Audio Video Verbal Analysis (AVVA) for Capturing Classroom Dialogues

Vivek Upadhyay a and Amaresh Chakrabarti a · 2026

Read Audio Video Verbal Analysis (AVVA) for Capturing Classroom Dialogues by Vivek Upadhyay a and Amaresh Chakrabarti a (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-22043.txt.

Introduction

Upadhyay and Chakrabarti present the Audio Video Verbal Analysis framework, mixing qualitative reading with quantitative counts. The method uses triangulation across ten steps, making results solid. A validation plan tackles time-based study problems. These include rare-event caps, shaky numbers, and the Modifiable Temporal Unit Problem, where links found depend on watch length. Tests on 23 hours of classroom recordings show it works.

Catalog record

CREATORVivek Upadhyay a and Amaresh Chakrabarti a
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE103829
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.22043

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Audio Video Verbal Analysis (AVVA) for Capturing Classroom Dialogues Vivek Upadhyay a and Amaresh Chakrabarti a Abstract Background: The classroom discourse analysis has been transformed by the growing use of audio-video multimodal data, which demands analytical methods that balance interpretive depth with computational scalability. Methods: This study introduces the Audio Video Verbal Analysis (AVVA) framework, adapted from the Verbal Analysis method to integrate qualitative interpretation with quantitative modelling. Unlike fully multimodal learning analytics approaches, AVVA focuses on verbatim transcripts with essential interactional modalities. Findings: The framework embeds triangulation as a core design strategy across ten methodological steps, strengthening validity and analytical rigour. A comprehensive validation scheme addresses fundamental challenges in temporal observational research: Phi Ceiling for low-frequency variables (via Base-Rate Filtering), estimation uncertainty (via bootstrap confidence intervals), and the Modifiable Temporal Unit Problem, where measured associations depend on observational window size. Four-criterion stability assessment (sign consistency, confidence interval overlap, zero exclusion, magnitude stability) classifies variable pairs into interpretable patterns: grain-invariant, scale-specific, or multi-scale, etc. structures across temporal grain sizes. Its application to 23 hours of classroom recordings illustrates its practical viability and its potential to yield meaningful insights. Contribution: The framework thus provides a scalable pathway for transforming rich classroom discourse into analysable datasets. keywords Verbal analysis; Quantitative analysis; Classroom discourse; Triangulation; Audio-video data † † affiliation: a Department of Design and Manufacturing, Indian Institute of Science, Bengaluru, India 1 Introduction In the social sciences, video data have been extensively employed to examine teaching and learning environments ( 93 ; 109 ; 151 ; 154 ; 155 ; 184 ) , courtroom interactions ( 9 ) , and ethnographic settings ( 80 ) . Research within the medical sciences has predominantly utilised video-based observation for educational and training purposes, such as studies of doctor–patient communication ( 101 ; 142 ) , the instruction of medical personnel ( 176 ) , and investigations concerning surgical training and patient safety practices ( 76 ; 176 ) . Thus, video-based research enables us to move beyond verbal interactions, allowing the analysis of multiple dimensions of human behaviour and social activity across diverse contexts ( 151 ) . Video provides a deeper level of analysis due to the diversity of the data it captures. It enables the examination of interactions, simultaneous actions ( 136 ) , and bodily movements ( 14 ) . Therefore, audio–video based analysis is often regarded as a valuable enhancement to traditional transcript-based analysis, offering a more accurate account of events as they occurred ( 127 ) while preserving the expressive and contextual richness of communication ( 39 ) . Although using audio and video data can make analysis more complex at first, relying only on written transcripts may lead to a loss of important context in participants’ narratives ( 39 ; 159 ) . The growing recognition of the analytical potential of audio-video data underscores the need for a methodology that connects qualitative interpretation and quantitative analysis. Researchers typically begin with qualitative exploration, identifying impressions and emergent patterns, and then develop coding schemes to formalise these observations. Once coded, the data can be examined quantitatively, effectively transforming subjective