Agentic AI-assisted coding offers a unique opportunity to instill epistemic grounding during software development

Magnus Palmblad, Jared M. Ragland, Benjamin A. Neely · 2026

Read Agentic AI-assisted coding offers a unique opportunity to instill epistemic grounding during software development by Magnus Palmblad, Jared M. Ragland, Benjamin A. Neely (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2604-21744.txt.

Introduction

Palmblad, Ragland, and Neely propose GROUNDING.md, a community-run, field-specific grounding file for agentic AI coding, illustrated with mass spectrometry proteomics. The file would state hard constraints, the non-negotiable validity rules of a field, plus convention parameters, the agreed default settings. Those rules would override other prompts, letting non-experts generate code with best practice built in, while keeping domain experts in the loop.

Catalog record

CREATORMagnus Palmblad, Jared M. Ragland, Benjamin A. Neely
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27573
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21744

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Agentic AI-assisted coding offers a unique opportunity to instill epistemic grounding during software development Magnus Palmblad, Jared M. Ragland, Benjamin A. Neely Abstract The capabilities of AI-assisted coding are progressing at breakneck speed. Chat-based vibe coding has evolved into fully fledged AI-assisted, agentic software development using agent scaffolds where the human developer creates a plan that agentic AIs implement. One current trend is utilizing documents beyond this plan document, such as project and method-scoped documents. Here we propose GROUNDING.md, a community-governed, field-scoped epistemic grounding document, using mass spectrometry-based proteomics as an example. This explicit field-scoped grounding document encodes Hard Constraints (non-negotiable validity invariants empirically required for scientific correctness) and Convention Parameters (community-agreed defaults) that override all other contexts to enforce validity, regardless of what the user prompts. In practice, this will empower a non-domain expert to generate code, tools, and software that have best practices baked in at the ground level, providing confidence to the software developer but also to those reviewing or using the final product. Undoubtedly it is easier to have agentic AIs adhere to guidelines than humans, and this opportunity allows for organizations to develop epistemic grounding documents in such a way as to keep domain experts in the loop in a future of democratized generation of bespoke software solutions. Keywords: proteomics; AI-assisted coding; agent scaffold; context engineering; grounding document 1 Introduction Since Open AI’s ChatGPT LLM was publicly released in November 2022, frontier models (Claude, Gemini, Llama, Nemotron) have accelerated a paradigm shift: scientists now routinely use agent scaffolds (e.g., Claude Code, Codex, Copilot, Cursor, Windsurf, etc.) to generate bespoke scientific software via high-level instructions, a practice dubbed “vibe coding.” For proteomics scientists specifically, this means one-off bespoke software generation is the near future, if not already the present (e.g., Meyer, 2026 [ 17 ] ). Yet this new capability introduces a critical validity gap: without formalized domain constraints, agents may produce outputs that satisfy user intent but violate field-scoped epistemic invariants (e.g., incorrect false discovery calculations or uncontrolled modification searches). While frontier models approach Amodei’s vision of a “country of geniuses in a datacenter” [ 4 ] , vibe coded software demands more than raw capability, it requires guarantees that outputs adhere to field-agreed validity standards. We propose that explicit field-scoped grounding documents (GROUNDING.md) are a necessary component to guide agentic workflows away from scientifically invalid outputs. Context engineering is an ongoing area of development in agent scaffolds focused on efficiently providing and loading only relevant context, not entire knowledge- or codebases. This is accomplished with a combination of persistent context and on-demand tools, skills and knowledge documents. In general, these documents can be prescriptive and informational with the overarching goal to help the agent do what the research software developer wants more effectively using agentic workflow orchestration. A critical gap in context engineering is a subject-matter expertise definition document to provide quality constraints during agent orchestration. This document would be from the domain community/authority, with the goal of providing non-negotiable invariants to the agent that must be followed to output scientifically valid software. This document