Effects conditional on post-treatment events generated by independent mechanisms

Marco Piccininni 1 , Mats J. Stensrud 1 · 2026

Read Effects conditional on post-treatment events generated by independent mechanisms by Marco Piccininni 1 , Mats J. Stensrud 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21837.txt.

Introduction

Piccininni and Stensrud show that effects tied to post-treatment events can sometimes be found without measuring all shared causes of the event and the outcome. Simple comparisons tied to dropout, nonadherence, or truncation by death usually have no causal meaning, even when treatment is assigned at random. If treatment and other unmeasured outcome causes generate the post-treatment event through independent mechanisms, then conditional separable effects and survivor average causal effects can be found with no such adjustment. Examples cover truncating events, uneven nonadherence, and the birth weight paradox.

Catalog record

CREATORMarco Piccininni 1 , Mats J. Stensrud 1
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53711
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21837

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Effects conditional on post-treatment events generated by independent mechanisms Marco Piccininni 1 , Mats J. Stensrud 1 Abstract . In both observational studies and randomized trials, post-treatment events such as dropout, nonadherence, and truncation by death occur frequently. In some studies, conditioning on post-treatment variables is a deliberate strategy to isolate particular treatment effects on the outcome. However, naive comparisons of outcomes conditional on post-treatment events generally lack a causal interpretation, even when treatment is randomly assigned. There exist causal estimands that account for post-treatment events, including survivor average causal effects and conditional separable effects, but identification usually requires measurement of common causes of the post-treatment event and the outcome. In this article, we show that such measurements are not always necessary. Conceptually, what we require is that the treatment and other unmeasured causes of the outcome generate the post-treatment event through “independent mechanisms”. Then, conditional separable effects and survivor average causal effects are identified without adjustment for common causes of the post-treatment event and the outcome. We illustrate the results in studies with truncating events, differential nonadherence, and the birth weight paradox. 1. Introduction Many causal analyses require explicit consideration of post-treatment events. Even in randomized controlled trials (RCT), researchers need to account for individuals who drop out of the study or individuals who experience competing events. Sometimes conditioning on post-treatment variables is also a deliberate choice, for example, when attempting to isolate the direct effect of the treatment on the outcome. However, conditioning on a post-treatment variable leads to problems, even in randomized trials. To fix ideas, suppose the post-treatment variable is affected by treatment, and shares common causes with the outcome. Then, we expect a non-null association between the treatment and the outcome conditional on the post-treatment variable even if the treatment does not cause the outcome for any unit [ 9 ] . This phenomenon is often referred to as “collider bias” [ 16 , 11 ] or “collider stratification bias” [ 3 ] , referring to the graphical relationships of such a post-treatment variable in a causal directed acyclic graph (DAG) [ 3 , 11 ] . The birth weight paradox is a canonical example of a counter-intuitive finding attributed to such collider bias [ 10 , 16 , 30 , 3 ] . Several causal estimands have been proposed to target effects that explicitly account for post-treatment events [ 18 ] , such as separable effects [ 19 , 20 , 29 , 27 , 28 , 9 ] . Conditional separable effects can allow the outcome to be undefined if the post-treatment event happens [ 28 , 37 ] , which is, e.g., relevant in truncation by death settings. The existing identification results for these effects require measurements of confounders of the post-treatment variable and the outcome [ 28 , 14 ] or proxy variables [ 15 ] . In this work, we present new results ensuring that, in certain settings, conditional separable effects are identified even without measuring confounders of the post-treatment and outcome variable. This is possible when the mechanism through which treatment affects the post-treatment event is independent of mechanisms involving other causes of the outcome. The result builds on a known property of survival multiplicative models [ 9 , 8 ] . We present several illustrative examples: studies where participants experience truncating events, studies with differential non-adherence, and the famous birth weight paradox. Furthermore, we show that a similar result holds for the survivor average causal effect [ 21 , 22 , 28 ] , and we also draw connections to traditional instrumental variable analysis [ 2 ] . 2. Setup and notation Consider an experiment in which individuals are randomly assigned to treatment ( A=1 ) or control ( A=0 ). The outcome of interest is a numerical variable Y , and let D\in\{0,1\} be an indicator of a post-treatment event, possibly affected by A and affecting Y . Let U denote unmeasured common causes of D and Y , which might exist because only A is randomly assigned in our setting. The causal model is represented in the DAG in Figure 1 , and we will assume that the graph encodes a Finest Fully Randomized Causally Interpreted Structured Tree Graph model (FFRCISTG) [ 21 , 17 ] . A D Y U Figure 1. Causal directed acyclic graph representing the assumed relationship between treatment ( A ), outcome ( Y ), post-treatment variable ( D ) and potential common causes of D and Y ( U ). Dashed nodes represent unmeasured variables. In such a trial the average (marginal) effect of A on Y is easy to identify and estimate: Because there is no confounding the association between the treatment and the outcome represents the marginal effect [ 9 ] . Suppose that we are interested in isolating the effect of A on Y , for example, because the outcome Y is undefined when the post-treatment event D occurs. Several different causal effects have been suggested to quantify such effects, see for example [ 21 , 22 , 28 , 32 ] . The existing strategies require access to measurements of the common causes U or their proxies [ 15 ] . However, we will show that when D is generated in a particular way that can sometimes be justified in practice, certain causal effects can be estimated without adjusting for U . To formalize the causal parameters and clarify our assumptions we will rely on potential outcomes [ 9 ] . In particular, we will use notation Y^{a=a^{\prime}} to indicate the value of the outcome had, possibly contrary to fact, the treatment variable A been set to a^{\prime} . While we use the story of a randomized trial to simplify the exposition, our reasoning is easy to adapt to an observational study where our causal model is plausible after having restricted the analysis on some values of baseline covariates. 3. Independent mechanisms Consider a large RCT that compares quality of life at 6 months ( Y ) between individuals who undergo a plastic surgery ( A=1 ) and no treatment ( A=0 ). The surgery takes place immediately after randomization. Some participants died before 6 months of follow-up ( D=1 ). Thus, the outcome Y is only defined for individuals who survived until the end of the study ( D=0 ). The post-treatment event D here represents what is called a “truncating” event [ 28 ] , sometimes broadly classified as a “intercurrent event” [ 26 , 12 ] or a “competing event” [ 5 ] , although the precise definition of these terms is debated and varies across literatures [ 37 ] . The plastic surgery of interest is only intended to have aesthetic effects, but the procedure has some risks and leads to a higher mortality rate in the treatment arm compared to the control arm. We also expect unmeasured common causes ( U ) of death and quality of life (e.g., comorbidities, socioeconomic status etc.). The data generating process of this hypothetical trial is reflected in the causal DAG in Figure 1 . Without further assumptions, the comparison of outcomes under treatment and control, restricted to survivors, cannot be interpreted causally: Because D

Read the complete text