Multi-Nucleon Transfer Reactions and the Creation and the Evolution of the Compound Nucleus Preprint: NT@UW-26-13
Matthew Kafker, Aurel Bulgac · 2026
Read Multi-Nucleon Transfer Reactions and the Creation and the Evolution of the Compound Nucleus Preprint: NT@UW-26-13 by Matthew Kafker, Aurel Bulgac (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21845.txt.
Introduction
Kafker and Bulgac present the first use of an enhanced Generator Coordinate Method. It is applied to a grazing multi-nucleon transfer reaction: calcium-48 plus lead-208 near the Coulomb barrier. Unlike Time-Dependent Hartree-Fock or standard Generator Coordinate approaches, the enhanced method describes the birth and later life of the compound nucleus conjectured by Niels Bohr in 1936. It does so in a fully quantum microscopic picture. Its thermalization time beats the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis prediction by at least two orders of magnitude.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matthew Kafker, Aurel Bulgac |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26792 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21845
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Multi-Nucleon Transfer Reactions and the Creation and the Evolution of the Compound Nucleus Preprint: NT@UW-26-13 Matthew Kafker, Aurel Bulgac Abstract There is no microscopic quantum approach based on the many-body time-dependent Schrödinger equation which capable to describe the formation and the evolution of a compound nucleus. The most advanced microscopic approach developed so far to describe multi-nucleon transfer (MNT) reactions in complex nuclear systems (with total number of nucleons ≫ 100 \gg 100 ) is the time-dependent Hartree Fock (TDHF) mean field theory. In any mean field approach, however, the mean field is an expectation value of a quantum operator, thus classical in nature and unable to describe its quantum fluctuations, which are often expected to be crucial. Quantum fluctuations can be in principle be included in a configuration interaction (CI) framework, which in the case of reactions has to be implemented in the continuum. Here we describe the first such implementation within a novel extension of the well known Generator Coordinate Method (GCM), dubbed the enhanced GCM (eGCM), applied to the MNT reaction 48 Ca+ 208 Pb near the Coulomb barrier, which demonstrates major qualitative differences with either TDHF or GCM previous approaches. Ninety years ago Niels Bohr introduced based on qualitative arguments the concept of a compound nucleus Bohr 1936 ; Editorial 1936 , when the individualities of the two initial reaction partners are “irretrievably lost” and which have been widely used in nuclear physics ever since. No microscopic derivation based on the many-body Schrödinger equation was ever convincingly demonstrated however and the compound nucleus is simply a theoretical conjecture or surmise, amply used however in phenomenological approaches. In the editorial Editorial 1936 to the Bohr 1936 paper, the compound state is pictorially described as a superposition of a very large number of “simpler” many-body states, which basically form a continuum and the best guess anybody has currently is that the coefficients in this expansion are complex random numbers, according to the Wigner-Dyson surmise in Random Matrix Theory Mehta 1991 , which has been studied in the case of the nuclear shell-model Horoi et al. 1995 ; Zelevinsky et al. 1996 , and the relation between classical and quantum chaos in quantum systems with a relatively small number of degrees of freedom Bohigas et al. 1984 ; Bohigas et al. 1993 ; Berry 1991 ; Haake et al. 2018 , but never for nuclear reactions between heavy-ion nuclei or fission, processes which are strongly non-equilibrium time-dependent phenomena. The multi-nucleon transfer reactions are in a somewhat better position, as an incomplete theoretical framework exists, the Time-Dependent Hartree-Fock (TDHF) method. MNT reactions are the tool of choice to produce new nuclides. One of the most fundamental questions in physics is how many elements exists, or more precisely, how any isotopes exist on Earth or can be created, and what is the mechanism of their creation, in the laboratory and in Nature in the collisions of neutron stars and black holes and in supernova collapses Thoennssen 2004 ; Thoennessen 2013 ; Thoennessen 2024 ; Thoennessen 2015 . Elements from Z=1 (Hydrogen) to Z=92 (Uranium) were all discovered on Earth until 1939, with a