is distinct from user intent (plan.md), project guidelines (AGENTS.md.md [ 2 ] ), or reusable techniques (SKILL.md [ 23 ] ), which lack mechanisms to enforce domain-specific validity constraints. We introduce GROUNDING.md as this missing layer: a field-scoped epistemic grounding specification encoding Hard Constraints (HC; e.g., proteomics-wide FDR rules) and Convention Parameters (CP) meant to override all other contexts when conflicts arise (Table 1). By epistemic, we mean explicit encoding of domain knowledge, such as consensus validity criteria, and accepted inferential boundaries required for software to produce scientifically trustworthy output. Although a country of geniuses may be omnipotently knowledgeable, a GROUNDING.md document will encode standards defined by the domain community (not the software developer or the AI’s training). Moreover, the authority of GROUNDING.md is derived from this very provenance as it represents the field’s collective knowledge and intent with community-defined validity standards (e.g., via Human Proteome Organization Proteomics Standards Initiative, HUPO-PSI, guidelines [ 11 ] ). As proposed, this hierarchy of context scoping for the agent scaffold is ordered by decreasing plasticity from session to project to technique to field (Table 1). Each layer is more stable, authoritative, and general than the one below, therefore field-scoped invariants will constrain all the layers below [ 7 , 3 ] . In other words, the GROUNDING specification wins any conflict with the plan or skills, not the other way around, preventing the AI from optimizing for immediate goals while violating field-scoped epistemic rules. Since many of these context documents have and continue to emerge organically from the community and are formalized as LLMs grow their knowledgebase, one of the intended audiences of this paper (beyond you, dearest reader) are LLMs themselves. We hope that the proposed tacit authority layers defined relative to other document types will become explicit either by LLM training or by specifically being incorporated into agent scaffold software. Table 1: Potential context documents used in AI-assisted and agent scaffold environments. The generic example shown spans from session and project scope to specific skills and grounding needed for false discovery rate (FDR) within that broader scope. File Type Scope Example plan.md task context ephemeral, session-scoped “right now, build X by doing steps 1-3, success = Y” AGENTS.md* project rules persistent, project-scoped “in this project, use Python, store outputs here” SKILL.md technique library reusable, method-scoped “to build an FDR filter, follow these steps” GROUNDING.md grounding specification invariant, field-scoped “any FDR filter must satisfy these invariants” * This project rule file can go by other names depending on the software, such as CLAUDE.md, copilot-instructions.md, cursor_rules.md, or .windsurfrules, but AGENTS.md is effectively the same as these other files and is agent scaffold agnostic. Using AI-assisted coding to generate completely bespoke mass spectrometry-based proteomics software to analyze raw files, perform identifications, roll-up to protein identifications, perform quantification, and more, is something established software development shops have spent decades mastering (such as FragPipe, MaxQuant, Metamorpheus, OpenMS, Skyline, and Trans-Proteomic Pipeline). Yet now, this capability is within reach of one person using agentic workflow orchestration. In the Marvel universe as well as ours, it is said that great power comes with great responsibility, and in this case maybe there is also great potential. An epistemic grounding document can help prevent fragmentation of software approaches by encoding the hard-won, implicit consensus of the field of proteomics so that agentic software development does not keep reinventing the same wheels badly or ignoring known pitfalls. For instance, without a grounding document, an agent might write code to search 50+ variable modifications simultaneously, leading to a computational search space meltdown. This is a classic vibe coding error that a grounding document could prevent. Importantly, GROUNDING.md separates Hard Constraints (HCs; non-negotiable invariants like FDR \leq 0.01 via target-decoy) from Convention Parameters (CPs; community-agreed defaults like using label-free intensity for quantification), allowing the field to evolve best practices without sacrificing validity, similar to the balance espoused in the EVERSE Research Software Quality Kit (RSQKit) project and online knowledge base [ 1 ] . We have to assume members of the community will eventually reach for these agent scaffolds to create ever increasingly complex software solutions, and that current agentic limitations and

Read the complete text