impressions into operationalised, measurable constructs through the comparative analysis of code frequencies ( 31 ) . To address this need, ( 31 ) proposed Verbal Analysis, a methodological approach that offers systematic guidance for analysing verbal data by integrating qualitative interpretation with quantitative rigour, thereby reducing subjectivity in interpretation. While audio–video recordings capture the multimodal richness of human interaction, they also introduce considerable complexity to analysis ( 11 ) . In response, the present study introduces the Audio Video Verbal Analysis (AVVA) framework, designed to enable scalable, systematic verbal analysis alongside large audio-video datasets. The ten steps of the AVVA framework emphasise both methodological robustness and practical feasibility, with provisions for extending the encoded data to applications in machine learning and deep learning. Across these steps, various types of triangulation ( 47 ; 141 ) have been implemented as a design strategy. During the statistical validation of patterns, it was realised that variables with low frequencies of occurrence yield unreliable correlation measures ( 6 ) ; hence, the concept of a base-rate filter has been introduced. Bootstrap confidence interval analysis ( 53 ) quantifies estimation uncertainty, enabling researchers to differentiate patterns from sampling variability. During the grain-size experiments, challenges related to temporal aggregation, such as the Modifiable Temporal Unit Problem (MTUP) ( 29 ) , have been observed. MTUP describes how observed relationships vary with the chosen time window, and is analysed using four criteria to assess stability. Variable pairs are classified into interpretable patterns (grain-invariant, scale-specific, multi-scale, etc.) based on sign consistency, confidence interval overlap, zero exclusion, and magnitude stability across multiple temporal grain sizes. The AVVA framework was applied to collect approximately 3 months of audio-video data. Then, following all the steps of the AVVA framework, we encoded 23 hours of classroom recordings from science and mathematics lessons across grades 6–12 in an Indian school, for the variables Knowledge Dimension, Cognitive Process Dimension, Learning Theories, and 21st-Century Skills. The following section reviews the most common theoretical frameworks for gathering and analysing visual data and verbal analysis, evaluating their strengths and limitations. 2 Analysis of audio video data: An overview of relevant theories Actor Network Theory, Picture Theory, Grounded Theory and Multimodality Theory offer insights into visual data analysis ( 60 ) . However, not all of them focus specifically on video data or provide clear guidelines on how to organise, describe and interpret video content ( 60 ) . Actor-Network Theory (ANT) foregrounds the interplay between human and non-human entities within intricate networks, emphasising the complexity of their interrelations. However, it has been criticised for its conceptual ambiguity regarding how “actors” are to be defined, interpreted, and empirically examined ( 186 ; 182 ; 112 ; 100 ) . Similarly, Picture Theory advances the primacy of visual representation over linguistic expression ( 130 ) , offering valuable insights into visual analytical methodologies. Nevertheless, as its focus remains largely on static imagery, its application to dynamic video analysis remains limited. Grounded Theory derives theoretical insights directly from empirical data rather than from pre-existing theoretical frameworks, hence its name. Originally formulated by ( 70 ) , subsequent scholars extended the approach to encompass a postmodern dimension ( 23 ; 32 ) . The methodology is grounded in the assumption that reality consists of multiple constructions, with the researcher inherently connected to the knowledge being produced. This perspective supports a flexible set of principles and practices for theorising about how individuals interpret and construct their lived experiences ( 24 ) . Grounded Theory has had a significant impact across disciplines, including psychology, nursing, medicine, social work, the social sciences, and education ( 89 ; 175 ; 38 ) . Originating from the work of Gunther Kress, Multimodality Theory provides a critical framework for investigating social communication at the intersection of linguistic and visual modes ( 87 ; 105 ) . The theory explores how meaning is produced and interpreted through diverse communicative modes, such as speech, gesture, gaze, and visual imagery, beyond traditional written language ( 103 ) . Owing to its robust foundations for analysing both visual and non-visual semiotic resources,

Read the complete text