Code Llama ( 36 ) , on a curated dataset of 78k Java comment–edit pairs, achieving notable performance both on automatic metrics and in-the-wild submissions of generated edits to

Read the complete text