very small number of exceptions, see wiki and also information about the Oklo natural reactor in Gabon. Concerning the question about how many isotopes exist naturally on Earth, the answer is about 339, including 251 primordial nuclides 251 stable isotopes and 88 radioactive isotopes. Among the rest of the predicted 7000-8000 possible isotopes Erler et al. 2012 ; Bulgac et al. 2018 , only about 3,000-3,300 have been created so far in many laboratories throughout the World lab ; Valverde and others 2026 . While most of these predicted isotopes are not naturally stable, their even rather short-time existence as an intermediate stage in the creation of other elements and isotopes is crucial in order to predict the abundances in the Solar system in particular. The overwhelming number of nuclei and isotopes not found naturally on Earth have been created in multi-nucleon transfer (MNT) heavy-ion reactions and the quest to identify the rest of them is an ongoing process. Unfortunately, there’s still no microscopic framework accurate enough to replace the many existing phenomenological models, which are based on various assumptions and are overwhelmingly classical in their character. These approaches have been discussed in the recent overview and in Refs. Loveland 2013 ; Hinde et al. 2021 ; Godbey and others 2025 ; Zhang et al. 2024 ; Li et al. 2024a ; Li et al. 2025 ; Fasoula and others 2026 , and where in many cases the typical phenomenological equation for production of a heavy reaction product is used Loveland 2013 ; Hinde et al. 2021 ; Godbey and others 2025 \displaystyle\sigma_{EVR}=\sum_{J=0}^{J_{\text{max}}}\sigma_{\text{cap}}(E_{\text{CoM}},J)P_{\text{CN}}(E^{*},J)W_{\text{sur}}(E^{*},J), (1) where the compound nucleus formation probability P_{\text{CN}} is always purely phenomenological with wide variations, which is the only quantity discussed in this work. The most sophisticated microscopic model existing in the literature is the time-dependent mean field theory in either its TDHF incarnation or in its extension, the time-dependent Density Functional Theory (TDDFT) Simenel 2010 ; Sekizawa and Yabana 2013 ; Sekizawa and Yabana 2016 ; Simenel et al. 2025 ; Simenel 2025 ; Wu et al. 2026 , an approach which is based on the adequacy of using mean field which is classical in character. This classical character of the mean field approximation can be corrected in a configuration interaction (CI) framework, of which the generator coordinate method (GCM) was believed for a long time to be a good solution Peierls and Yoccoz 1957 ; Griffin and Wheeler 1957 ; Reinhard et al. 1983 ; Reinhard and Goeke 1987 , although this claim was recently challenged with the introduction of the enhanced GCM (eGCM) framework Bulgac 2026 . The GCM Griffin and Wheeler 1957 is basically a CI-method based on linearly independent non-orthogonal system of ground state static Slater determinants with fixed shapes, which were assumed to describe an adiabatically evolving nucleus from the neutron capture to scission in induced fission Bohr and Wheeler 1939 ; Hill and Wheeler 1953 ; Griffin and Wheeler 1957 . In the case of heavy-ion reactions however the reaction fragments acquire significant excitation energy, not accounted for in an adiabatic evolution as Reinhard et al. 1983 noticed, which also happens in induced fission Bulgac et al. 2016 ; Bulgac et al. 2019 ; Bulgac et al. 2020 ; Bender and et al. 2020 . The corresponding many-body wave functions for the three approaches are defined as \displaystyle\Psi_{\rm GCM}(\xi_{1}\ldots\xi_{A})=\sumint_{Q}f(Q)\Phi(\xi_{1}\ldots\xi_{A}|Q), (2) \displaystyle\Psi_{\rm GCM_{R}}(\xi_{1}\ldots\xi_{A},t)=\sumint_{Q}f(Q,t)\Phi(\xi_{1}\ldots\xi_{A}|Q,t), (3) \displaystyle\Psi_{\rm eGCM}(\xi_{1}\ldots\xi_{A})=\sumint_{Q,\tau}f(Q,\tau)\Phi(\xi_{1}\ldots\xi_{A}|Q,\tau). (4) The difference between \Psi_{\rm GCM} and \Psi_{\rm GCM_{R}} is the time dependence of the Slater determinants in the latter Reinhard et al. 1983 . eGCM Bulgac 2026 on the other hand is a “bouillabaisse” of linearly independent non-orthogonal time-dependent Slater determinants generated with a large set of initial conditions and all mixed at many times along their TDDFT trajectories, and thus in the continuum limit a path integral Feynman 1948 along the TDHF trajectories Bulgac 2026 . We will demonstrate here that the enhanced GCM (eGCM) is indeed a many-body framework, which leads to a many-body wave functions of extreme complexity describing the collision of heavy ions in particular, which has the